5 ms·
San Francisco has been ceding its monopoly of violence for years if not decades. Trends suggest otherwise: https://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-cal
by anigbrowl 4y ago
San Francisco has been ceding its monopoly of violence for years if not decades.
Trends suggest otherwise: https://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/ https://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/
The big peak in violent crime in the 1990s is the crack epidemic. I personally saw driveby shooting attacks and personal murders in broad daylight; 24th street (and the Mission in general) used to be considered a no-go area by folk in better-off neighborhoods.
It seems to me that the basic problem in SF is wealth disparity. The city is a great place to make money if you are in the finance or tech industries and have decent social skills. But the wealth that stays in SF tends to build upward rather than lift up less well off neighborhoods. Not only is housing expensive, community space for weird stores/art galleries/music events is also at a premium, which severely limits avenues for grey market enterprise and social mixing/mobility. The unorganized crime exists because regular jobs are not that profitable and there's a large and deliberately-created (at the federal level) underclass of undocumented people with no straightforward path to legal workforce participation.
SF was a remarkably different city prior to 9-11, which ushered in a securocratic mindset in many respects. A simple but telling example is that nearly BART stations used to have toilets, though as you might expect some of them were nasty. After 9-11, these were closed in the name of security, a 'temporary' situation which has persisted for over 20 years. Concession stands like news/candy/flower vendors gradually vanished too, along with buskers. Subway stations stopped being part of the city's social life in favor of pure transit functionality. Likewise bus stops now have all sorts of built-in tech to tell you when the next bus is arriving in 20 different languages, but the bus shelters are deliberately constructed not to provide any shelter from the elements, or even make it easy to sit down.
The state (qua city government) very much maintains its monopoly on violence; police budgets have gone up rather than down. It's just selectively enforced because the police are themselves a political constituency who compete with other agencies for funding.
https://abc7news.com/sfpd-budget-defund-the-police-department-funding/12321818/ https://abc7news.com/sfpd-budget-defund-the-police-departmen...
- beambot 4y ago> But the wealth that stays in SF tends to build upward rather than lift up less well off neighborhoods. How do you square this statement with gentrification? Feels like a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation...
- xvedejas 4y agoI think people are realizing more and more that failure to build up is a failure to help less well-off neighborhoods. The bad part of gentrification is displacement, not that some buildings might look new and desirable. SF politicians still need to learn this lesson.
- beambot 4y ago> failure to build up is a failure to help less well-off neighborhoods How - like tangible, tactical recommendations that have the political willpower to get enacted?
- xvedejas 4y agoThere's been a lot of tangible, tactical legislation that is just gearing up, so I'm optimistic. Look at the record of state senator Scott Wiener. He's proven there's political will in areas that seemed hopeless ten years ago.
- arcticbull 4y agoI'd be careful with any crime stats other than like, murder stats. The problem is that people are less likely to report crimes if they don't think they're going to be prosecuted. There's many anecdotes of people asking for police help and they just tell them not to bother. > In April [2022], [...] the dept issued 338 tickets for traffic violations. By comparison, in April 2014, the year Vision Zero began, the department issued 11,612 tickets. Does that mean nobody violates traffic laws in SF anymore? Of course not. But if the tickets aren't issued they're not rolled up into stats. Same with all sorts of violent and property crime. When I lived in the mid-mission a few years ago I had to call in a shooting that happened outside my bedroom window. There were a ton of violent altercations between pimps and prostitutes that were just straight-up ignored. And 24th St became an open-air Walgreens. > The letter highlighted alarming data backing up many residents’ concerns that police have thrown up their hands. For example, last year the Department of Police Accountability opened 595 cases into alleged police wrongdoing; the largest share by far, 42.6%, related to “neglect of duty.” That percentage has ticked up steadily since 2016, when neglect of duty made up 32% of complaints. [1] [edit] Your own source seems to back that up. Your source is for all of California, not SF. And one of the big sub-headings is "crime rates vary dramatically by region and category" and specifically calls out SF as having an outsized quantity of property crime. > The state’s highest rate of violent crime was in the San Joaquin Valley, which had 640 violent incidents per 100,000 residents. The highest rate of property crime was in the San Francisco Bay Area, at 2,718 per 100,000 residents. [1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/bayarea/heatherknight/article/sf-police-crime-16931399.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/bayarea/heatherknight/article...
- anigbrowl 4y agoThat's why I addressed violent crime specifically, where reporting is much more reliable.
- alfalfasprout 4y agoIs it? I know of two armed rape cases in SF proper where the police refused to even file a report. Anecdotal yes, but bottom line is officers are encouraged to not report things. Unless there's a body there's enough anecdotal evidence out there to suggest coverage might not be all that perfect.
- JPKab 4y ago> It seems to me that the basic problem in SF is wealth disparity. Really? > police budgets have gone up rather than down. And what do you think the police are supposed to do when the prosecutions by the DA fall off a cliff? Don't you think that maybe, just maybe, if the number of cops remains unchanged, but the percentage of criminals they detain being arraigned/charged/arrested drops, that maybe, just maybe, crime will go up? The cognitive dissonance is just unbelievable here.
- Talanes 4y agoExcept they mostly skip the detain step in favor of complaining that the latter steps totally would have been messed up had they actually tried to do their job.
- wolverine876 4y agoMaybe provide evidence rather than exaggerated statements and attacks (a signal of lack of evidence). Inform us: What are the stats on DA prosecutions - I've heard that claim in other places about progressive DAs, and they turned out to be false. Also, it's not clear to me that crime goes up if prosecutions go down; it's possible, but it's possible that looking at all arrests the same, for every alleged crime, is meaningless; it's possible that more arrests means worse cases; it's possible police are providing worse evidence, or the distribution of crime types has changed, or criminals have no idea of crime stats and have other motivations. Is there some correlation you can point to?
- JPKab 4y agoThe stats on the previous DAs dramatic reduction in prosecutions are publicly available via Google search. If you actually cared about interrogating your own beliefs you would look this up yourself but you don't. I don't waste time arguing with far left ideologues. It's like talking to fundamentalist Christians about evolution: wasted time. Your statement about it not being clear that crime goes up if less criminals are prosecuted is the most unintentionally hilarious thing I've seen in a long time. Do you even realize how utterly lacking in common sense the statement is?
- sammalloy 4y ago> The big peak in violent crime in the 1990s is the crack epidemic. I personally saw driveby shooting attacks and personal murders in broad daylight; 24th street (and the Mission in general) used to be considered a no-go area by folk in better-off neighborhoods. You have your dates and anecdotes off. The crack epidemic was in the 1980s, not the 1990s. There was, however, always a serious heroin trade in that area. After the gang truce in 1992, the Mission was incredibly safe and a great place to live. Going to the bars after work and spilling out into the streets after 2 am was a safe and peaceful affair. Further, a lot of the property crime that people are complaining about has nothing to do with locals; it was perpetrated by organized gangs from outside the city. This is still true today and several investigative news articles on this phenomenon have been published recently. The Mission was never a "no go" area by people who lived in the city. It was an incredibly vibrant place to live and work, with great bars, restaurants, stores, and culture. In many ways, the Mission is the heart of San Francisco given its centralized location and history. For anyone to describe it as a no go area reveals that they never lived there and know nothing about it. That all changed when the tech bros moved out from the Midwest and East coast and chased all the artists out of the city. These people who were forced out were the people who actually cared about their communities and helped each other out and were the spirit and life blood of what the city was in its heart and soul. Now the new blood doesn’t like the new city they helped create, but of course, it’s always someone else’s fault.
- anigbrowl 4y agoNo I don't. The crack epidemic continued well into the 90s. I lived in the Mission at the time, loved it, and know the area like the back of my hand. It was a normal thing to get offered crack by 5 different people while walking down 24th from Mission to Harrison; I could BART over there and give you a walking tour of local crimes I personally witnessed. I grew up in a rough town so it didn't bother me much. For anyone to describe it as a no go area reveals that they never lived there and know nothing about it. ...which was why I said it was considered that way 'by folk in better off neighborhoods.' People who lived in places like North Beach or the Marina were horrified by it. You are right about the influx of tech people during the first boom (along with the finance bros, though those have shaped SF in various ways since the gold rush) pushing people out. By the 1990s Haight/Ashbury had already become an unaffordable tourist trap with most of the fancy victorian houses being super expensive. In contrast SoMa was a much more industrial than it is today, with enough turnover that there were always empty spaces that could be rented or borrowed for a rave.
- WillPostForFood 4y agoIt seems to me that the basic problem in SF is wealth disparity. You own data suggests otherwise https://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/ https://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/ The peak in violent crime was the 90s. The peak of property crime was 80s, and there were 40 years of crime decline at the exact same time wealth disparity was growing. What changed recently was the new lax attitude on crime, decarceration, and hated towards the police. Truth is, San Francisco did not follow the pattern of the rest of CA and saw rising murders through the 2000's. It finally declined in 2009 after a huge federal and local crackdown on gangs and MS13 in San Francisco.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI'm not arguing that inequality explains all crime, I thought it was clear from the contrast I drew between previous decades and the present that I was talking about it being the main driver of present-day crime (whereas economic mobility and housing space availability was better a couple of decades ago). Sorry for not articulating that more clearly.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nyarlathotep_ 4y ago> It seems to me that the basic problem in SF is wealth disparity. Indeed, I hate when wealth disparity breaks into my car.