3 ms·

I don't see ads as a big problem with ChatGPT. You could put a side-bar on the right and on the fly recommend products relevant to the on-going conversation. T

I don't see ads as a big problem with ChatGPT. You could put a side-bar on the right and on the fly recommend products relevant to the on-going conversation. The cost of computing these ads would be a lot more than today's keyword-based approach, that's certainly a problem. But think of hyper-relevant ads, based on the chat itself. There's a lot of information there, that beats tracking people's behavior online all day.

HyperSane 4y ago
And you could even program the LLM to try to subtly manipulate people into using the advertised product.
- deleted 4y ago
  [deleted]
- visarga 4y ago
  A LLM trying to trick and manipulate? That's how your multi-million dollar model quickly becomes worthless in the eyes of the public.
  - HyperSane 4y ago
    Not if it was REALLY good at everything else and really subtle.
  - bigDinosaur 4y ago
    People haven't been up in arms about the dishonesty around 'native' marketing.
  - Lio 4y ago
    I could see this happening. I’ve been infuriated with DuckDuckGo on occasion because it refused to exclude certain results. In fact when you add an exclusion clause it simply boosts those results further instead of removing them. I’ve been told this is because the underlying search providers refuse to exclude paying customer even when you explicitly don’t want to hear from them. I could definitely see this happening in LLM answers too and I don’t expect it to be particularly subtle.
- flir 4y ago
  You can inline the ads. Ask it to write you a poem about flowers that includes an ad for interflora.
visarga 4y ago
> But think of hyper relevant ads That depends on ad publishers, right? If they want to sell A, B and C and I am interested in D, then Google's still showing one of A, B or C to me. D doesn't make profit if there is nobody paying for ads. Google is advertising things we don't need, that's why ad clicks are so abysmal. LLMs won't change that.

HyperSane 4y ago

And you could even program the LLM to try to subtly manipulate people into using the advertised product.

deleted 4y ago
[deleted]
visarga 4y ago
A LLM trying to trick and manipulate? That's how your multi-million dollar model quickly becomes worthless in the eyes of the public.
- HyperSane 4y ago
  Not if it was REALLY good at everything else and really subtle.
- bigDinosaur 4y ago
  People haven't been up in arms about the dishonesty around 'native' marketing.
- Lio 4y ago
  I could see this happening. I’ve been infuriated with DuckDuckGo on occasion because it refused to exclude certain results. In fact when you add an exclusion clause it simply boosts those results further instead of removing them. I’ve been told this is because the underlying search providers refuse to exclude paying customer even when you explicitly don’t want to hear from them. I could definitely see this happening in LLM answers too and I don’t expect it to be particularly subtle.
flir 4y ago
You can inline the ads. Ask it to write you a poem about flowers that includes an ad for interflora.

visarga 4y ago

> But think of hyper relevant ads That depends on ad publishers, right? If they want to sell A, B and C and I am interested in D, then Google's still showing one of A, B or C to me. D doesn't make profit if there is nobody paying for ads. Google is advertising things we don't need, that's why ad clicks are so abysmal. LLMs won't change that.