4 ms·
> The people running companies doing this kind of thing need prison sentences. HIPAA and, if any federally-involved (even indirectly) treatment was involved, e
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> The people running companies doing this kind of thing need prison sentences.
HIPAA and, if any federally-involved (even indirectly) treatment was involved, even more stringent [0] (as to disclosure conditions, the penalties are the same) special rules for the protection of federal substance use disorder patients, provide both civil penalties for unauthorized disclosures and criminal penalties for knowingly disclosing or obtaining information without authorization.
[0] More stringent, as in, for example, its still a crime to disclose information to someone with a completely valid subpoena for it, unless you have also been issued a special disclosure-authorizing court order in addition to the subpoena.
- i_am_jl 4y ago>More stringent, as in, for example, its still a crime to disclose information to someone with a completely valid subpoena for it, unless you have also been issued a special disclosure-authorizing court order in addition to the subpoena. Can you elaborate? Does this mean that a subpoena that purports to allow seizure of HIPAA-protected data is only valid for seizure of that data if it's accompanied by a court order saying "Yes, this subpoena includes HIPAA-protected information"? Sort of a safeguard against HIPAA data being included unknowingly in subpoenaed materials?
- dragonwriter 4y agoThis is for federally-involved substance use disorder patient info, which is protected beyond HIPAA, but, yes, it means information related to them that is subpoenaed or subject to similar otherwise-compulsory disclosure cannot be disclosed (or even responded to in a way which would confirm that a person is a patient, if the form of the compulsory demand is, e. g., fot records of a particular person) without a separate court order specifically authorizing disclosure of federal substance use disorder patient records. (Note that a judge has to issue the order here, whereas the lawyer for a party — the biggest concern here being the government — can issue a subpoena, and there are also legislative and administrative subpoenas.) > Sort of a safeguard against HIPAA data being included unknowingly in subpoenaed materials? It’s more a prevention against otherwise-valid subpoenas being used to end-run the protection of SUD patient data, especially for the ultimate use of law enforcement.