I wouldn't give up on it, the follow up has a massive flaw. They didn't account for why the judges were fasting. They used Ramadan which is a religious observan

I wouldn't give up on it, the follow up has a massive flaw. They didn't account for why the judges were fasting. They used Ramadan which is a religious observance and the fast is done for religious reasons. That's obviously going to have an impact on the judges' leanings towards mercy.