3 ms·
The calculations on that page are not correct. First, the average car occupancy is not 1, it's 1.5 on average. Second, the lane capacity is 1900 cars per hour (
by cyberax 4y ago
The calculations on that page are not correct. First, the average car occupancy is not 1, it's 1.5 on average. Second, the lane capacity is 1900 cars per hour (that's maximum at around 45 mph, btw). So this works out to 8550 people per hour.
A realistic scenario for commuter trains (that would replace a freeway) is 1 train every 10 minutes, and even this is pretty tough. So you have 6 trains per hour, and to match the throughput you'd need 1425 people per train.
Most train platforms are maxed out at well below 10 cars (Caltrain is 6 cars), 20 car trains are just pure nonsense for commuting. So for 10 car trains it'll be around 150 people per car. Caltrain cars are 130 seats per car ( https://www.greencaltrain.com/2014/05/keeping-up-with-caltrain-capacity-needs/ https://www.greencaltrain.com/2014/05/keeping-up-with-caltra... ), with another 40 standing places.
Basically, a perfectly run commuter train system is _just_ barely comparable with a regular 6-lane freeway.
Sorry train fans, but trains are not that great for commuting.
- judge2020 4y agoCorrection, trains specifically. Subways and light rail are immensely higher ROI (as in, benefit vs cost) within a city since it effectively forces people close together, while a 6-lane-on-each-side highway isn't economically feasible for all of the high-traffic areas.
- richardw 4y ago> Sorry train fans, but trains are not that great for commuting. Quick comparison: more people (3.6m) go through Shinjuku Station in Tokyo than the daytime population of Manhattan, at 3.1m. Only half of those travel into Manhattan, using all modes of transport. When things get extreme it’s hard to just double the road network and parking into a single location. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shinjuku_Station https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shinjuku_Station
- cyberax 4y agoThis station is served by 12 lines. So presumably that's 24 tracks. This means that one track would need to carry a bit more than 150000 people a day on average. A 6-lane freeway can carry around 100000 people a day. As a sanity check, the infamous Katy Freeway carries 350000 cars a day, for about 600000 people. It's 14 main travel lanes wide. So yep, trains are not that efficient compared to freeways.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agothat's not 24 tracks. you need more tracks at the station since the trains are stopped, but you can probably do that with 4 to 6 tracks for the portions where the trains are up to speed.
- richardw 4y agoSo you'd need 6 of those highways converging on the middle of a city to compare to Tokyo's single train station. To make it really fun to solve, no rational city would allow that disastrous use of above-ground land, the parking for another 2m cars would be an engineering feat of note and you're dragging millions of tons of steel around for no reason. We haven't begun on emissions or need for fuel stops for those 2m cars. Oh, and that's not the entirety of the Tokyo metro population, which is ~37m. The entire of Texas is ~29m-ish and that's spread out so far and wide they can afford to fuck around with 14 lane highways. The scale and solution are incomparable.
- ProfessorLayton 4y agoBART has a capacity of 200 passengers per car in their legacy fleet, 241-256 for their new fleet, and regularly has 10 cars per train during peak hours [1] and travels 80mph. [1] https://wbcapp.oaklandnet.com/cs/groups/public/documents/procedure/b2fr/mdcy/~edisp/oak072793.pdf https://wbcapp.oaklandnet.com/cs/groups/public/documents/pro...
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Most train platforms are maxed out at well below 10 cars (Caltrain is 6 cars) > a perfectly run commuter train system is _just_ barely comparable with a regular 6-lane freeway Also look at any major route in Britain, like Manchester to London, no 6-lane highways anywhere in sight. You are comparing some weak-ass train with a giant highway. It's easy to extend a rail platform to accomodate more train cars - you just need to knock down a few buildings in a local area. Now try widening a 3-lane highway into a 6-lane, that could be hundreds of building and NYMBY's across three cities.
- cyberax 4y ago> It's easy to extend a rail platform to accomodate more train cars - you just need to knock down a few buildings in a local area. Do you know any actual transit systems that run 20-car trains?
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoAllegedly the Eurostar, which links Paris to London, does: "Inter-Capital" sets consisting of two power cars and eighteen passenger carriages. These trains are 394 metres (1,293 ft) long and can carry 750 passengers: 206 in first class, 544 in standard class > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurostar#:~:text=These%20trains%20are%20394%20metres,class%2C%20544%20in%20standard%20class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurostar#:~:text=These%20train.... I can't find info on the upcoming HS2. However I do testify that extremely long trains are common in Eastern Europe, Russia, India, etc. they might not be high-speed but they do move a lot of people at once.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y ago20 car trains are a distraction here the important correction is 150 passengers per train is way low. 250 is common and going higher (e.g. double decker) is pretty easy if you need to