4 ms·
> By default, those requests are denied. That's not the case in Germany, at least.
by lxgr 4y ago
> By default, those requests are denied.
That's not the case in Germany, at least.
- RandomLensman 4y agoBanks don't need a SEPA mandate to allow a direct debit?
- germanier 4y agoThe SEPA mandate is between the parties in the transaction. While banks require their existence, it is usually not shared with the banks involved.
- RandomLensman 4y agoSo only a creditor ID is needed if someone has a set of IBANs and then things will be processed?
- germanier 4y agoA creditor ID and a direct debit agreement with some bank, yes. After you have those, (usually) the banks won't verify individual transactions.
- oblio 4y agoDo you mean that if I know a German bank account number I can just withdraw money for me? Be right back, asking some German friends for their bank account numbers. Jokes aside, you're probably wrong. There's NO way I can just pull money from their bank account just by knowing their bank account number.
- germanier 4y agoYes, if you set up a direct debit agreement with a bank you can do that. If you'd actually try what you suggest it will be revoked quickly and charges filed as your identity is known.
- lxgr 4y ago> Jokes aside, you're probably wrong. What GP says is accurate. > Do you mean that if I know a German bank account number I can just withdraw money for me? You most likely can't, because if you have to ask this you don't have an agreement with a SEPA Direct Debit originating bank that lets you :) And even if you decide to open one now: Given the risks involved for the originating bank, they will heavily scrutinize your business case and demand considerable collateral and/or payout time limits.
- summarity 4y agoYes, yes you can. Name + IBAN is all you need to enter even large recurring payments.
- lxgr 4y agoMost importantly, you need a bank that will let you submit any DD requests.
- oblio 4y agoI don't believe that. Let's say I have account number 1234 and my name is John Doe. You're telling me that, no strings attached, no repercussion, Mike Hacker can set up a large recurring payment from my account, without my approval? I'd need solid proof of how that would work.
- jon-wood 4y agoYes. That is a thing that can be done, here’s Stripe’s documentation on how to set up a Direct Debit mandate: https://stripe.com/docs/payments/payment-methods/bacs-debit?locale=en-GB https://stripe.com/docs/payments/payment-methods/bacs-debit?... The thing that’s being missed here is that direct debits can be disputed in the same way a credit card payment can, and by default the customer wins. Their money will be refunded immediately by the bank, who will then go after you to get it back.
- oblio 4y agoOk, that's both interesting, slightly unsettling, but also doesn't really fall under: > You're telling me that, no strings attached, no repercussion This bit: > by default the customer wins. Their money will be refunded immediately by the bank, who will then go after you to get it back. sounds a lot to me like repercussions :-)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- lozenge 4y agoAs a person you can only send them money. As a business you can initiate a direct debit which withdraws money. However you are attesting that they signed a direct debit agreement with you and provided their account number and agreed on the amount to pay. This is the same as a credit card - you can charge any card with just the number and a couple of basic details, however if there's a complaint "I found these CC details on a random website" isn't accepted, you need to show the card holder agreed to the charge. If you don't provide the evidence the transaction is reversed.
- oblio 4y agoThat's a distinction without a difference. I obviously don't care about people sending me money, I care about people requesting money from me. Individuals can't do it and business can only <<ask>> for money, that's different.
- jeltz 4y agoThat is usually not how credit cards work anymore. Sure, you can try to charge any card but if it is issued by a European bank it will very likely be denied and you will be asked to do a Strong Customer Authentication. Same applies to SEPA direct debit. Here in Sweden most (all?) banks requires the customer to sign digitally before any direct debit mandate is created.