I think another important distinction between today's chiplet CPUs and the Pentium D/Core 2 Quad is that those early parts were still using a traditional shared

I think another important distinction between today's chiplet CPUs and the Pentium D/Core 2 Quad is that those early parts were still using a traditional shared front side bus connecting CPU cores to the memory controller/northbridge residing on the motherboard. So those MCMs were functionally equivalent to a dual-socket system even from a performance perspective, but harder to cool. AMD's chiplet-based CPUs gain some real benefits from using faster or lower-power short-range links that would not work between separate CPU sockets, and more advanced packaging using interposers or bridges further reduce the power and performance costs of communication between chiplets. These benefits mattered even for AMD's early chiplet-based CPUs that were homogeneous rather than using a mix of specialized dies.