5 ms·
Companies were told for years that their data is an asset. Instead they should treat it like a toxic substance and a liability, to get rid of it as soon as they
by jacquesm 4y ago
Companies were told for years that their data is an asset. Instead they should treat it like a toxic substance and a liability, to get rid of it as soon as they can. But it will be a long time before this view will become more prevalent.
- userbinator 4y agoI very much hope not, for the sake of future historians. Orwell put it best: "He who controls the past controls the future. He who controls the present controls the past."
- mtrycz2 4y agoDid you really just compare private companies data retention to totalitarian censorship, and in a good way?
- olliej 4y agoIndeed, for future historians it is critical that every company store the address, id, and private info of all their customers, for all time, regardless of risk. Without which we may forget that I lived on Paeroa St for two years while at uni, information that will be crucial in a discussion of the habits of early 2000s university students in New Zealand, and the impact that had on the fall of western civilization and the rise of our new fish-centric ethno-religion in the year 1200 AT (After Tilapia).
- rickdeckard 4y agoLet's not forget that all this personal data should also enter public domain for historians of the world to process. How else will future generations be able to put your residence on Paeroa St in connection with the consumption of fish in that area during that time, to reveal the political stance of you and your offspring against the ruling party of the Tilapia...
- pizzaknife 4y agoHail and Bless Our Lord ./makes gill flapping gestures
- macintux 4y agoI will admit, for as much as I dislike Amazon now, on multiple occasions I’ve found it useful that I can log in and find my old addresses. Which reminds me, I really should just write those down somewhere safe.
- lm28469 4y agoHistory isn't private data For example you don't need to know exactly who voted for Trump or Biden in the last election, you just need to know the result
- tjoff 4y agoGDPR is a huge step in the right direction and has made a big difference. But yes, it needs much more time.
- stormdennis 4y agoHopefully it makes a real difference to compensate us for the never-ending, dark pattern cookie notices we have to endure as a result. Who wants a choice of 'Accept all' or 'Manage your settings' on every second webpage they land on?
- tjoff 4y agoThey are not GDPR compliant anyway, they just try to fight it by making GDPR look bad. Look for alternatives for such pathetic sites. Even Google of all places "respects" it now (after pressure). It becomes noticeably better every year.
- raverbashing 4y agoThese companies comply with GDPR as much as alcoholics comply with drinking driving laws by keeping a bottle on the trunk and stopping to take a swig once in a while
- HPsquared 4y agoBig centralized sites want that.
- jacquesm 4y agoYour beef is with the companies that do this, not with the GDPR.
- xp84 4y agoA law which causes the whole web to be worse for no reason deserves criticism. Managing cookies belongs in the browser, a place auditable and adjustable by the user. Not on every website in the world. GDPR may have had good outcomes too, and I am neutral on all other aspects, but whatever part of EU and California regulation led directly to cookie banners is a colossal failure which has benefitted no one (except possibly the dozens of snake oil cookie banner products which pretend to comply).
- fauigerzigerk 4y agoYes it will be a long time if it ever happens. Deleting data is hard work that requires a lot of preparation and has to be done without the safety net of backups. In many cases it will require changes to proprietary software. Keeping data happens automatically. Not having data that you're supposed to have becomes obvious as soon as someone asks for it. Holding on to data for longer than necessary only becomes a problem if there's a data breach (that cannot be covered up).
- gonzo41 4y agoCame here to say this. The added complexity is regulation saying you need to keep data on your customers. In a way the early somewhat anonymous internet was better in this regard. An edit to add, if you encrypt user data at rest (big ask currently). You can destroy the keys past a point and then the data in backups is safe etc. Anyway it'll take a while for this view of the world to shake through.
- hgsgm 4y agoEncrypting data at rest was table stakes 10 years ago Bitcoin and then ransomware became practical.
- ed_balls 4y agoThis will never happen. For a long time I thought there is a an USP in treating data as toxic substance, but with the rise of LLMs I think data is the new oil. Company A that leverages data will outcompete company B.
- organsnyder 4y ago> data is the new oil Lots of layers to this analogy, given the damage our use of oil is causing. Companies are going to learn that using LLMs without paying proper consideration to data governance is a recipe for large fines and worse (such as being required to throw out entire models because their provenance violates data subjects' privacy rights).
- mistrial9 4y agoexcellent reading for today: The Secret History of Lead, The Nation Magazine March 2000 .. many direct analogies indeed
- nabnob 4y agoThey're only subject to large fines if those laws are in place and actually being enforced, though. Companies keep getting away with these huge data breaches in the United States with almost no real consequences.
- organsnyder 4y agoIt's getting harder and harder to ignore these laws unless you're willing to stay out of some major markets (such as Europe and California). I think we'll see a national privacy law in the United States at some point in the next five years. There's appetite for it in both major parties (Democrats to protect bodily autonomy, Republicans to stick it to Big Tech), and I think the targets of the regulations themselves will at some point lobby for a consistent national law rather than the patchwork of state laws that we have now.
- wizzwizz4 4y agoThe RESTRICT Act suggests that there's political will in the US to solve the same problems that the GDPR solves. If the RESTRICT Act fails, the US might get federal-level privacy protection (subject to the PATRIOT Act, of course).
- andrenotgiant 4y agoI think you're paraphrasing from Maciej Ceglowski amazing "Haunted by Data" talk from seven years ago. Everyone should watch it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAXLHM-1Psk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAXLHM-1Psk
- notduncansmith 4y agoI was about to say, they’ve been told for years how toxic it is! Just not by enough people I think. Great talk indeed.
- philipov 4y agoIt is impossible to make a person understand a thing which their livelihood depends on them not understanding.
- brookst 4y agoThat’s kind of a false dichotomy; lots of things are both assets and liabilities. I work at a megacorp, and we have an entire group that goes around auditing projects to ensure compliance with data rentention policies, which include mandatory deletion of different types of data at different timeframes. Financial transaction records have a very long mandatory retention, IP addresses for logins have a fairly short mandatory deletion. Product telemetry has strict rules about avoiding PII and very very quick deletion (aggregate data can be kept longer). I’m sure the policies could be improved, but I suspect every large company is intensely aware of the importance of data deletion, even if competing priorities sometimes lead to longer than technically/legally required retention.
- organsnyder 4y agoI work on the Privacy Engineering team for one such company. Data retention is a huge topic and while there are often good guidelines, there usually aren't hard-and-fast rules. It's an exciting specialty for anyone that enjoys ambiguity (I like to joke that I enjoy the space since my dad was a philosophy professor). It also pays well and is recession-resistant.
- whimsicalism 4y ago> very very quick deletion What is very, very quick? And why?
- brookst 4y ago14 days in many cases, 24 hours in some. That quick because it is very hard to ensure that app telemetry doesn't have any confidential / sensitive information. And if the purpose is troubleshooting, there's no value in old data.
- erik_seaberg 4y agoWhen finding the proximate cause, it's pretty important to know whether a problem started today or went unnoticed for a month.
- skeeter2020 4y agoisn't it both? It's valuable fuel and radioactive waste? I see 2 immediate problems though: 1. you don't know when the fuel is exhausted or if you can reuse it in the future so you stockpile it; 2. the contamination is much worse than the local radioactivity, so it's hard to manage correctly.