4 ms·
Because land is actually real, physical, naturally finite. It's actual property in the simplest most intuitive sense. Intellectual property is just the whole wo
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
Because land is actually real, physical, naturally finite. It's actual property in the simplest most intuitive sense. Intellectual property is just the whole world pretending it can't produce an unbounded number of copies at negligible costs. If we had planetary scale Star Trek replicators there'd be no need to have physical property either.
- katbyte 4y agoland is also usually taxed. Squatting on it, at least the most desired/valuable kind, has a cost.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoGood point.
- xref 4y agoHey at first blush I’m really liking the idea of taxing copyrights and patents, just like land. If you want to maintain them over the duration allowed you pay yearly tax, just like property. Wether it is valuable or not, wether you monetize it or not, the tax is the tax. You want the ongoing protections the legal system affords your copyright? Pay the tax. to avoid payment you can sell or renounce the copyright/patent. For random “copyrighted” content like say my blog scrawlings, it would by default be under a CC attribution license unless I paid copyright tax on the content. Ie: default open not default closed. Curious if any country does this?
- untangle 4y ago> taxing copyrights and patents It's an interesting point. I believe (chatGPT4 agrees) that taxes on IP occur via licensing deals, on transactions, and/or through registration fees. But not through anything resembling a RP wealth tax. There are probably some corner cases though.
- bazoom42 4y agoThis is a good argument for making real estate ownership temporary and non-inheritable. For a finite resource like land, ownership is literally depriving the land from everybody else. Ownership of creative works you create yourself does not deprive anybody else of anything, so is less problematic.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoNo, it's not a good argument for that. Hell yes my ownership of my house deprives others of access to it. Obviously. That's by design and absolutely how things are supposed to be. And you'd have to be a literal communist to believe otherwise. People cannot have my house because I'm living in it, and my family will get my house in the future when I die because they will also be living in it. Because land is real property. Unlike the made up BS that is intellectual property which is just like trying to own numbers.