4 ms·
What you must understand is that this is human nature not "private companies." When I was in high school I had a friend who worked at one of those 1-hr photo p
by SoftTalker 4y ago
What you must understand is that this is human nature not "private companies."
When I was in high school I had a friend who worked at one of those 1-hr photo processing places. People would bring their film in to have prints made. And there were no small numbers of "intimate" photos on those rolls of film. Yes even in the days of film cameras, people took photos of themselves in sexual situations.
Of course my friend thought it was hilarious and the shop would make extra prints of these photos to pass around among the staff. They had separate categories similar to what you'd see on any porn site. Of course it was in violation of policy but people do this stuff. If you're building something that handles photo/video images you must expect it and build in privacy from the ground up. You cannot rely on your staff to always be on their best behavior.
- smodo 4y agoI assume they don’t mean that they are baffled by human nature. The thing that’s sort of unexpected is that, knowing human nature, companies don’t build in safeguards for this kind of sh.
- plagiarist 4y agoExactly so. It is repugnant that level of access was even available to a employee based on nothing but curiosity. Unfortunately another part of human nature is that most people profiting off you don't give a shit about your privacy. This is why legislation such as HIPAA has to exist.
- WalterBright 4y agoDo you really thing the people in government care about your privacy? Let's be real. Nobody cares about your (or my) privacy.
- plagiarist 4y agoIf the government gave a shit about privacy in general, Equifax would have been fined into oblivion and its owners jailed for a bit. The example is not evidence that they give a shit, it is presented as something without which our healthcare data would be traded as another commodity.
- freedomben 4y ago> Do you really thing the people in government care about your privacy? They definitely don't, but at least there is electoral pressure applied to them from constituents who they represent. In the case of private orgs it is gobble up anything you can and there's no way for regular users to hold them accountable.
- opportune 4y agoRight, so the problem is still private companies not putting in the effort to build in privacy to prevent this. For physical film it’s hard, but for software you should at the very least record access to personal data and audit it to make sure people actually need it and aren’t abusing whatever permissions they are using to get the data.
- zaroth 4y agoThe employees in this case aren’t going looking where they weren’t supposed to. This isn’t an auditing problem, like the Google/Facebook/Amazon employee snooping where they aren’t supposed to. In this case employees are tasked with watching the video clips that car owner intentionally shared with them in order to label it (draw boxes around specific objects). After spending 8 hours a day drawing boxes around fire hydrants, they would joke about the funny things they saw with their coworkers. This is literally how all human labeled AI training works. You can’t teach an AI to identify crucial features on the road without building the labeled data set to train it with. Amazon does the same thing with Alexa. Apple does the same thing with Siri. Security camera companies all do the same thing with their motion and object detection software.
- asdff 4y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2023/4/6/23672760/tesla-employees-share-vehicle-recordings-privacy https://www.theverge.com/2023/4/6/23672760/tesla-employees-s... They were sharing recordings and screenshots on internal message boards, even making memes of them. It wasn't just funny stuff either, graphic stuff too. That's far from joking around with your coworkers, even that would be totally inappropriate and worthy of termination imo.
- account42 4y ago> video clips that car owner intentionally shared with them Clicking through a we-can-do-whatever-we-want agreement is hardly the same as intentionally sharing something.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rurp 4y ago> If you're building something that handles photo/video images you must expect it and build in privacy from the ground up. I agree with this as part of a bigger solution. There should also be privacy regulations with serious consequences for negligence or abuse. If private customer data were a liability due to the risk of huge fines from misbehaving employees, companies would collect a heck of a lot less of it. Right now data collection is almost all upside for the company; there are many ways to use or sell it to make more money. But users bear the costs, many of whom don't realize just how much they are being spied on.
- dylan604 4y agoTo go further, it should also go down on someone's permanent record so that they aren't allowed to work in the same field for someone new. This shouldn't be like being a priest where you just get rotated to a new area but get to continue doing what you got in trouble for in the first place.
- _mj0m 4y agoWhen I was working for [blank] cellphone carrier we had a competing carrier fire their entire phone repair/support staff in the area because they were keeping a USB hard drive stash of nudes. Tech support staff would pass it from store to store and dump whatever nudes they'd collected from customer phone repairs that week. I don't remember how they got caught. I had to come down on multiple tech staff at our own store for digging around in photos anytime a hot woman came in with a phone. Rare occasions we had this one older women that would ask us to transfer photos every year to her new phone and to "verify personally that every photo had been moved." Of course the majority of the photos would be her naked selfies or what seemed to be swinger parties. I've got a 65yo woman in a cowboy hat only seared into my brain because I was the first tech to deal with her kink of having people look through the photos.
- JohnFen 4y ago> I had to come down on multiple tech staff at our own store for digging around in photos anytime a hot woman came in with a phone By "come down on", I hope you meant "fire".
- officeplant 4y agoWasn't in charge. Management was fully aware of the issue so all I could do was shame them.
- eternalban 4y ago> What you must understand is that this is human nature Seems no one is speaking up in the defense of humanity at large. What you describe is possibly even "common" but it is not ingrained in all of "human nature". There are many people who are simply incapable of certain transgressions - for some even the thought doesn't occur. These are possibly rare but they do exist. What you are describing is the fundamental problem of humanity: we are not a smooth and uniform distribution and practically every political thought ultimately boils down to this foundational problem of our collective but morally and ethically disjoint coexistence.
- lm28469 4y ago> What you must understand is that this is human nature not "private companies." Everything is human nature that's why we have laws and regulations You shouldn't even be able to access prod data as a simple employee, especially in payment company
- tsol 4y agoIt's kind of a social problem that's it's so normalized. This isn't the first such story I've heard
- A_non_e-moose 4y agoHuman nature? Sure, but very much lack of regulation and of good corporate privacy policies. First, customer data should be in a special, highly logged environment. Anyone logging in for whatever reason needs a justification. Next audit or periodically or if something goes wrong, those logs are checked and people confronted with why they're accessing random person X's data for no work related reason. Won't make those incidents disappear completely, but it will sure kill off fetching data from a friend of a friend for shits n giggles.