4 ms·
> Sure, but it prevents everyone from getting what they should get from J&J in that scenario. There's no way to give everyone what they're owed if there isn't
by lmm 4y ago
> Sure, but it prevents everyone from getting what they should get from J&J in that scenario.
There's no way to give everyone what they're owed if there isn't enough money to go around. An orderly procedure is better than everyone rushing in with sharp elbows, and that's exactly why we have bankruptcy laws and courts - a system that works very well on the whole.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> There's no way to give everyone what they're owed if there isn't enough money to go around. There's at least more money (significantly so!) in J&J as a whole than one of J&J's subsidiaries. If my teenager had a car accident and injured you, I don't get to spin them off into a new standalone family unit and say "gee, sorry, you can't sue me!"
- lmm 4y ago> There's at least more money (significantly so!) in J&J as a whole than one of J&J's subsidiaries. No there isn't. 61.5 billion in this subsidy, while the equity value of the whole company is 76.8 billion. > If my teenager had a car accident and injured you, I don't get to spin them off into a new standalone family unit and say "gee, sorry, you can't sue me!" Depends where you are; in a lot of states you wouldn't be liable.
- ceejayoz 4y agoJ&J's market cap is a bit over $400B, with assets in the nearly $200B range. I guarantee you the talc subsidiary isn't 80% of J&J's total value. > Depends where you are; in a lot of states you wouldn't be liable. Take one of those states, then. In California, the parent is civilly liable if they granted the teen permission to drive the car. Should disowning your kid be a viable way out of that?
- lmm 4y ago> In California, the parent is civilly liable if they granted the teen permission to drive the car. Should disowning your kid be a viable way out of that? I mean, we have plenty of stories of people divorcing to avoid liability for their partner's medical/end-of-life care costs. So this stuff isn't limited to companies.