3 ms·
I do go over it in the linked entry. It's not a particularly long or technical article. Basically, it's the social structure that is built around a community's
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
I do go over it in the linked entry. It's not a particularly long or technical article.
Basically, it's the social structure that is built around a community's Raison D'etre, or reason for existence.
This is schools, housing, curriculum (there's a reason that RIT is based in Rochester, for example), as well as oral and learned tradition.
"Tribal knowledge" is a dirty word to efficiency nerds, but that doesn't change the fact that it exists, and is highly effective, for a reason.
There are entire districts, known for the finest $WHATEVER. Lübeck, Germany, is known for marzipan (I don't really like it, but lots of others do). Bordeaux is known for wines and cooking, Afghanistan has some of the best opium, etc. Some of these are due to climate and soil, but others can be lost to other areas (Sonoma, for instance).
They may have great soil, but they also have great farmers, who have been handing their skills down, for generations, etc.
Once that is gone, there ain't no making new ones.
- enraged_camel 4y ago>> Once that is gone, there ain't no making new ones. You haven't made a single compelling argument as to why we cannot also rebuild social infrastructure.
- elcritch 4y agoI believe the missing part is that it takes a lot of work to create that social network. Without a driving economic reason or lots of time and regional interest (ie generations) it would be difficult to redevelop. Much of this social capital requires lots of folks being interested in something since they were young and "playing" at it. Play is an important way to learn and understand it. Also I believe social capital requires adults to respect and take interest in the item, as children often take their cues from that. That said, I wonder if industrial clothing manufacturing requires that much social infrastructure? That industry seems to move very couple of decades to a new country with the cheapest labor.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> You haven't made a single compelling argument as to why we cannot also rebuild social infrastructure. ...and I don't have to. Have a nice Easter/Passover!
- somewhereoutth 4y agoExactly. And it is not just knowledge, it's not even just ways of thinking - it's ways of being. For our own sanity we have to believe we have at least some handle on the reality unfolding around us - but even a cursory examination shows this cannot be true. Our lives are so brief, so localised, when set against the totality of all that is, was, and will be. Instead, as we shape the world, the world shapes us, and it is this emergent collective consciousness that conspires to give us all that we have.
- xyzzy123 4y agoI think of ASML sometimes and its relationship to hundreds of years of Dutch work in optics.
- jen20 4y ago“Efficiency nerd” is another word for sociopath, right?!
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoNot sure I'd go quite that far, but wouldn't surprise me to see an overlap in the ol' Venn diagram...