3 ms·
Calorie Restriction with or Without Time-Restricted Eating in Weight Loss
- pknomad 4y agoPaper pretty much confirms that calorie differential is what matters the most when it comes to weight loss. I think it'll be interesting to see the results (especially in terms of compliance) when you also add timing of eating (IF) and source of nutrients.
- aitchnyu 4y agoI tried IF since allegedly cells are flushed and repaired in fasting mode, and it makes fat more "mobile" instead of untapped. Are those claims debunked yet?
- paulpauper 4y agoCICO is hard to beat. People trying to come up with hacks but they fall short. You cannot beat thermodynamics. Surplus = weight gain. Not surprising to me . Of course, if one or two meals a day helps you adhere to a diet, go ahead. All diets entail having to change this differential to work, to undo the surplus, so either the input or output side of equation.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI don't think anyone's argued seriously about whether or not a calorie deficit causes weight loss, mostly I've seen that CICO doesn't actually help people perform the calorie deficit part and is instead primarily used for people to be smug about the struggles fat people have about losing weight.
- dangus 4y agoThe fact that people on Internet forums can be smug is entirely independent to whether or not following the CICO principle is effective. In other words, when you say "CICO doesn't actually help people perform the calorie deficit part" that's observably false. We can observe that tracking calories has helped a non-zero number of people achieve calorie deficit. I think what's more important for anyone looking to lose weight is understanding that most people will at some point gain that weight back. To me, it's important for people on the quest to lose weight to understand that gaining weight back isn't a a personal failure, it's expected and statistically likely. The only failure you can make is not trying again. https://health.clevelandclinic.org/why-people-diet-lose-weight-and-gain-it-all-back/ https://health.clevelandclinic.org/why-people-diet-lose-weig...
- senttoschool 4y agoIF doesn't help people perform the calorie deficit part either. You can eat way more calories than you can burn off during eating periods. Everything comes down to discipline. I don't do IF. I just do calorie counting with an app. In other words, I just do CICO. This research is a validation that I don't need to do IF to lose weight. It feels smarter and better to just eat at normal times and then count the calories. Less social life impact. Less hunger pains. Actual proof that you're eating fewer calories than you need.
- vostok 4y agoI find that IF actually has less effect on my social life. I can just go to a barbecue on the weekend and eat whatever if that's my one meal for the day. I find it much harder if I have to plan to leave room for other meals.
- matt-attack 4y agoI think the reason IF is often successful is simply because it indirectly results in reduced caloric intake simply by cutting out what would have been useless meals/snacks. For example it just encourages you to eat less by eliminating midnight snacks, popcorn during movie night, or useless bowls of cereal at breakfast.
- DangitBobby 4y agoThe graphs tell a slightly different story. I was hoping to find their explanation about why there's no significant difference when clearly TRE was better for about 6 months and then leveled off slightly but still about 25% more effective in the end.