3 ms·

If they can't find the person solely responsible for something, then they got away. If you make an AI that is hooked up to the internet and it does something c

If they can't find the person solely responsible for something, then they got away. If you make an AI that is hooked up to the internet and it does something criminal, you'd be liable. You can't just let your pitbull roam the streets and not be held liable when it bites someone.

Teever 4y ago
What if I release the AI onto the internet, and then tragically die in a car accident? Who is responsible for the AI? What happens when the AI spawns more AI, who is responsible for that?
- notch898a 4y ago
  Yeah this reminds me of a thought experiment with Ethereum virtual machines. If someone writes and produces the code for tornado cash, publishes it on the internet as free speech but never deploys it obviously they are not at fault. So lets say they publish it and some anonymous person from Somalia publishes it to the Ethereum network and the nodes absorb the program. When then is responsible for the tornado cash instance? The Ethereum VM node operators who have no idea they're even running it? An unknowable person from Somalia?
  - EdwardDiego 4y ago
    Most likely the node operators would be held to be liable if they're hosting illegal content and take no steps to prevent it.
    - notch898a 4y ago
      Right now the node operators worldwide even to this day are running tornado cash on their EVM, including validating transactions to sanctioned contract addresses.
      - yokem55 4y ago
        And keep in mind, the US Treasury has said that it would issue licenses to Americans who need to be able to withdraw their legitimate funds from Tornado cash. Some validator needs to be able to process those transactions, and would have no idea whether any particular TC withdrawal is licensed or not.
- JohnFen 4y ago
  > Who is responsible for the AI? A deceased person. > What happens when the AI spawns more AI, who is responsible for that? The creator of the first copy.

Teever 4y ago

What if I release the AI onto the internet, and then tragically die in a car accident? Who is responsible for the AI? What happens when the AI spawns more AI, who is responsible for that?

notch898a 4y ago
Yeah this reminds me of a thought experiment with Ethereum virtual machines. If someone writes and produces the code for tornado cash, publishes it on the internet as free speech but never deploys it obviously they are not at fault. So lets say they publish it and some anonymous person from Somalia publishes it to the Ethereum network and the nodes absorb the program. When then is responsible for the tornado cash instance? The Ethereum VM node operators who have no idea they're even running it? An unknowable person from Somalia?
- EdwardDiego 4y ago
  Most likely the node operators would be held to be liable if they're hosting illegal content and take no steps to prevent it.
  - notch898a 4y ago
    Right now the node operators worldwide even to this day are running tornado cash on their EVM, including validating transactions to sanctioned contract addresses.
    - yokem55 4y ago
      And keep in mind, the US Treasury has said that it would issue licenses to Americans who need to be able to withdraw their legitimate funds from Tornado cash. Some validator needs to be able to process those transactions, and would have no idea whether any particular TC withdrawal is licensed or not.
JohnFen 4y ago
> Who is responsible for the AI? A deceased person. > What happens when the AI spawns more AI, who is responsible for that? The creator of the first copy.