4 ms·
Not entirely clear from the article, but it looks like it might be a "straight" line on a Mercator-projected map, in other words, a rhumb line[1]. So that techn
by ryandrake 4y ago
Not entirely clear from the article, but it looks like it might be a "straight" line on a Mercator-projected map, in other words, a rhumb line[1]. So that technically doesn't answer the question "what (and where) is the longest distance you can walk in a straight line [...]??" When you are walking in reference to a compass (let's simplify and assume it references True North), you are actually making a gradual turn to stay aligned with your angle to the meridians. Especially at high latitudes like in Great Britain. Instead, he should be looking for the longest Great Circle[2] line from point to point, which may, in reality, be in a very similar location because for short distances, great circles often line up very closely with rhumblines.
The author is a founder of a mapping company, so he very likely knows this, and the article is aimed at a more layman audience who likes to play around with Google Maps and such.
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhumb_line https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhumb_line
2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_circle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_circle
- rootusrootus 4y agoIf it were to get technical enough to differentiate between rhumb and great circle, then maybe it should factor in elevation changes too.
- 0_____0 4y agoIf you include elevation then you have to include tolerance for deviation. I live in an old house, so I can't even walk across the room without a vertical deviation of some sort :) Edit: My point here is that if you try to plot a literal straight line through 3D space, it will be necessary to allow some amount of deviation in one axis. Else your longest 3D line will be the distance between your first two points.
- crznp 4y agoHe does: 75.9km on the map, 77.0km when accounting for elevation. With the caveat: "Well, it's never as much as I'd think and it depends upon the accuracy of your terrain model"
- ta1243 4y agoThat number surprised me, but because of how much extra it was rather than how little extra -- I always assume it's negligable, but in this case was over 1%
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- teruakohatu 4y agoI also agree it seems like a lot. If there was 3000m of elevation gain and 3000m of elevation loss, I would only expect a couple or hundred extra meters of distance walked. 77.23 ≈ sqrt(77^2+(3+3)^2). Reading total elevation gain/loss from his graph it hard but 3000m up and down seems about right.
- OscarCunningham 4y agoThe average gradient of Scotland is 19.3%.
- rdlw 4y agoThen it becomes a coastline problem, with different answers depending on the resolution of your elevation data. Great video on this from Matt Parker (focusing on area in this case): https://youtu.be/PtKhbbcc1Rc https://youtu.be/PtKhbbcc1Rc
- codeflo 4y agoMercator maps are conformal, which means that over small distances, shapes are preserved, though you do have to correctly adjust the distance scale. So how much does that matter over 76 km, would the bend in the line even be visible?
- ryandrake 4y agoYea, admittedly at these distances (<100km) the difference will be very small unless at extreme latitudes. Looks like the points are at approximately N57°18.280', W3°55.948' -> N56°54.152', W4°56.664' if anyone wants to do the math. My guess is the rhumb line and GC route differ by no more than a few meters. I was hoping the article would go more into how they searched the data and found the points. An exhaustive search of all points in the U.K. would obviously be computationally prohibitive. Maybe create millions of polygons where the edges are roads, and sort them by area to reduce the search space? From the article's text it looks like he "eyeballed" the map to find empty areas to focus on, which is unsatisfying :)
- bluenose69 4y agoI get a bit over 200 metres from the following R code. (Edit: I forgot how to format code for HM, sorry.) library(oce) lat <- c(57+18.280/60, 56+54.152/60) lon <- -c(3+55.948/60, 4+56.664/60) m <- lm(lat ~ lon) # Find points along a great-circle route gc <- oce::geodGc(lon, lat, 0.001) # 'scale' is distance associated with 1 degree latitude shift scale <- geodDist(mean(lon), mean(lat), mean(lon), mean(lat)+1) # 'e' is latitude shift from great-circle route to 'straight' line route e <- scale\*sapply(seq_along(gc$longitude), function(i) gc$latitude[i] - predict(m, data.frame(lon=gc$longitude[i]))) plot(gc$longitude, e, type="l", xlab="Longitude [degE]", ylab="Distance error [km]", col=2) max(e)
- codeflo 4y agoI’m not familiar with R, but the lm(…) line looks like it’s linearly interpolating the latitude and longitude. However, that’s not what straight lines in a Mercator projection are. You might be confusing it with the cylindrical projection. The Mercator projection stretches things away from the equator vertically to compensate the horizontal stretching, in order to preserve local shapes. This makes it a bit better for these kinds of local measurements than one might think at first glance.
- cies 4y ago> Without crossing a pub road Or crossing water. I think given this constraints a line from any non-pub-road, non-water place in GB to the center of the earth is the longest straight line, without considering space bending around mass. :)
- jodrellblank 4y agoThe question was "what (and where) is the longest distance you can walk in a straight line..." so that rules out the center of the Earth.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- timthorn 4y agoSpecifically, the projection used is the Ordnance Survey National Grid projection, which is Transverse Mercator. The OS published a good introductory (but detailed) guide some years ago: https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/documents/resources/guide-coordinate-systems-great-britain.pdf https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/documents/resources/guide-c...