5 ms·
F-16 training for Ukrainian pilots successful: U.S. makes course “much shorter”
- exabrial 4y agoA year ago Russia had very strong words for Polish transfers for Soviet-era Mig29's being transferred to Ukraine and the idea was scrapped. Interesting to see how much has changed over the course of a year (I'm sure they're still not happy about it).
- trasz3 4y agoA year ago Russia was still widely considered to be a great military power.
- simion314 4y agoThey are not happy but they are not showing it, they put a face that the weapons civilized world delivers to Ukraine will make no difference. Surprisingly the Zeds claimed now that Finland entering NATO is not a big deal, when we Easter Europe we remember Putin and his dogs threats about entering NATO or NATO bases. There is no diplomatic talent in that country politicians.
- yks 4y agoPeople in power in Russia are gopnicks with prison values and behavior, and so is their diplomacy, when looking crazy tough and dangerous is a primal objective. Alas it works on the more civilized folks who take it at face value and try to make a deal when they don't even have to.
- rasz 4y agoWhat do you mean scrapped? Poland transferred 4 MIGs last year. Meme circulating at the time: "Polskie MiG-i nie trafią na Ukrainę. Ponadto Polska nie ma żadnych Mig-ów. Nie wiemy, skąd Ukraina ma MiG-i. Pragniemy zauważyć, że MiG-ów jest bardzo wiele i można je kupić w dowolnym sklepie z MiG-ami, na przykład na terenie Federacji Rosyjskiej." "Polish MiGs will not go to Ukraine. Moreover, Poland does not own any Migs. We do not know where Ukraine got the MiGs from. We would like to emphasize that MiGs are plentiful and can be bought in any MiG shop, for example, in the Russian Federation." and just yesterday pledged 4 more right away with another 6 being prepared, 14 total. https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/duda-poland-transfers-mig-29-145136325.html https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/duda-poland-transfers-mig-29... rofl at yahoo publishing this in lifestyle section, 'sending fighter jets to help kill russians is just a lifestyle choice in Poland yo'
- greedo 4y agoThe initial plan was in the spring of 2022. That plan was scrapped/put on hold until the recent transfer.
- YeBanKo 4y agoIirc the offer was that Poland gives Migs to Ukraine and to replenish the missing jets, the US would give either F-16 or F-22 to Poland. It was scrapped because the White House, not Russian words.
- androidbishop 4y agoUkrainians continue to impress in spite of the horrors being inflicted against their country and people by the genocidal Russian war machine. May they obtain all the advanced weapons, ammunition, and support they need to inflict a thoroughly devastating victory against their murderous oppressors.
- mrandish 4y agoCompletely aside from the geo-political/war implications, as a general data point this supports one of my pet "things I think which a lot of other people don't." In short, it's the idea that a lot of activities people usually assume require extensive (ie multi-year) training to be even somewhat capable at, can in fact, often be taught to reasonably intelligent, capable and motivated people in a much shorter amount of time. To be clear, I'm not saying that the resulting skill set is the same in all ways, it's certainly not. It's more that in an emergency scenario where higher effort is available and some compromises may become acceptable, adequate levels of competence can be achieved in a narrower subset of tasks. Especially as compared, to the alternative which is often assumed to be "doing without." A classic example is the studies which found if we suddenly needed to do many thousands more respirator intubations of chronically ill patients, veterinarians can be cross-trained to replace doctors in a week to perform around 90% of normal intubations, leaving the specially-trained doctors to handle the remaining difficult cases. Note: Vets were notably better than other seemingly more related disciplines like e-room and surgical nurses because vets do intubations on animals quite often. That direct experience has a lot of elements which transfer quite well to intubating humans. Apparently, much better than the experiences of nurses who often assist doctors in intubating humans.
- mhb 4y agoSimilarly, it might be possible to train barbers in fewer than 1500 hours: https://www.barber-license.com/rhode-island/ https://www.barber-license.com/rhode-island/
- squarefoot 4y agoWait... isn't 1500 hours the same amount required to become a civil airline pilot?
- ihatepython 4y agoAnother example might be brain surgery. Imagine a training course that will cross-train sushi-chefs to become brain surgeons.
- dragontamer 4y agoIn the long term, Ukrainians have a defensive need for fighter jets. One of the major uses of a fighter jet is "interception". That is, to fly out and patrol the skys while you think the enemy might launch an attack on your cities. When an enemy attacker (formerly an enemy bomber, but today it could be a Missile or rocket) starts to attack your city, your fighter-jets fly out and try to shoot it down. Its not always successful, but its better to leave the chance of successful interceptions open, rather than have nothing else. Of course, other defense measures (ie: missile defenses, like Patriot missiles) are useful. But Patriot missile batteries cannot fly or move. Once you place a Patriot Missile in one area, you cannot move it elsewhere (ex: If you expect the enemy to "focus fire" and try to overwhelm one area of your defenses, you can't move your Patriot missiles to guard that one area). In contrast, you _can_ fly more airplanes from around the country to defend the area of focus fire. The base level of ground defenses are there to handle the average cases... but a proper "air force" is needed to handle exceptional cases. ------------- But all due when needed. I think its obvious that the first step is to build the cheaper ground defenses around Ukraine (ex: the current Patriot missile defenses going on right now). In the long term, the F16s will probably be needed.
- fwungy 4y agoPlanes are too valuable to risk. Modern interception occurs at 100+ miles, well before visual contact. Enemy air defenses are mapped and no one will fly a plane in range of them. Planes are used to fling things at the enemy from safe positions. Air defenses are too cheap and good to risk valuable planes on. What Ukraine really needs is a massive donation of air defenses so Russia doesn't have free reign over most of Ukrainian airspace. Problem is those air defense systems don't presently exist in anyone's inventory to make a substantial contribution to Ukraine.
- greedo 4y agoRussia doesn't have free reign over Ukraine. They are flying very limited mission sets due to the threat from Ukrainian SAMs. Ukraine already has a decent AD setup with SA2/S300/NASAMs etc, and then an excellent inventory of MANPADs that forces the VKS to use their aircraft as glorified flying Katyusha launchers.
- fwungy 4y agoThis is wishful thinking backed up by dropped standards. Yes, a fighter pilot can quickly enough learn to fly another fighter in terms of basic flying functions, but a fighter is an advanced weapons system built to interact with a constellation of advanced weapons systems. Not only does a fighter pilot need to learn the particular performance features of the plane, but also the weapons systems, and then combine them in real time to have a reasonable chance of returning the plane whole in a combat environment.
- dragontamer 4y agoBut does a Ukrainian pilot need to train for all of the F16 missions? I don't think so. Some of the most difficult training missions are "Wild Weasel" roles for example... IE: The F16 being used as anti-antiair. Its dangerous mission and difficult training. But if the Ukrainians never plan to use the F16 as anti-antiair / Wild Weasel, then the training can be cut out of the routine entirely. Maybe the Ukrainians just wanna focus on missile interception, for example (IE: forming a missile shield to block out Russian rocket attacks on their cities).
- fwungy 4y agoThe problem is that F-16s are rare and expensive. If a pilot screws up due to a failure that could have been addressed with training, it's a huge loss.
- greedo 4y agoRare? It's one of the most common fighters in the world. And the cost of the airframe is moot during a war. Ukraine needs them, has pilots capable of handling it, and can learn to maintain them as needed. But the US is holding back for fears that Ukraine would use them to attack Russian territory. This is the same thinking that held back tanks for so long (and continues to hold back ATACMs). We're scared of the Russians.
- dragontamer 4y ago
- marsven_422 4y ago[dead]
- Nezghul 4y agoI don't get it why they didn't start that training year ago, even if it was not known if F-16 will be send to Ukraine or not.
- greedo 4y agoWestern advisors have both underestimated the Ukrainians and overestimated the Russians since day one. First they thought the Russians would capture Kiev in a week, then thought there would be some negotiated settlement. Plus most Western governments (other than Poland and UK) went "wobbly" as Margaret Thatcher was reported to have said. Biden's security advisors didn't want to have the conflict escalate, and much of the EU felt the same way. This led to hesitancy on providing anything that could be "offensive." Providing Stingers and Javelin were fine, but ATACMS, tanks, F-16? Nope. Only once Ukraine demonstrated both a chance of surviving and even winning did this mindset begin to change. Every Ukrainian victory or Russian defeat encouraged the West to provide more equipment and munitions. But we're still providing too little. Both Poland and the UK really deserve huge amounts of credit for their stalwart support of Ukraine (as well as the Baltic states). The US may be providing the most in terms of raw dollars, but without Poland and Ukraine pushing as hard as they have, Ukraine would be in a much tougher situation.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoWelcome to those new Ukrainian Viper pilots. :) A plane originally built in the 70's that's fly-by-wire and requires computer control since it's unlikely any human can fly the inherently unstable design. 1 engine so there's that SPoF. As but another PC joystick jockey, I played Falcon A.T. (2.0), Falcon 3.0 Gold, and Falcon 4. If I had been 4" / 10 cm shorter, I probably would've been a USAF fighter pilot rather than a startup flunkie and "engineer". F-35's intending to replace Vipers are a moneypit boondoggle. At some point, even with investment bias, that program will need to be killed because it's a POS.