3 ms·
It’s the claim I’m making. As to the error—I don’t think anything is “trivial” here. In the EIP study, there were 181 tickets, with almost 6 million tweets “di
by rayiner 4y ago
It’s the claim I’m making.
As to the error—I don’t think anything is “trivial” here. In the EIP study, there were 181 tickets, with almost 6 million tweets “directly referenced in a ticket.”
If you flag a tweet and it’s removed, what happens to the associated tweets? I believe retweets and replies are removed too, right? If so, I don’t see how Hassan’s characterization is accurate either. EIP is shooting at the roots of information trees that branch out. They don’t need to shoot at all the leaves.
- tptacek 4y agoMohdi Hasan didn't have you on his show to confront you about your claims, because very few people know or care that you made them, unlike the claims Taibbi made, which went viral. The mistakes you're making in your analysis just aren't newsworthy.
- rayiner 4y agoThat’s kind of how online forums work, right? People make points such as “Party B’s rebuttal to Party A misses the larger picture”—without necessarily reiterating Party A’s point And as noted above—Hassan’s rebuttal seems equally if not more mistaken. Taibbi is being sloppy with the definition of “flag.” But the end result—in terms of what happens if a flagged tweet is removed—is closer to Taibbi’s characterization.
- tptacek 4y agoI can't tell which formulation I'm meant to be responding to at this point: is it Hasan's takedown of Taibbi's clearly-flawed reporting, or is it the way Hasan's takedown applies to your own beliefs?
- rayiner 4y agoYour original post implicated both points (the two thoughts separated by the semicolon). But I suspect we would make more progress talking about why you think Hasan’s response isn’t clearly flawed.
- tptacek 4y agoI only care that Taibbi is demonstrably wrong, because I have a very low opinion of Matt Taibbi's reporting (this is a hobbyhorse of mine; I don't even think he got the Vampire Squid story right.)