Totally agree about visualization, and that those authors are great advocates for it. Confidence intervals are definitely much more informative and intuitive th

Totally agree about visualization, and that those authors are great advocates for it. Confidence intervals are definitely much more informative and intuitive than p-values. Would the policy be "look at our confidence intervals later and then decide what to do"? One remaining issue is how to have consistent decision criteria, and to convey it ahead of time. Imagine a context with 10-50 teams at a company that run experiments, where the teams are implicitly incentivized to find ways to report their experiments as successful. Quantified criteria can be helpful in minimizing that bad incentive.