3 ms·
Sure, but these sorts of questions are a one- or two-page web form that people could fill out on the IRS's web site, click Submit, and wait a few seconds for th
by kelnos 4y ago
Sure, but these sorts of questions are a one- or two-page web form that people could fill out on the IRS's web site, click Submit, and wait a few seconds for that information to be used (along with all the rest of the info the IRS has) to fill in their return.
For some of this stuff (like number of dependents or being blind), it would remember what you said last year, pre-fill, and let you edit (like if you had another kid, or if one aged out of being a dependent).
And this is the thing that annoys the shit out of me about all the naysayers like yourself about automating this stuff. It does not have to be 100% automated! Even 50% would be valuable, but for the majority of taxpayers I expect it would be close to 100%, with the average level of automation in the 80%-range (or even better; I'm being conservative with my guesses here). That would save people so much time and so much money, and it would absolutely destroy the revenue of the greedy, make-work tax-prep industry, which is fantastic.
You mention looking at 1040 to make this determination, but I look at it from looking at the TurboTax or TaxAct prompts. The vast majority of what I'd have to do on TurboAct (I use a CPA now, but used to use TaxAct) is either a) verifying that last year's information hasn't changed, or b) uploading or manually typing in data from documents that the IRS already has. I would gladly let the IRS do that all for me, and give me the opportunity to do the 10% or 20% of the work that the IRS can't automate. I wouldn't need a CPA anymore, for one thing, and I could knock out my taxes in under an hour, and feel confident that they're correct, much more so than if I were to try to do them 100% myself now.
- refurb 4y agoOK, so now take all those examples I gave and multiple them by 10 if you have an even slightly complex tax return. Calculate your own RSU tax basis, track whether or not you're eligible for a Roth IRA contribution based on a 5-factor test, etc, etc. Kinda sounds like what I'm already doing now. Sure, a nice slick government interface instead of TurboTax would be nice, but let's not kid ourselves that the work load would suddenly drop to something negligible. You say I'm a "naysayer", I say I'm just being realistic based on how complex the tax code is.