3 ms·
How did you prompt it to play tic-tac-toe? I'm surprised that didn't work, it feels like something it should be able to handle really well. Hangman and stone-p
by simonw 4y ago
How did you prompt it to play tic-tac-toe? I'm surprised that didn't work, it feels like something it should be able to handle really well.
Hangman and stone-paper-scissors though are entirely unsuited to a language model, at least one with a chat interface like ChatGPT, because they both require it to be able to store a secret. ChatGPT has no ability to do this: each time it returns a response by evaluating the previous conversation.
You could build a system that COULD play those games via an LLM but you'd have to write extra code to do it.
- ollien 4y agoWell, for hangman at least, if the human knows the secret, it should be possible for the LLM to handle that, no?
- simonw 4y agoOh right - yeah, that would work great. I'd be very surprised if ChatGPT couldn't do that.
- ollien 4y agoI asked Bing AI > I am thinking of a five letter word. You guess the word letter-by-letter (in the style of the game hangman) as many times as you like, but may only guess incorrectly six times. Please begin guessing > Sure! Let’s start with the first letter of the word you’re thinking of. What is it? lol but it did get the picture after that. It does seem to be very fixated on guessing vowels though, after it has already exhausted all of them.
- simonw 4y agoIt took a bit of prompt engineering but this worked for me in ChatGPT v4: > Let's play hangman. I have thought of a 8 letter word, you have to guess it one guess at a time. You get to draw an ascii-art hangman too. Then YOU guess with a letter and I'll tell you if you were right or not. I won't give you a category clue. Start by drawing the hangman in a code block and then guessing a letter. The same prompt against 3.5 didn't work - it didn't seem to be guessing likely next letters, and it couldn't keep track of how many body parts it should have drawn on the diagram.
- swilliamsio 4y agoOn the free ChatGPT, I got it to play hangman with the prompt: > Let's play hangman. I'm thinking of a word: _______ It made a variety of guesses generally in the form of > Based on the pattern you provided, I will guess the letter "I". Is there an "I" in the word? My response was either "No [letter]" or an updated state of the word: "_RE_IE_".