6 ms·
Sugar Should Be Regulated As Toxin, Researchers Say
- thenewgreen 15y agoHuh, was just talking about this on hubksi: http://hubski.com/pub?id=15982 http://hubski.com/pub?id=15982 I provided this link there too: http://naturalnews.com/Images/Cola-Earlier.jpg http://naturalnews.com/Images/Cola-Earlier.jpg It wasn't so long ago that the cola industry was actively marketing it as something that was beneficial to "put in a bottle". I imagine that years from now we will look back at our naiveté regarding health with shock and awe.
- brianbreslin 15y agoI love how that image touts the health benefits as "fitting in" and social acceptance.
- ori_b 15y agoThe second link is a parody created in 2002. http://rjwhite.tumblr.com/post/472668874/fact-checking http://rjwhite.tumblr.com/post/472668874/fact-checking
- thenewgreen 15y agoThank you.
- ImprovedSilence 15y agoYeah, and caffeine is a drug, do you need a prescription for that. I have no doubt that some lobbying special interest group is behind this "research".
- astrange 15y agoWhich group would that be?
- jff 15y agoWhy, the artificial sweetener industry, of course! In seriousness, there is surely a bunch of money to be made here, even if that isn't the objective of the researcher. Step one, declare that eating X will kill you. Step two, develop a book all about how not to eat X. Step three, profit. Note that there is no "..." step, because there are always people dumb enough to jump on the latest food craze.
- mitchty 15y agoYou might want to watch this video of the guy behind this research first. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM His reason for regulation is fructose acting very similarly to alcohol as far as reactions go. Be forewarned that video takes about 20-30 minutes to pick up. But he gets into cell biology of what fructose and sucrose do in cells. Now does anyone have links to criticism that actually argues his points biologically? I can't help but agree that we eat too much sugar in our modern diets.
- brudgers 15y ago>"Sugar and other sweeteners are, in fact, so toxic to the human body that they should be regulated as strictly as alcohol by governments worldwide" Alcohol shouldn't be regulated, endangering others while intoxicated and other irresponsible acts should be.
- gerggerg 15y agoAlcohol should be regulated for the same reasons other harder drugs should be regulated. - Proper regulation(not prohibition) takes money away from organized crime. - Government based health regulations are still of great social impact. - The money generated helps pay for the societal impacts of its use.
- mixmastamyk 15y ago> - Proper regulation(not prohibition) takes money away from organized crime. So does legalization/lack of regulation.
- joejohnson 15y agoAlcohol should be regulated. When I buy a handle of vodka, I want some guarantee that I'm not going to go blind from drinking it.
- bdunbar 15y agoIt is possible there are better ways to regulate booze than having a government do it for you.
- roc 15y agoAt least in the US, government regulation of food and alcohol was a response to the (in)effectiveness of market-based self-regulation. You can certainly disagree on whether things were all that bad, or that the particular degree of, or programs of, our government regulations are not the best way to do it. But it's not like government forced itself into this position on a whim. Society experienced the alternative to government regulation and decided it wasn't sufficient.
- codergirl 15y agoI didn't see that article cite the researchers, but it's probably this group: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM. Pretty interesting talk about the rise of high fructose corn syrup.
- jganetsk 15y agoThe guy in that talk is the principal investigator of the study. But it has nothing to do with HFCS in particular, and everything to do with added sugar in general. Sugar made from cane and beets is just as bad as HFCS.
- joejohnson 15y ago>> Sugar made from cane and beets is just as bad as HFCS. That is false. Refined sugar (that is, sucrose) is made up of a molecule of the carbohydrate glucose, bonded to a molecule of the carbohydrate fructose — a 50-50 mixture of the two. The fructose, which is almost twice as sweet as glucose, is what distinguishes sugar from other carbohydrate-rich foods like bread or potatoes that break down upon digestion to glucose alone. The more fructose in a substance, the sweeter it will be. High-fructose corn syrup, as it is most commonly consumed, is 55 percent fructose, and the remaining 45 percent is nearly all glucose. It was first marketed in the late 1970s and was created to be indistinguishable from refined sugar when used in soft drinks. Because each of these sugars ends up as glucose and fructose in our guts, our bodies react the same way to both, and the physiological effects are identical. In a 2010 review of the relevant science, Luc Tappy, a researcher at the University of Lausanne in Switzerland who is considered by biochemists who study fructose to be the world’s foremost authority on the subject, said there was “not the single hint” that H.F.C.S. was more deleterious than other sources of sugar. The fructose component of sugar and H.F.C.S. is metabolized primarily by the liver, while the glucose from sugar and starches is metabolized by every cell in the body. Consuming sugar (fructose and glucose) means more work for the liver than if you consumed the same number of calories of starch (glucose). And if you take that sugar in liquid form — soda or fruit juices — the fructose and glucose will hit the liver more quickly than if you consume them, say, in an apple (or several apples, to get what researchers would call the equivalent dose of sugar). The speed with which the liver has to do its work will also affect how it metabolizes the fructose and glucose. Full article: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/17/magazine/mag-17Sugar-t.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/17/magazine/mag-17Sugar-t.htm...
- joejohnson 15y agoI am in favor of taxing sugar and this money could could go directly to healthcare.
- aresant 15y agoRead "regulated" as "taxed" in this headline. In another similar "regulatory" move, taxes on cigarettes have been shown to be effective for reducing smoking in "new smokers" and young adults (18 - 24) but with almost no effect in other age groups: http://org.elon.edu/ipe/gallagher.pdf http://org.elon.edu/ipe/gallagher.pdf and http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr4916a1.htm http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr4916a1.htm Would a similar strategy really be effective w/sugar or just add a further tax burden to 95% of us? Can't we come up with a better system that seeing more money out the door in taxes?
- roc 15y agoNot too long ago a link was posted here regarding some research that suggested bodies that had been overweight will process foods differently to try to return to that weight, even after a person had lost weight via diet and exercise. The gist was that a person who was, say, 200 pounds and lost weight down to 160 pounds had to eat ~20% fewer calories to maintain that weight than someone who was at 160 without ever being overweight. If that research is upheld upon further examination, then any policy which prevents young people from becoming obese in the first place would be perhaps the most promising way to obtain objective progress against societal obesity. I'm not suggesting that taxes are the right way to go, but if taxes merely discourage the young from developing obesity, that's not a mark against it.
- Someone 15y agoI find it hard to believe such ideas. It would mean that, somehow, a body that has not been overweight wastes 20% of its energy intake every day. Moreover, if you subtract the energy loss that must take place due to the temperature difference between body and air, the muscle efficiency of such persons must be extremely more efficient. Surely, evolutionary pressure must have been able to optimize that away? I find it more likely to believe that people who become overweight tend to be less inclined to be active, and that that does not change when they do lose weight.
- roc 15y ago
- derleth 15y agoWell, there go apples. And grapes. And peaches. And so on, and so forth.
- bwanab 15y agoNot at all. From the article "Added sugar, more so than the fructose in fiber-rich fruit, hits the liver more directly and can cause more damage."
- bdunbar 15y agoWell that's nice. I have some favorite bread recipes that call for sugar. Not a ton, just a pinch. Sugar - added sugar - is just a tool for creating edible food.
- gte910h 15y agoI mean Oreos, which are chocolate cookies with shortening and sugar in the middle, taste fantastic too. But that doesn't mean we can eat them all the time and stay healthy.
- gchpaco 15y agoIt should be noted that in bread, sugar is mostly food for the yeast (and anyway there's very little of it; my bread recipes call for an oz of honey to two pounds of bread flour and a pound and a half of water). This is why using sugar substitutes is a bad idea--the yeast isn't on a diet.
- derleth 15y agoSo if they added fiber to a Snickers bar, that Snickers bar would be healthy?
- derleth 15y agoI guess the downvote means the answer is "Of course not", so fiber isn't the concern here. So, people here claim that sugar is bad except when it's in fruit, and the fiber in fruit doesn't make sugar good.
- joejohnson 15y agoThis NY Times article from last August (http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/17/magazine/mag-17Sugar-t.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/17/magazine/mag-17Sugar-t.htm...) goes into a lot more detail on the toxicology of sugar.
- bdunbar 15y agoThe headline is misleading. The researchers propose regulations such as taxing all foods and drinks that include added sugar, banning sales in or near schools and placing age limits on purchases. It's for the children, of course. And for your own good, because you, yes you, are clearly irresponsible and can't think for yourself. Funny ol' world where supposedly smart guys can't think of a better solution for a problem than to ask the government to step in.
- techiferous 15y ago> And for your own good, because you, yes you, are clearly irresponsible and can't think for yourself. I really dislike a nanny state. But I also dislike a state where people don't take care of themselves and then clamor for better healthcare for their preventable diseases and expect the public to pay for it. Not sure what the answer is.
- UnFleshedOne 15y agoA lot of people clearly _are_ irresponsible and can't think for themselves. Not sure if government (especially in US) can help here though. US congress recently declared pizza to be a vegetable. Enough said.
- gerggerg 15y agoAnyone with a bit of time and a mild interest in chemistry and/or nutrition should watch this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM It's a talk by Dr Robert Lustig called Sugar: The bitter truth.
- driverdan 15y agoIt's good to watch his talk but keep in mind this is hyperbole and propaganda mixed in with science. He uses alarmist words to push his ideas which is pretty unscientific.
- 127001brewer 15y agoPlease explain how Dr. Lustig's words are "unscientific".
- Florin_Andrei 15y agoIt runs against the principle that my liberty as an individual is above all other considerations. Ergo, it's "unscientific". /sarcasm
- 127001brewer 15y agoI appreciate your sarcasm, but there is a fine line between "regulations" (in terms of general public safety) and "free will". For example, you could smoke as many cigarettes as you want to, but is that in the interest of the general public?
- gerggerg 15y agoI agree that his word choice at points is unscientific, and that he no doubt has an agenda especially being Professor of Pediatrics. But I still feel it's a hugely informative talk in which the science greatly outweighs the sensationalism.
- jpxxx 15y agoRobert Lustig, despite his considerable bona-fides, is an alarmist who uses hack science and a number of unsupported suppositions to make his (telegenic) points. When you call something like fructose 'toxic', you are doing the public a disservice.
- alecco 15y agoWith the epidemic of child obesity getting out of control alarms are necessary. And your ad-hominem is very pitiful.
- cgh 15y agoCan you elaborate on his specific use of "hack science"?
- jpxxx 15y agoYes. Here's the argument being put forth: Fructose in the diet must be metabolized by the liver, which creates excessive amounts of palmitic acid which induces fat to deposit in the liver which causes abnormal insulin response which leads to metabolic syndrome (an umbrella term including diabetes and obesity) which leads to poor personal health which means poor social health which means fructose is toxic. The science available can support this: fructose in the diet is metabolized by the liver, which at some point of saturation (in animal studies, at outrageous levels of pure fructose intake) causes excessive creation of palmitic acid which is deposited into the liver as a fat. This liver fat is moderately to strongly implicated in abnormal insulin response which can progress to diabetes which is comorbid with obesity. Thus, actual science is a long long long long way from ~Fructose is Toxic And Must Be Removed From The Foodstream~. There's also the problem of sucrose, which immediately decomposes into… drumroll… fructose and glucose. Glucose in this story is beyond reproach - it is the foundation of animal life. Which means that the Fructose Is Toxic hypothesis needs to take into account sucrose consumption. Which his argument doesn't. This guy isn't completely full of shit, and I don't think his heart is in the wrong place. But he's screaming fire in a very crowded theater.
- alecco 15y ago
- zephjc 15y agoMaybe processed food producers should stop adding sugar/HFCS to everything under the sun. An example list: http://www.accidentalhedonist.com/index.php/2005/06/09/foods_and_products_containing_high_fruct http://www.accidentalhedonist.com/index.php/2005/06/09/foods... Does HFCS REALLY need to be in NyQuil? In steak sauce? In vegetable soup?
- ScottBurson 15y agoThe problem is, they do that because people buy more of the product when it has sugar in it. On the whole, I don't think pressuring the producers is going to get us anywhere. There may be specific cases where such pressure might work -- vegetable soup, perhaps -- but even then, that can only happen if enough consumers refuse to buy products containing gratuitous sugar. No, I think educating the public is really the only strategy available to us. Even regulation and taxation, which could be beneficial, can't happen without a certain number of informed consumers pushing for it.
- zephjc 15y agoWell, some of that is happening already. As people become educated about healthy eating, they investigate the ingredients lists more for what they're buying (becoming more health-conscious), and rejecting bad foods - letting their money do the talking. But I agree that health education in the US is the pits, and is the key to turning it around.
- tnicola 15y agoEducating the public will be hard as well. People lobby the government on behalf of sugar companies. Stevia, a low calory, low GI sugar substitute was unavailable in the US until very recently because the sugar companies lobbied the FDA to classify it as a 'drug' or a supplement and needed to be tested ad nauseum before it became available. All this allowed sugar and sweetener companies to prolong the entrance of Stevia into the market and not hit their profits. In addition to actually getting it classified as a drug, there is paid propaganda research out there saying that it is actually bad for you. Some handwaving arguement is presented without much evidence and a giant leap in order to frighten people. On such article can be found here. (done by quick Google search and I am in no way partial to this particular one. I am sure that there are more on the same subject) http://www.30thstreetclinic.com/general-reviews/100-stevia-dangers.html http://www.30thstreetclinic.com/general-reviews/100-stevia-d... When asked about dangers of stevia, this author says that it is dangerous, because it is not approved by the FDA. Hence, there is this vicious circle that even people who will seek out to educate themselves will come across these claims and perhaps continue to use sugar. Educating the public against products of the giant companies is an uphill battle. I am Canadian and Canadian doctors and nutritionists chuckle at this "not approved by the FDA - hence bad" arguement about stevia, but I am sure that if we were a major sugar country that it would be the same here as well.
- droithomme 15y agoSugar is as essential to the body's functioning as water and air. Such a tax will not eliminate sweet foods. Basic uncontroversial economics is sufficient to know the result of such a tax will be that manufacturers will switch to saccharine, Aspartame and other synthesized sweeteners which are not so taxed. Whether their deleterious health effects are real or conspiracy theories and if real are more harmful over the long run than sugar I will leave to the curious reader's further research.
- tghw 15y agoThat's just flat out wrong. Sugar, as in sucrose, is not at all necessary for the body's functioning. Other sugars are used by the body, but they can easily be synthesized from fruits and vegetables.
- Craiggybear 15y agoSugar is sugar is sugar is sugar. And it is absolutely essential ... regardless of its origin. But yes, too much ain't a good idea.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- grecy 15y agoI highly recommend watching King Korn [1], a documentary about growing corn in the USA and the subsidies that come with it. At one point, they make High Fructose Corn Syrup in their home kitchen - The chemicals involved and the process is mind blowing. It's amazing it's considered "food". [1] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1112115/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1112115/
- refurb 15y agoIt's a simple basic hydrolysis of sucrose. If that scares you, I suggest you don't take vitamins either because that process would really freak you out.
- jff 15y agoChemicals, oh my god! Not that! I bet you don't eat that scary irradiated meat, either.
- grecy 15y agoFor lunch just now I ate wild moose that I shot... so no, I don't eat farmed meat.
- malkia 15y agoI still don't understand why people put sugar into tea? At least Trader's Joe has very good tea (yes, I have to put that one here "UNSWEETENED")...
- jakeonthemove 15y agoI don't get it - glucose is fuel for our cells (or at least that's what I've been taught), so why is sugar bad for you? Does anyone know?