3 ms·
> Privacy is taken extremely seriously here in Germany. On paper. But there are plenty of examples of companies doing things that they shouldn't be doing.
by jacquesm 4y ago
> Privacy is taken extremely seriously here in Germany.
On paper. But there are plenty of examples of companies doing things that they shouldn't be doing.
- bhelkey 4y agoDon't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. The important question is: what would the consequences be to a German car manufacturer given similar circumstances?
- jacquesm 4y agoGerman regulators are notoriously understaffed, see 'Wirecard'. I would not be surprised if there were no consequences at all until it hit the press or someone in a position of power was embarrassed.
- bhelkey 4y ago> I would not be surprised if there were no consequences at all until it hit the press or someone in a position of power was embarrassed. At which point the Data Protection Authorities (GDPR enforcement) would get involved. They would almost certainly levy a hefty fine against the auto manufacturer.
- jacquesm 4y agoYes indeed. It's interesting that companies are willing to take these risks, sometimes knowingly.
- nickff 4y agoMissing Wirecard seems to be a product of arrogance and incompetence. Under-staffing could have caused the regulator to overlook the fraud, but the continued obstinacy of the regulators in the face of overwhelming evidence was incompetence. Attempting to prosecute the journalists revealing the fraud was incompetent arrogance.
- natch 4y agoGiven similar circumstances to what? Having a camera that is off by default and where it is up to the user whether to turn it on or not? What exactly is the problem?
- renewiltord 4y agoProbably nothing? Because they're pretty good at cheating the rules so they don't get caught. Occasionally they get caught, but you know how it is: if you find one cockroach in your food, that probably wasn't the only cockroach in the restaurant. As far as I can tell, German companies are very good at keeping their shenanigans under wraps because they know that being caught has terrible consequences. Occasionally they slip up and then you see what a complex conspiracy they've been operating. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal
- PestoDiRucola 4y ago> what would the consequences be to a German car manufacturer given similar circumstances? Probably attempted to be hidden in collaboration with the German government like they did with Dieselgate.
- buildbot 4y agoI worked for Mercedes R&D for a bit, they absolutely do. Mistakes do happen if course.
- jacquesm 4y agoMercedes was my car of choice for decades. Then a late model one decided to phantom brake twice and put me in danger. Never again. That's the kind of thing I would expect from brands with a different reputation. That doesn't say they are playing fast and loose with privacy, and if they do not then that's a point in their favor. But their software absolutely sucks and if that passed QA then who knows what else is going on. Also: working in R&D doesn't necessarily give you insight into what operations people are up to and what kind of access they have to sensitive data. I've looked at plenty of companies in Germany and not all of them are lily white in this respect. MB may well be one of the better ones, I haven't looked at them in particular. But they use an awful lot of components from companies that have a less good reputation. And then there was this: https://dieselgate.legal/news/bosch-leaks https://dieselgate.legal/news/bosch-leaks Which mentions MB explicitly. They also had things like this happen: https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/mercedes-benz-data-breach-exposes-ssns-credit-card-numbers/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/mercedes-benz... I'll reserve judgment, but this is a less than stellar record from my perspective.