2 ms·
That's a mess of an article. It confuses "free will" and "freedom". "Free will" is an internal issue within brains. "Freedom" is about what you can do before s
by Animats 4y ago
That's a mess of an article. It confuses "free will" and "freedom".
"Free will" is an internal issue within brains. "Freedom" is about what you can do before some external constraint stops you. Confusing the two does not help.
On the free will side, there are various technical arguments. One science fiction author has one of his robots, asked about free will by a human, say that they have a random number generator, and that's the same thing. There's also the paradox of Buridan's Ass, having to choose between two equally attractive alternatives and getting stuck.[1] That turns out to be related to the arbiter problem, where two requests for the same resource at "the same time" have to be resolved. It's a theorem that resolving such conflicts cannot be done in a bounded time, and hardware to do it has to allow for occasional delays while something in a metastable state settles. The non-technical concept is trying to decide who wins with rock-paper-scissors. If both parties offer the same value, you have to try again. With retries, the odds of getting a decision keep improving. But there's no number you can say is always enough.
There are psychology experiments which indicate that the explanation for a decision is generated after the decision is made.
On the "freedom" side, there's much political exploitation of the term, on both sides. Not going to go there today. The Economist had a cover article on this recently.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Buridan%27s_ass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Buridan%27s_ass
- Nevermark 4y ago> There are psychology experiments which indicate that the explanation for a decision is generated after the decision is made. Beyond experiments, there just isn't an alternative. Unless our decision making was completely conscious and objective (lists, arithmetic, logical selection or elimination, etc.) then it includes subconscious components (feelings, instinct, intuition, reflex, etc.) whose processes we don't know, and which are dependent on so many parameters that they likely could never be accurately summarized. Even if we could somehow be conscious of our activity at the individual neuron, synapse and neurotransmitter reservoir level. So for most decisions, there is no alternative to conjecturing/confabulating our decision making process. For the same reasons we have to conjecture/confabulate other's decision making processes. Other than simply self reporting that we don't know, and we know that we don't know ("I have a bad feeling about this!") In both cases, the point is that it is better to have some model to predict future decisions by ourselves and others, inevitably incomplete and inaccurate, than to have no model at all.
- morpheos137 4y agoWhat will really blow your mind is when "you" learn there is no "you."
- Tagbert 4y agoI would say that I am We and we don’t all talk to each other.
- Brian_K_White 4y agoI thought right at the beginning they not only stated pretty plainly, but also illustrated with a simple enough example, that they are concerned with neither simple physical limitation nor a simple idea of will, but with the effects of ideas. You are physically free to do something(freedom, by your description), and able to decide to or not(free will, by your description), but there is another govorner which is what you believe or how you reason on all manner of other possibly related topics. You don't do something, and it's not because you aren't free to, nor because you have no free will to imagine it, nor because you don't want to.
- danaris 4y ago> There are psychology experiments which indicate that the explanation for a decision is generated after the decision is made. While this is true (IIRC it found that for the decisions it was tracking, the "real" decision was made subconsciously seven seconds before it was consciously stated), it is trivially disprovable that this is universally true. All you have to do is present people with a novel decision to make, and force them to make it in a very short amount of time. Since we know that humans are capable of reacting and making decisions based on new information in well under seven seconds, it is clearly dangerous to overgeneralize the results of the experiments you cite.
- krapp 4y agoThat doesn't disprove anything. It could just as well be the case that the subconscious decision-making process can be done more quickly when necessary.
- mgh2 4y agoThe misunderstanding is understandable, since there is a bias in 1st world countries, living in too much "choice" (fueled by marketing): https://trendguardian.medium.com/free-will-a-rich-fairy-tale-4fecf8095812 https://trendguardian.medium.com/free-will-a-rich-fairy-tale...