4 ms·
> If renewables are the solution to our energy problems, I like to think kindness and tolerance might be the solution to our political problems. Perhaps he coul
by lmm 4y ago
> If renewables are the solution to our energy problems, I like to think kindness and tolerance might be the solution to our political problems. Perhaps he could publish a master plan for that, too.
What's your basis for thinking that? If anything I'd say the weaponisation of "kindness and tolerance" to the point that it drowns out speaking the truth and calling out bad behaviour is the biggest problem with our politics.
(And as far as I can see Musk has removed the single most toxic influence on our politics by buying Twitter; even if the discourse on there is now worse than it was before, the benefit from real politicians no longer taking it seriously vastly outweighs any possible costs)
- danparsonson 4y agoThe easy answer is that weaponised kindness and tolerance are not actually kindness and tolerance - the word 'weaponised' is the differentiator.
- lmm 4y agoRefraining from ever saying anything against a person's political views is genuinely kindness, or at least it's hard to argue that it isn't. It just does more harm in other ways. The redefinition of tolerance to mean deference to other people's absurd views is a travesty IMO, but that battle has already been lost. In any case this "easy answer" is useless in practice; arguing that these policies are unkind or intolerant at best gets you debating semantics, and is usually even less effective than that.
- doctor_eval 4y ago> The redefinition of tolerance to mean deference to other people's absurd views is a travesty IMO, but that battle has already been lost. I'm not sure anything has been redefined. Tolerance is the ability to live in a world alongside people whose views you don't share. Kindness is the ability to treat those people with respect, despite disagreeing with them. It would be nice to see influential people expressing these views, instead of making things worse. It's basically impossible to provide examples without the conversation devolving, so I'll leave it there.
- danparsonson 4y agoStrawmen all round: - Refraining from ever saying anything against a person's political views is not kindness. It's possible to disagree kindly, which is indeed the point at issue here - "The redefinition of tolerance" that you mention is not tolerance, but a convenient misdirection for politicians and other talking heads to use when justifying their demonisation of whichever outgroup is currently the target. The choice is presented as either maintaining the status quo at the expense of the minority, or this twisted phantom version of tolerance that is worse for everyone, thereby shutting down honest respectful discussion.
- misssocrates 4y agoPeople thought he was in their tribe. Maybe he was. But now he's tribeless. So he's the outgroup and thus bad. That's literally the basis. I wish it were deeper, but it's not.
- danparsonson 4y agoTribeless? I thought he was pretty hardcore Republican?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- foderking 4y agohes anything but a hard-core republican. iirc he has always voted democrat unril not long ago
- epgui 4y agoAnd yet almost everything he says on Twitter is highly indicative of the contrary, so who knows what he really thinks.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ROTMetro 4y agoRupert Murdoch, the guy Elon spent the Super Bowl with, might know a bit of his position.
- godelski 4y agoI'm lost, are you talking about Trump or Elon?
- mlindner 4y agoHe voted for Obama, Clinton and Biden, so no, not really.
- robinson7d 4y agoWeaponized “kindness” sounds a little bit oxymoronic to me, would what’s being weaponized not be closer to “niceness”? Unless it’s second-order / indirect through people meaning well.
- hirundo 4y agoA non-paradoxical variation: "We wish to be kind to party A, the good people, but to do that we must be mean to party B, the bad people."