2 ms·
> For instance; it was retroactive — they were already levying the tax. So what? You could certainly make the argument that any taxes collected prior to the 1
by kelnos 4y ago
> For instance; it was retroactive — they were already levying the tax.
So what? You could certainly make the argument that any taxes collected prior to the 16th's ratification should be returned (courts may not agree with you, but I think it's a reasonable argument to make), but everything since then is legally free and clear.
> They then effectively didn’t pass it by the states in a way that they’d done previously, etc etc
Not sure what you mean here. Congress is absolutely constitutionally allowed to propose amendments, and it was then ratified by the 36 states necessary at the time to trigger its adoption. Ultimately, only six states never ratified it.
It doesn't matter if all the previous amendments had been proposed by state legislatures; the way 16A was proposed and passed is explicitly outlined in the constitution as a valid way to amend it.
The only thing approaching a "scandal" around 16A is that there was a bunch of opposition at the time, mainly in the northeastern states. Which... so what? Bottom line is that it was ratified by the required number of states.
Really, it just sounds like you don't personally like the income tax, and are making up fantasy reasons for why the US government should not be allowed to tax you. If it really bugs you that much, you're of course free to renounce your US citizenship, and go live in a country where they don't have an income tax, assuming they'll have you.