2 ms·
Ok, so, at 14:45 in the video she shows some spacetime diagrams. The "normal" interpretation is that the distortions shown, including the event-ordering flip sh
by ben_w 4y ago
Ok, so, at 14:45 in the video she shows some spacetime diagrams. The "normal" interpretation is that the distortions shown, including the event-ordering flip she shows, represent reality. Relativistic motion is actual time dilation and not merely your perception of someone else's motion. This is backed up by evidence in a lot of extreme cases.
I don't have the skills to know if one is really "allowed" to say that there exists some frame of reference that is preferred or if that breaks something else, but I think that any such frame where time must always go forwards would do what she's saying here.
Possibly.
Unfortunately, I know this is an area where not only does my intuition often fail me, but where I can easily have the wool pulled over my eyes with plausible sounding but erroneous maths.
- hgsgm 4y ago> Relativistic motion is actual time dilation and not merely your perception of someone else's motion. What distinction are you drawing? What is the difference between "actual" and "what [every] observer observes? Part of the concept of relativity is that there is no preferred clock. That's why it is called "relativity".
- ben_w 4y agoAlice, Bob, initially at rest, Bob accelerates to relative motion of 0.5c, turns around, returns, decelerates to rest with respect to Alice, both agree Bob experienced less time. No clock is preferred, but the dilation is real. That the Alcubierre metric is supposed to avoid dilation made me ask ages ago if it also avoided the usual paradoxes, but everyone I asked insisted it didn't help at all with that.