3 ms·
What's special about RISC-V? How does companies not having to pay for using an ISA in a processor having anything to do with whether they implement other proces
by charcircuit 4y ago
What's special about RISC-V? How does companies not having to pay for using an ISA in a processor having anything to do with whether they implement other processors inside of their processor?
- snvzz 4y agoBeing compatible with the standard ISA is itself a benefit.
- anonym29 4y agoIt's not that RISC-V guarantees truly transparent firmware and microcode; as you correctly point out, it does not. What RISC-V offers is the possibility of truly transparent firmware and microcode. This comes as a refreshing alternative to x86, which guarantees that firmware and microcode, including those of security coprocessors (e.g. Intel CSME & AMD ST, formerly ME and PSP) will not be transparent.
- wmf 4y agoARM offers the same possibility but there's like one SoC that's fully transparent.
- anonym29 4y agoI am not as well-versed in the specifics of ARM's TrustZone as I am with Intel CSME and AMD ST, but I understand many of the people uncomfortable with the latter two are uncomfortable with the former as well. I do not believe it comes with the same capabilities as CSME or ST (PSP), but I do know that earlier versions of PSP were implemented using an ARM TrustZone core. That said, I need to do a lot more reading and research on it before forming more substantial positions on it.
- wmf 4y agoAFAIK you can build an ARM SoC without TrustZone (or without using TrustZone for anything) if you want.
- 7to2 4y agoARM offers the same possibility.. in exchange for a fee and a stack of NDAs. Competition and openness is how we should deal with this disease.