5 ms·
> 2. No open source webmail servers that I've seen come close to Gmail's functionality, and I don't have time to write one that is. Obligatory comment pointing
by pavel_lishin 15y ago
> 2. No open source webmail servers that I've seen come close to Gmail's functionality, and I don't have time to write one that is.
Obligatory comment pointing out an opportunity for disruption, etc., why aren't we all millionaires., etc. etc.
- Arelius 15y agoI'm not sure that an open source webmail is an easy way to become a millionaire. =P
- mseebach 15y agoBecause not even "extremely security and privacy aware" hackers care enough to use it. That said, Zimbra is pretty bloody decent.
- rgrieselhuber 15y agoThe business model isn't there. I have yet to see a large group of consumers willing to pay for secure email and the only other alternative, advertising, leads to the exact same problem that you face with GMail.
- atdt 15y agoI would pay and so would many others.
- ansy 15y agoThat seems to imply you don't already. There are lots of paid email services that don't monetize user's emails. And many that are hosted outside the United States. For the extremely vigilant, there is always CounterMail https://countermail.com/ https://countermail.com/ The threat of email interruption and snooping can't be completely avoided. Undersea cables get cut, governments change, servers crash, data centers get raided, and companies disappear. At some point the data gets decrypted and everything is retrievable unless you are any extremely hard core PGP user. Even HushMail has to bend to the feds when it's all said and done. Even savvy people realize paranoia only gets you so far with email.
- mrschwabe 15y ago+1 for willing to pay for secure email.
- rdtsc 15y agoOk that's 2 customers who are also HNers. I think you'd need to do better than that. We are hardly a representative of the general consumer. There is another problem, US govt' need to get access all these messages. For example http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hushmail http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hushmail, people seemed to have signed up, but Hushmail was forced to provide plaintext messages to US govt upon request. So they sort of compromised their main selling point. That is probably the largest problem, you'd be stuck between a rock and a hard place. You either please your security conscious customers or please Uncle Sam. You can't please both.
- Zirro 15y ago"There is another problem, US govt' need to get access all these messages." You're assuming the service has to be located within the US. Why?
- rdtsc 15y agoIt doesn't have to, but unless it is located in Iran, NK or other US-unfriendly place, US govt can always pressure the local govt to pressure the local business to turn things over. I wouldn't, for example, count on countries like Switzerland, US is already getting to its banks to turn over US accounts, and is supposed to be one of the most independent and un-influenced countries. With the current legislation trend, eventually un-cooperative or "terrorist friendly" sites would just be filtered out and blocked, so you might have a hard time accessing your email. Some messages might never make it to you.
- pyre 15y ago> US govt can always pressure the local govt That depends. In some places, the privacy laws are better than in the US. You would just have to choose wisely.
- mike-cardwell 15y agoHushmail would disagree - https://www.hushmail.com/ https://www.hushmail.com/
- acavailhez 15y agoNice to know, thanks for the tip Did you try it and can compare it to gmail? Especially on: - linking other accounts (POP and IMAPS) - spam detection
- mike-cardwell 15y agoI actually host my own email. I developed an open source application for automatically encrypting all email with my public key as soon as it arrives, and I can't do this if somebody else hosts my email. You can read why and how here: https://grepular.com/Automatically_Encrypting_all_Incoming_Email https://grepular.com/Automatically_Encrypting_all_Incoming_E...
- erikano 15y agoBrilliant! Thank you for sharing the post and code. I'd be interested in hearing thoughts on how to make it searchable. If you don't index, searching will take quite some time. I guess the best thing to do would be to index each e-mail (keywords?) before it is encrypted and then encrypt the index itself as well. There is a problem with the keyword approach though - if the index encrypts the words but the "link" between message id and encrypted keywords is not encrypted, then an attacker who is in posession of one or several other message bodies in plain text can see correlations between the content of known and unknown message bodies.
- pyre 15y ago> advertising, leads to the exact same problem > that you face with GMail. Not necessarily. For some people that largest factor is that Gmail brings all of your email under US jurisdiction. It may be enough to just do advertising-funded Gmail clone that is solely based out of another jurisdiction. You may even be able to convince non-US businesses that this is a better alternative.
- joejohnson 15y agoI would gladly switch to a different webmail provider (and pay a decent amount for this service) if they could replicate all of the benefits of gmail.
- tonyarkles 15y agoAs a curiosity, what is "a decent amount"? $5/mo? $10/mo? More?
- joejohnson 15y agoI would probably pay $200-$300/year, so maybe $15-25/month if this hypothetical service could completely match gmail in features.
- tonyarkles 15y agoI'd be really curious to see what Google makes off the advertisements served up in Gmail, compared to this price.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoBy the way, I meant someone creating an application you could install locally, instead of just being a gmail clone hosting everyone's e-mail at once.