9 ms·
Andrew Huberman Has Supplements on the Brain
- pedalpete 4y agoIt's a bit of a hit-job on Dr Huberman, and the final sentence is probably too harsh, comparing Huberman's support of supplementation to Andrew Wakefield and the Autism-Vaccine lie. However, I am surprised by the state of the supplements market, and that there is no way to reliably know what you are taking. Athletic Greens doesn't even try to suggest what amounts of different vitamins you get in a serving, apparently they just say it is a "proprietary blend". There is a "Know Drugs" platform for tracking safety of recreational drugs, I believe another platform exists, I'm not sure about the space as I'm not a user. I'm surprised a similar platform doesn't exist for supplements. How difficult is it to test for the amounts of vitamins and minerals in a supplement, say if you had access to a university laboratory?
- prepend 4y agoI’ve listened to Huberman for a few dozen hours and think he has useful info. But his supplement talk triggered my spidey sense, especially with his sponsors. I remember he was talking about how ashwaganda (or something like that) wasn’t good to take long term because of cortisol suppression and then added that the amount found in athletic greens is ok as it’s not high enough. I thought that was an odd comment and then later in the episode heard an add for athletic greens. I think he means well, but I don’t think I can trust his advice because of all his supplement advertisers. I had a loved one with a rare condition and would talk with their doctor about lots of different things to try as I was desperate, the doctor said something that sticks with me “look, these aren’t harmful unless you consider the cost of spending hundreds or thousands per month for supplements harmful.” Athletic greens is $100/month/person. It’s not bad for you, but that’s a lot of money. Couple it with fancy fish oil, lots of resvetrol, NAD, and all the other stuff and you’re looking at a high bill. Huberman isn’t a doctor, but it’s expensive to experiment with all the stuff he talks about. All that being said, he’s still in my podcast feed and I listen to an episode every once in a while. So I think he had good info, but just requires lots of confirmation and research. I think it’s tough for podcasters in this space to make money because naturally supplement people want to advertise. And the targeted ads for Huberman listeners are super frequent and full of all sorts of bio hacks.
- digdugdirk 4y agoI honestly think your last two paragraphs nail it. From my experience he's quite clear about the marginal benefits from supplementation, and as long as he doesn't cross that line I'm perfectly happy to have him serving as a sort of one man literature review. I also get the impression that his audience is a fairly affluent one, so I don't even have an issue with the price level of the supplements he's advertising. So far they seem legitimate (again, even if they're wildly expensive for any associated benefits) so as long as they don't cross into snake oil territory, I see zero issue with any of it.
- deadbolt 4y agoThe website https://www.consumerlab.com/ https://www.consumerlab.com/ might be close to what you're looking for, though it does require a subscription. I started researching things there after learning that many powdered protein supplements contained high levels of heavy metals.
- fergbrain 4y agoSeattle Public Library gives you free access if you’re a member. I suspect other libraries do as well! https://www.spl.org/online-resources/consumer-and-diy https://www.spl.org/online-resources/consumer-and-diy
- moosedev 4y agoThanks for this - you inspired me to finally get a library card! Unfortunately I can’t find anything on ConsumerLab about my go-to unflavored whey protein powder (Natural Factors). I guess no news is better than bad news.
- devinmcafee 4y agoI personally use Labdoor: https://labdoor.com/rankings/protein https://labdoor.com/rankings/protein They do independent testing for supplements and provide rankings based on detected ingredient, heavy metals and adulterants per serving (I linked protein but they also test other types of supplements). My only complaint is that their database is limited so you may not find the brand you are looking for.
- leetrout 4y ago> Athletic Greens doesn't even try to suggest what amounts of different vitamins you get in a serving, apparently they just say it is a "proprietary blend". I've never used athletic greens but I've heard of them from podcast ads. The nutrition panel is on their site - the direct link is https://images.prismic.io/athletic-greens-new/293c294b-4f3f-4fb1-8c28-bf124b4dc2ac_AG1_ingredients_030322.png?q=80&auto=format&w=1678 https://images.prismic.io/athletic-greens-new/293c294b-4f3f-... Were you talking about something else or just didn't see the link to the details?
- pedalpete 4y agoThanks for pointing that out. I had seen a review on Youtube and the reviewer was saying AG didn't list the amounts, perhaps it was an older review, or he was full of it. I didn't look deeper myself.
- fundad 4y agoHow do you feel about Dr. Oz?
- pedalpete 4y agoNot good. Why?
- fundad 4y agoThis is the first I'm hearing about Huberman his entertainment career compared to his professorial career sounds like Dr. Oz. Oz promotes the wildest products as part of the grift but by all accounts isn't bad at being a physician (or escaped accountability thus far).
- pengaru 4y ago> Dr Huberman He's not an M.D.
- pedalpete 4y agoBut don't PhDs still get labelled as Dr?
- pengaru 4y agoNot generally in casual conversation, and certainly not in a medicine-adjacent/overlapping subject matter where it creates substantial confusion as to a person's authoritative clinical capacities. This is an ongoing game played by "doctors" of chiropractic misleading the American public to perceive them as equivalent to M.D. Doctors. It's a cheap way to gain clout, but an M.D. is a professional doctorate, a PhD is not, the distinction matters here. Beware of non-M.D.'s insisting on a Dr. prefix, or folks citing these people as such especially when it serves to bolster their medicine/health/nutrition claims. It at least suggests a desperation for authority. Huberman's at best prefixed as Professor here IMO. Even that's being generous since he's an associate professor according to his wikipedia page.
- jbm 4y agoThe gotcha / sneering style harms something I otherwise agree with. For example, Ashwagandha is something I've been putting into daal curry for years; it has been a part of Indian cuisine forever. Not that you'd know by the style it is conveyed in; there must be a word for this style of dishonesty, where you purposely hide context to inflate the danger. It's a shame because most supplements are clearly not necessary.
- kranner 4y agoI've lived in India almost all my life and I've never heard of Ashwagandha being part of any of the traditional culinary systems of India. Cooking with Ashwagandha seems to be a recent Internet trend exclusively. Traditionally, as Ayurvedic medicine, it would either be swallowed in powder form with milk or ghee, or brewed as a tea/kadha. I've grown up eating dal everyday, and we really don't put any Ashwagandha in it.
- ewanmcteagle 4y agoAgree. Maybe people are thinking of asfoetida. A very different thing.
- zachruss92 4y agoMy response to this is rather neutral. As a long-time follower of Huberman, I can attest that he consistently delivers valuable information. Each episode is akin to a college-level biology lecture. When you closely listen to his advice (and I'm paraphrasing), he suggests first getting your life in order (focusing on proper light exposure, sleep, exercise, and diet), followed by seeking behavioral modifications, and only then considering supplementation or pharmaceuticals. The critique regarding his sponsors is legitimate. However, one should consider that producing this content is not free for Huberman, as he spends at least ten hours a week of his own time working on it, and it's reasonable for him to want to monetize his efforts. That being said, I did try AG1 based on his recommendation (he claims to have used it daily since 2012). My significant other and I tested it for a month (costing over $160) and experienced no noticeable improvements. It's worth noting that I already take Spirulina and other supplements, so my experience may be an outlier, but neither of us felt any tangible benefits.
- adamgordonbell 4y agoThis article feels a bit harsh. I recently started listening to him and my main complaint about him is that he can be boring. 4 hours about breathing and the correct way to breathe and I didn't feel like I understood what to take away from it at the end. I would need to go back and listen again and take detailed notes. The thing he lacks is the ability to summarize. I think he himself is a person who takes a lot of supplements and is looking for an edge in whatever way it comes. Maybe breathing a special way or ice showers or whatever. All that stuff feels like way past the basics that most listeners need to learn about. The best stuff I learned from him was basics, like alcohol is never good for you. And it's bad in low amounts in lots of subtle ways. That message will improve lives. I hope he doesn't hit the doctor Oz spiral but it doesn't seem like he has so far.
- lez 4y agoBreathwork is something that you should experience yourself to know what's in it for you. Notes won't help. Practice for 3-6 months, then listen to the podcast again. Then, you can relate Huberman's words with your own experience, and not be bored at all.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago> alcohol is never good for you This episode, # 86, changed my life. I’ve not had a single drink of alcohol since i listened to it in august 2022. I don’t expect I will again. SCARED STRAIGHT. > thing he lacks is the ability to summarize Yes! I have a love/hate relationship with him because of this. Many of his episodes could be half the length, so i just do not listen to him very often. The alcohol episode is an exception and if a friend hadn’t recommended it, I would have missed it.
- AraceliHarker 4y agoIf he was sponsored by an alcohol company, wouldn’t he start saying that alcohol is actually good for your health?
- pas 4y ago
- inerte 4y agoHuberman recently interviewed someone that I consider to be the real deal, Andy Galpin, and it was a very interesting series of 6 episodes. I don't listen to a lot of Huberman, but during these long conversations I've learned about the incredible amount of things he take. Of special note was a "sleep cocktail", a mix of several supplements. Stuff pre and post workout, for this function or this other function, I don't know if it was every cataloged but I wouldn't be surprised if we're talking about ~30 different supplements. Anyway, Huberman and Galpin were talking, and Huberman super interested in all sorts of things Galpin would recommend, and Galpin then says "My objective is to get you OFF supplements long term, fixing the foundational problems instead of the symptoms" - I found some transcription online here https://podscript.ai/podcasts/huberman-lab-podcast/guest-series-dr-andy-galpin-optimal-nutrition-supplementation-for-fitness/ https://podscript.ai/podcasts/huberman-lab-podcast/guest-ser... around the 01:53:06 mark. I think it's easy to miss in a +3 hour conversation about supplements someone actually saying: Long term you shouldn't need this stuff. So friendly reminder how supplementation is one of last things you should consider when trying to improve performance. PS: Athletic Greens (which I tried for 3 months) is more like 99 since at least for California you need to add +20 for shipping. Interesting, I decided to try based on this review https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjJOo78NiFI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjJOo78NiFI - and stopped because it didn't do much for me.
- jvican 4y agoSeconded. I've been following Andy Galpin for four years; I can attest that his knowledge is unparalleled. He's one of the worldwide experts in physical science and the coach of many elite athletes: the best definition of an applied scientist. His guest video series with Huberman is amazing. He's taught me so much about the do's, don'ts, and trade-offs in training effectively and staying healthy. His delivery is immaculate and you get away with understanding what's the actual truth (which in a field as full of myths as exercise science is a must). I'm a semi-professional powerlifter and I apply his knowledge every day. If you're not following him, you're missing out.
- tinyhouse 4y agoI'm not taking supplements beyond vitamin D and B12, but what you just quoted could be said on anything really. It's always best long term to fix the problem instead of the symptom, but reality is that it's very hard for many people. Why people taking statins instead of living super healthy life so that their cholesterol levels are normal? Just one example...
- lez 4y agoThe writer of the article clearly wants to put negative light on Huberman and in general frightens readers away from taking responsibility for their own health. The tone is suggesting not to waste money on vitamins or minerals or supplements, unless proven deficient. You even put yourself in danger if you do so! That's exactly what we expect from a Big Pharma sponsored university.
- Escapado 4y agoHmm I listened to about 2 dozens of his podcasts and I feel like the author is really putting a lot of focus on something that I didn’t feel was nearly as emphasised as this post makes it seem. The vast majority of info I think is about behavioural things and processes inside of us and I think him relentlessly reminding us to always check with our health care providers first before taking or stopping to take anything is enough of a preface for me to be alright with him talking about supplements. And while I appreciate the callout of him citing low quality data (albeit I haven’t checked myself who is in the wrong here), I would also like to point to the fact that most of the other interventions he talks about do in fact have lots of proven benefits and are widely recognised as such. Another questions would be the baseline we are comparing him to. I have two friends who have dramatically improved their lives after stumbling upon his podcast and I also took away quite a few practices that had a positive impact on my life. If that is the mean effect I am ok with embracing a few imperfections in the data he cites or the supplements he recommends since a lot of people start with a baseline of shitty self destructive behaviour consuming all sorts of really damaging stuff.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoI've liked Huberman's podcasts, I think that sometimes he has some really useful info... but I'm getting increasingly concerned about all of the products he's hawking for sponsors. Most are dietary supplements. Athletic Greens is one product he's been advertising for a while - I saw a review of AG on a YouTube channel (they didn't mention Huberman) and their conclusion was that at best it was way over priced and probably will have no effect other than placebo.
- codethief 4y ago(Disclaimer: I have no idea what the author's political views are, so my comment is not about the author & his article specifically but rather about a general phenomenon I have come across various times.) > Even though his podcast is firmly rooted in the masculine space of “body optimization” While there's no doubt that self-optimization topics seem to attract more men than women, why is it that people who are into gender, equality and "toxic masculinity" topics – and, for the sake of this argument, let's assume the author is one of them – always have to put a label on everything, such as "This is male, this is female." They seem to be falling into exactly the trap they are criticizing. The author goes on to say: > Huberman is a lot less “bro-ey” than his fellow influencers. There’s a real gentleness and care to his delivery. The packaging is less aggressive, but the content does not stray far from Silicon Valley’s love affair with the tweaking of healthy human biology. Ah, so gentleness is not associated with masculinity, but aggressiveness is, got it. Ergo, women must be gentle but not aggressive. Oh and "body optimization" is clearly not for females. Why are they reinforcing the same stereotypes[0] they are fighting? Why can't we simply say > While body optimization influencers often come across as aggressive and demonstrate little care for their delivery, Huberman's podcast… ? There, gender stereotypes and labels avoided. [0]: I am aware that studies indicate that there is some truth to this specific stereotype in that – on average – men are more non-agreeable, women a bit less so (i.e. more agreeable). But this is a statistical average – an individual's personality traits can be far away from the average, and so I think stereotypes like "X is clearly male, and Y is clearly female" are doing us a disservice. Can't we all just be individuals?
- skinnymuch 4y agoHuberman is slightly more right wing which is more masculine. I could be wrong. I can’t name any of his views off the top of my head but he is considered one of the new gatekeepers of the intellectual dark web alongside contemporaries like Lex Fridman. Women are normally considered more egalitarian. I believe there’s studies on this. I run an online coworking community and keeping people who present as men is harder than people presenting as women. It’s been an issue with people noticing and commenting on the patterns of the community wrt genders. I try not to care about gender personally. > always have to put a label on everything > Ergo, women must be gentle but not aggressive. > “X is clearly male” This isn’t what people like the author who complain about “bro-ey” are normally trying to say. I don’t think they meant any extreme stuff like the above. I agree their tone could be better.
- 000ooo000 4y agoParaphrasing, but "Filter the things I'm professing through the lens of your own research and conversations with your doctor" is something Huberman has said often in his early podcasts I've listened to. I'm an adult and I'm happy to trade my attention for free information that I know may be biased due to his sponsors or even wrong due to a bad read on The Literature. Still, if I were to act on any of his advice, I would do so knowing that it's ultimately my responsibility to evaluate and vett the info. Which is no different to how I would think a reasonable person should approach info from any source. That said, this article definitely reads like a hit piece as another commenter mentioned. Quite a bit of loaded language and associations. I think if you call yourself a 'pseudoscience buster', you have probably established some incentives and now everything looks like a nail.
- philip1209 4y ago1. When he talks about supplements, it's mostly accomplied by discussion of peer-reviewed papers about the supplements. 2. Supplements and medicine converge in some ways - for instance, the line between "refined fish oil supplements" and "Vascepa, the FDA-approved medicine" is blurring. 3. The future of science is rooted in the educated hypotheses of scientists.
- kypro 4y agoI read the first two paragraphs, and although they are presented neutrally I knew this was going to be a negative article. > Combining the calm delivery and pared-down wardrobe of a Sam Harris with the more imposing physique of a Joe Rogan > The aesthetics of Huberman’s show are that of masculine minimalism. Such weird comments. I do agree with some of this article though... I don't really follow Huberman, but I have seen a couple of his podcasts on YouTube. I also found the personalised advertising of supplements and health services quite distasteful. If it was a simple "sponsored by Athletic Greens" then fine, but reading an elaborate script about how much he personally loves Athletic Greens is a bit questionable given his credentials. The actual information he presentee in the episodes I listened to seemed mostly fine though. Not perfect, but way better than most content on health and nutrition on the internet. Perhaps the quality has dropped more recently or something.
- jvican 4y agoFirstly, I disagree with the core premise of the article. What Huberman does is worthy of applause and respect; I've watched about 20 videos of his, and I've never had the impression he pushes supplements on people. On the contrary, he sometimes even acknowledges people that prefer not to take supplements and says that's a completely reasonable stance as well. His job is informative, and he only recommends what he actually takes and has experimented with. Secondly, I often find it useful to regard The Huberman Lab (his podcast) as a natural extension of his teaching at Stanford. He just goes as deep as he can, mentioning papers, and getting into the actual science of things, because he's a geek and a passionate researcher first and foremost. I see some people complain he's too boring. I disagree; the problem is people expect that learning is supposed to be a light and fun exercise. The thing is, true learning takes time and a lot of effort. Otherwise, you'll just forget about what you're learning. When you listen to Huberman you might need to take notes and re-watch episodes to fully get a mental model of the things he talks about. If you just want tips and suggestions: sure, listen to it casually. But if you want to be in a position where you can precisely explain to someone why a certain intervention or practice is good, then expect to put in the time. Personally, I even prefer reading the transcripts and taking notes instead of listening to him, though often I would only do that after I'm determined to learn deeply about a topic and I've watched a list part of the episode. Here's a list of resources you can use to read transcripts: 1. https://www.hubermantranscripts.com https://www.hubermantranscripts.com (powered by ChatGPT, it has search, and does episode summaries) 2. https://www.steno.ai/huberman-lab https://www.steno.ai/huberman-lab 3. https://podscript.ai/podcasts/huberman-lab-podcast/ https://podscript.ai/podcasts/huberman-lab-podcast/
- electrondood 4y agoOr... maybe the guy is just interested in experimenting with supplements. This article seems to be implying something that just isn't there in my perception.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoThis reads like there’s an agenda and the author isn’t looking at the balance of Huberman’s content objectively at all. The podcast repeatedly, almost relentlessly advises putting sleep, socializing, movement, and diet above all else (unless a situation warrants immediate remedy of course). He frequently suggests not taking supplements to address issues that foundational self-care should address first. He warns against taking many supplements, urging people to experiment carefully, reminding listeners that biology varies and people will experience varying results. There are no silver bullets. The guy puts breathing, yoga nidra, and morning light exposure on a pedestal. My takeaway from listening to almost every single episode has never been to take more supplements. Sure he is sponsored by people who sell them. Yes he takes them. My experience is that this is transparent and not foisted on listeners as the holy grail of health and performance.
- pas 4y agoit still has the same effect. he is pushing supplements. sure you might not need them now. but keep listening and eventually there will be one that you think you might need.
- jasfi 4y agoSuch a negative take on supplements in 2023 is really behind. They frequently make huge, positive differences to peoples' lives.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- YouAmuseMe 4y ago[flagged]
- YouAmuseMe 4y ago[flagged]
- thunkshift1 4y agoEngagement farming 101: 1. find something a lot of people like or are interested in 2. Dis on it in a public platform, usually a blog post or twitter thread, or a news article 3. Profit from the attention you get by riling up people from group in step 1
- ofcourseyoudo 4y agoI don't think Huberman has a dark agenda focused on supplements behind his contents, but I do wish he would find a pill he could take that make him record shorter podcast episodes.
- raspasov 4y agoJelly pretend-journalism at its finest.
- parentheses 4y agoHis content suffers from the library size being large. I doubt in one sitting he’d suggest everything to a person all at once. I have adopted my own “stack” which works for me and many of the items I take work for me. So should anyone else who is interested in supplements. They should start slow and try to measure what works. They should periodically take breaks.