2 ms·
This trend of building opulent Havelis as a status symbol by the diaspora still exists across South Asia to this day. Documentary about it among the Pakistani
by alephnerd 4y ago
This trend of building opulent Havelis as a status symbol by the diaspora still exists across South Asia to this day.
Documentary about it among the Pakistani Norwegian community - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_fOYJ3_ZppM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_fOYJ3_ZppM
Article about it among the Malayali community - https://theprint.in/features/kerala-has-a-ghost-houses-problem-but-the-state-just-doesnt-want-to-get-into-it/1455219/ https://theprint.in/features/kerala-has-a-ghost-houses-probl...
And speaking from personal experience, my family has done similar stuff too in our ancestral village, though sadly it's increasingly abandoned as people move abroad or to larger cities to work as professionals.
- robocat 4y agoThat really brings home our own foibles for trying to climb the property status ladder in my own country. Fabulous doco, thanks. The Malayali article is on archive here: https://archive.vn/iBLAZ https://archive.vn/iBLAZ
- alephnerd 4y agoOh dang! Which country? And yea, it seems to be common occurance in all small formerly agrarian towns. I've heard similar stories occur in towns with a heavy migrant presence in Ningxia, Southern Romania, and Honduras. The life of a Garbeister/Guest Worker/Blue Collar Migrant I guess.
- robocat 4y agoChristchurch, New Zealand. It demonstrates the folly of everybody’s status driven home buying in most any city around the world. I think the underlying behaviour is is not limited to migrants: it is just that the migrants so clearly demonstrate how deeply irrational we all are. [edit: Stereotypically] we think of the migrants wasting money on empty houses as crazy people, without identifying with them as being exactly the same as ourselves. In fact the folly is more of a problem in developed countries because homeowners usually borrow as much money as they can to compete with others to buy a home: yet somehow a huge mortgage is not seen as irrational. Disclaimer: I have a mortgage and on paper I have done very well on house appreciation over the last few years. I believe that renting is shorting the property market because we each require 1 unit of shelter. I admit I have been long the property investment market (even worse: mortgages are highly geared investments, and you can only get mortgages similar to variable mortgages in New Zealand).
- alephnerd 4y agoI think you are misinterpreting the article and my post above, and honestly it is kind of insulting to compare first world house ownership with building unused property in your ancestral town.
- robocat 4y agoI am really sorry but I am unsure of how I was insulting. I am saying that we all have similar drives in this world, i.e. I was identifying with the migrants. You know little about me but I admit I am fairly middle class and have never lived in any kind of poverty. Perhaps you are saying I can’t empathise with the lives of the migrants? Maybe I am digging a hole here, but we are in the context of a BBC article about obscenely wealthy old mansions in Tamil Nadu, and also a British documentary by the BBC that feels condescending towards the people it presents, and perhaps an alien depiction of the relatively wealthy migrants. The doco mentions selling a hectare of field for USD400000, and a quote for building a block of flats at USD700000.