2 ms·
The dualist position doesn't seem like a serious one to me, more of like a historically interesting position to take.
by whimsicalism 4y ago
The dualist position doesn't seem like a serious one to me, more of like a historically interesting position to take.
- haswell 4y agoIt’s serious enough to be held by many people in elected office, and by even more people who voted them in. The status of dualism as a “serious” position does not matter if the people who still hold that position have the power to sway or set public policy. And as a matter of experience, the vast majority of people interact with the world dualistically regardless of their metaphysical beliefs or lack thereof. It is possible to both recognize the illusion exists while remaining very much under its spell as a matter of experience and as a frame of reference. This framing becomes problematic when one continues to base assumptions about intelligence and language on the felt experience of “I”, regardless of the seriousness of the metaphysical position.
- int_19h 4y agoPeople coming from those positions might have other motivations for a crackdown, though. I have already seen talk about "abomination" etc in more casual non-tech discussions about this stuff.
- haswell 4y agoPerhaps. Or they could also use their mistaken belief to grant AI powers that would otherwise be reserved solely for humans. Think AI judges. They'll never be sold as such, but the impact of their operation on individuals may be just as impactful.
- pmarreck 4y agoWell, explain punishment in a world where free will dualism doesn’t exist… Seems senseless to penalize people for actions they had no actual “say” in doing
- whimsicalism 4y agoPunishment should be done to deter others from same crime, I agree there is little value in the other reason for punishment.