4 ms·
And the next sentence: "In this country you work harder to achieve your dreams and goals." 1: The higher the tax, the harder you have to work to achieve your d
by mseebach 18y ago
And the next sentence: "In this country you work harder to achieve your dreams and goals."
1: The higher the tax, the harder you have to work to achieve your dreams and goals => the decision to leave certainty for a venture is harder => less people will do it.
2: A tax increase counts twice when you're hiring e.g. cleaning help for your home, since both you and the cleaner is paying the higher tax. Thus, it get harder to pay for cleaning (gardening, construction, mechanics etc), and you're more likely to do it yourself, devoting less time to your family, start-up or work.
3: Finally, higher taxes will make it harder to promote/be promoted. In a promotion, you get more money and more responsibilities. The higher the tax, the less money will be in your pocket after the promotion, and the incentive to accept is lower. Coupled with no. 2, if you're busy building a new bathroom and a garage at home, you don't have the time to accept more responsibilities at work.
By the way - watch out for "95% won't be affected" rhetoric. A functioning democracy can't just be 95% fleecing the 5% - or the 55% fleecing the 45%.
- dusklight 18y agoIf the only difference between the stated policy positions of Obama and Mccain was this one tax policy, then you might make some sense. As it is I can only conclude that you are really bad at math.
- mseebach 18y agoAs it is, I can only conclude that you are really bad at reading, since my post contains general observations about taxation, and only a brief remark about Obama. In the interest of making everyone smarter, rather than throwing mud, might you care to share where my math is wrong?
- dusklight 18y agoWell okay so think about it this way. If the only change in the system, is that your tax rate gets increased, and the extra money that gets collected is thrown away, and the economy continues on its current trajectory, then what you said makes perfect sense. If the desired goal is "more money in your pocket" then the equation should be money I make - taxes = money in my pocket and assuming we are talking about a guy with a business and not someone taking a salary, the money you make is probably affected by the overall state of the economy. If the action that causes of increasing your taxes also substantially improves the economy, don't you think maybe .. just maybe .. you might make more money overall? What is better? To have a bigger slice of a shrinking pie or to have a smaller slice of a pie thats getting bigger and bigger?
- cousin_it 18y agoA tax increase helps the people affected by it make more money? How?
- nazgulnarsil 18y agowell, it can be for awhile. then the successful people start leaving and all the morons wonder why. look at the skilled labor problems they are having in socialist european countries.
- khafra 18y agoWhen we had a 94% top marginal tax rate in 1944-45, or >=91% for 12 years starting in 1951, was there a big "brain drain" emigration problem, and jobs going overseas? Perhaps international outsourcing has grown not only because of the internet, but in part because Reagan cut the top bracket from 70% to 28%. Cuba makes European countries look like the Mises institute, just as Norway or France would deem Obama's policies to be tilted right wing/laissez-faire. But Cuba has one doctor--the gold standard of skilled labor--for every 175 citizens, compared to the US's one for every 300.
- lionhearted 18y ago"When we had a 94% top marginal tax rate in 1944-45, or >=91% for 12 years starting in 1951, was there a big "brain drain" emigration problem, and jobs going overseas?" --> Mobility is much, much, much increased since 1951. I did a quick google to look for how much it cost to make long distance phone calls in '51 and this came up: "The first customer-connected long-distance telephone call was made on November 11, 1951... was the first call dialed with an area code, using what would now be called 10-digit dialing, and was connected automatically within 18 seconds." Getting up and going wasn't as viable back then for most people. Likely almost all of the people in the top tax bracket have friends, connections, and associates in at least a couple countries these days.
- mattmaroon 18y agoIt's not that simple. 1. That tax money doesn't vanish down a hole. It gets spent, largely on American businesses. 2. By collecting more we reduce the deficit, so it also saves on inevitable future taxes plus interest.. 3. The cleaner isn't paying a higher tax, unless the cleaner makes $250k a year. In fact since the cleaner is probably making 1/8th of that, he is paying a lower tax and could therefore charge me less while still making the same amount himself, and the free market will make that happen. 4. A rising tide lifts all boats. If there's one thing we can be sure of, it's that the middle class isn't going to save that extra money, that's just not the American way. They're going to spend it. A retailer's after tax margins might drop a bit, but their volume will increase. (I think that's what Obama was trying to say in response to the infamous Joe the Plumber question, but he didn't explain it well.) I don't see the logic behind your number 3. Salaries are, of course, a deduction, so higher taxes should have little effect on them. Any employees making less than $250k (and that's the overwhelming majority of non self-employed people) will require less salary due to paying less taxes to maintain the same quality of life. And increased volume will make up for decreased margins at least to some extent (probably varying by industry). Also, one of my blog readers sent me a neat economics paper he had written in college (I think at Harvard) that showed that sensible tax increases (like the Clinton years) have no impact on business creation. He used EINs issued, among other metrics.
- steveplace 18y agoA comment on your first point: It does not get spent on American businesses. I wish it did, but a large share (~40%) goes to entitlement programs (Medicare, SS). Then you've also got defense spending, which benefits some companies, and also you've got other things like debt interest, homeland security, etc. http://www.wallstats.com/deathandtaxes/ http://www.wallstats.com/deathandtaxes/ is a pretty good visualization.
- khafra 18y agoNot to belabor the point unnecessarily, but Social Security checks are generally injected immediately back into the economy as well, and Medicare-while it does help prop up the least fiscally efficient medical system in the world--does, at least, get spent in the US. Defense and Homeland Security spending benefit some companies at the expense of others; that's an effect with debatable benefit. The debt interest supports the GP's other point, that the money would be taxed or inflated away eventually, anyway.