10 ms·
The Case for Banning Crypto
- saurik 4y agoMany of the arguments made here (not all, but that's a separate argument: "but this other argument would still stand" is not a valid defense of a poor argument and it is important to whittle the set down to the ones that are actually strong) are the same arguments people make against private communication technology. So, yes: it is more efficient to not have to encrypt everything, and yes: it is more difficult to deal with spam when everything is encrypted, and yes: building a system that is decentralized is hard, and yes: anything you build that is decentralized can be built more easily and maybe even more "safely"--for even an actually-reasonable definition of "safe"--by some centralized entity, and yes: a fully decentralized and private communication platform would absolutely be used by at least some terrible actors to accomplish terrible things that might be made more difficult if that platform did not exist... ...but, no: just because something is more expensive or more difficult to pull off doesn't mean it isn't worth the cost, and no: just because some terrible actors use a platform that doesn't justify taking it away from all users, and no: just because previous attempts at something have failed it should be illegal to attempt to pursue the technology. If you make an argument that implies a kind of centralized control over things being good because privacy (which this article claims cryptocurrency provides--and it can, just not using Bitcoin--so if you want to quibble about that you are actually arguing against the authors of the article, not me, as many of their points seem to rely on this privacy at least mostly working) is an inherently dangerous thing to offer people, and when I call my bank there 100% should be a person there looking at my billing history getting to judge me for the things I buy and the places I shop and what those things imply about my sexual orientation (maybe you see me going to a specific bar a lot) or the medical conditions I have (based on the medications I am buying or the clinics I visit)... ...well, I would then want you to look in a mirror and really ask yourself is that's the kind of person you want to be, as I am going to claim that privacy is a thing we need to be offering all users even if there are costs and to the extent to which the current banking system and financial system fails to operate if people are granted such privacy, that's on them, not on us. You can't sit around and claim that people should get to have end-to-end encrypted secure blinded "communication" with their physician and then simply refuse to blind all of the financial transactions that leak a lot of that same secret information.
- colesantiago 4y agoWe should ban crypto anyway. It was a nice grift but it needs to stop. We are almost edging to 16+ years and there is no legitimate use case at all, except only the worst kind, (Speculation, Ransomware Enablement, Funding North Korea, etc..) And before you mention the 3rd world needs crypto as a "usecase", India, Brazil and other countries have real time payment systems such as UPI, Pix, PayNow that work and are used in the hundreds of millions, almost infinitely way more than crypto is. Crypto is a alleged 'solution' eternally searching for a problem. Some recommended reading: https://web3isgoinggreat.com/ https://web3isgoinggreat.com/ https://web3.lifeitself.org/guide https://web3.lifeitself.org/guide
- saurik 4y agoSo, I want to be very clear about this, as I don't think you should get to just sidestep this point as if it doesn't matter, and this is where the rubber hits the morality for me: are you seriously saying you believe that private money should simply not exist and that "when I call my bank there 100% should be a person there looking at my billing history getting to judge me for the things I buy and the places I shop and what those things imply about my sexual orientation (maybe you see me going to a specific bar a lot) or the medical conditions I have (based on the medications I am buying or the clinics I visit)"? As it stands, your comment seems to come off as the kind of authoritarian viewpoint that the narrative of the first world supposedly bristles against (even as it then pushes ridiculous agendas to build out the surveillance state... which I guess is you, huh ;P).
- colesantiago 4y agoAs long as crypto gets regulated out of existence, Yes. As long as the crypto exchanges collapses, Yes. As long as we are building better alternatives that are actually in use such as UPI, Pix and the like, Yes. As long as we as a society reject the crypto pyramid schemes and stop allowing more people to join it and in turn losing their life savings completely, Yes. As long as long as crypto dies and withers out of interest, then YES. We have tried private money before in the US and other countries and it completely failed. You mention 'first world narratives' I don't see India complaining about payment issues or surveillance. See for yourself: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/01/business/india-digital-payments-upi.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/01/business/india-digital-pa... Not a single mention of crypto, decentralisation, web3 or any useless crypto technobabble at all. Just damn well engineered real time payments that 300M+ people are using in the real world. https://navendu.me/posts/upi-vs-crypto/ https://navendu.me/posts/upi-vs-crypto/ This is where the future is headed, not crypto.
- rubychill 4y agohttps://archive.is/2O5qb https://archive.is/2O5qb
- protocolture 4y ago> The root of the problem is that cryptocurrency assets can be created at no cost and without limit, and an unlimited supply of assets makes a system more vulnerable to booms and busts. Theres more of a limit in your average crypto asset than any government bank. > When assets have nothing behind them, no reliable financial accounting practices or valuation techniques exist to expose the fraudulent manipulation of those assets. Again this may as well be a hidden hit piece against government fiat.
- protocolture 4y ago> Cryptocurrencies already facilitate many different kinds of harm. Pariah states, including Iran and North Korea, use cryptocurrencies, and the anonymity that they grant, to evade sanctions and launder money. Oh no a large government cant push other peoples money around boo hoo >Cryptocurrencies, particularly Bitcoin, have become the most common form of payment for the ransomware attacks increasingly targeting businesses and public services because it allows the nefarious actors behind these attacks to receive large amounts of money quickly and anonymously. Yes, and theres still orders of magnitude more crime occurring with cash >Blockchain-based finance is complex, automated, and highly interconnected, and it offers vast opportunities for creating leverage, because there is a virtually unlimited supply of assets to borrow against. These are the kind of fragilities that led to the last financial crisis, in 2008. Surely this outs the author as pro crypto, the 2008 crisis lead to the development of crypto. >Despite the industry’s claims, most of those who invested in cryptocurrency have lost money. Those already disillusioned with traditional finance are likely to become even more cynical after their cryptocurrency losses, and this cynicism may have further consequences. Everyone already hates it, so no need for a ban then
- uejfiweun 4y agoI mean, honestly, the fact that all these crypto guys are eagerly cheering on the decline of the US dollar and the collapse of the economy, in order to facilitate a transition to crypto, kind of indicates to me that the whole project has grown into a serious risk to the stability of the economy and our society.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 4y agoI don't understand modern Western politics on any level. It seems as if it's just completely been co-opted by some force that's trying to make it as inscrutable and counterproductive as possible. We're supposed to accept arbitrary genders, stop eating meat, stop driving cars, stop using cash, etc. But oh, let's ban cryptocurrency, because we can't have diversity in anything that actually matters. These people are in another galaxy from me. Every justification they give for everything, to me feels like a reason to do completely the opposite. It's utterly insane.
- tiedieconderoga 4y agoMaybe you do understand it. Why'd you pick out impending restrictions on gender, meat, cars, and cash? Are those pressing issues in your daily life, or things that you hear and read about a lot? The important thing it that you keep ignoring the chemical spills and inflation behind the curtain.
- xigoi 4y agoWhat is hard to understand about “the climate is changing for the worse because of the heavy usage of fossil fuels, so we need to limit using them as much as possible”?
- syntheweave 4y agoThis article imagines that states are more powerful than networks. They aren't. Networks - people networks, trade networks, electronic networks - get the final say in what states do and don't enforce. It was this way with the project of free trade and markets - a gradual succumbing of monarchs to capitalists through encroachment on the legal and power structures. So too is it likely to be with crypto networks - they have to fail by disinterest, not by enforcement. The definition of what finance should or should not be is not theraputic(in the Wittgenstein sense) to the underlying goals represented by the technology, which simply records and persists a shared account of transactions. Every time you have such a system, the market will pop up around it like a weed and invent some kind of game of value exchange to play, productive or not. A ban redirects attention back towards the core functions of crypto, and can discourage it as a speculative instrument - but it doesn't make it stop existing until you remove the last node, and the cost of doing that is staggering. So it's a very safe assumption to guess that it's here to stay, whether in a public and visible role or in the shadows.
- makingstuffs 4y agoCrypto does not need to be banned. The issue which needs resolving in the space is the complete lack of action from large players when it comes to recovering misappropriated funds. I recently wrote an article about this and proposed what I think is a feasible starting point for the discussion. Granted, in situations like FTX it would be ineffective but those situations are not the norm. For those regulation needs to happen. Crypto is not bad, there is a global smear campaign by those who would be negatively impacted by a globally available payment system which is not controlled by the current cartel.
- regularjack 4y ago> those who would be negatively impacted by a globally available payment system which is not controlled by the current cartel. You can include myself in that group. I would rather have my government control the currency I use, than some random miners in whatever location across the planet.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- voldacar 4y ago>The root of the problem is that cryptocurrency assets can be created at no cost and without limit, and an unlimited supply of assets makes a system more vulnerable to booms and busts. Hmm, this sounds familliar. What else can be created at no cost and without limit? Booms and busts... that also seems to ring a bell
- Awelton 4y agoCrypto and fiat have the same exact downsides. The only difference is in who is getting rich. The federal reserve also creates a currency that is backed by nothing and has an unlimited supply. Bitcoin didn't make groceries 40% more expensive, the 'experts' did.