3 ms·
To my mind, the lerp thing makes the direct interactions in the demos look slow, smooth, and imprecise instead of fast, sharp, and immediately correct. Where l
by nine_k 4y ago
To my mind, the lerp thing makes the direct interactions in the demos look slow, smooth, and imprecise instead of fast, sharp, and immediately correct.
Where lerp would be great is showing indirect results of some actions: a non-obvious effect shown as a slower animation may give a better idea of what is happening, when you were not tracking the value previously. The scrolling demo gives a glimpse of it, but it's still a bit too direct to benefit seriously.
- musingsole 4y agoWithout context, the animation applied to a basic interaction seems like it's getting in the way of User Interaction But as you hint, in many situations a gradual change of the presentation will allow a user a lot more awareness of the presentation and it's interconnections as a whole. With scrolling, the idea is usually you're looking at a massive block of text with some images. Why are you scrolling? Sometimes, you may know exactly where on the page you're trying to go -- in which case lerp will interfere with the interaction. But in most cases, your using the scroll feature to skim and find the correct place, in which case an animated scroll will serve the user better since the content will have a predictable location throughout the presentation.
- darkerside 4y agoAlso much easier on the eye, allowing you to place text and start reading it even as it's still moving
- toss1 4y agoYes. The examples were clear, but seems like not the best use cases for this. My impression is that it was smoother but laggy and imprecise. I wouldn't want it for an object I was directly controlling (what's needed is faster sampling rate), but likely great for less controlled objects. Or maybe just change the parameters to make it track more closely (adjustible)?
- illiarian 4y ago> To my mind, the lerp thing makes the direct interactions in the demos look slow, smooth, and imprecise instead of fast, sharp, and immediately correct. I think the examples are made this way specifically for you to notice the effect. Animations can, and should be employed sparingly and made fast. However, there are quite a few places where adding just a little touch of animation helps immensely: buttons that react to the touch, slight dampening of the scroll when you jump to an anchor link (so that the eye adjusts to the new page position), state changes etc. Personal gripe: Older versions of iOS were quite good with that, but then they've made a ton of animations, and made them slow.