5 ms·
New study reports 1 in 5 adults don't want children, and don't regret it later
- sublinear 4y ago> Many adults are child-free, and there do not seem to be differences by age, education or income I find the lack of correlation with income surprising. My own experience has been that people of lower income tend to have more kids when they do and are more likely to be stuck in codependent relationships. My perspective has always been that higher income individuals don't regret skipping kids because they have their investments to take care of them in old age, they're happier because they had better control of their finances and time throughout their life, and they aren't necessarily lonely because high income individuals tend to find each other and can keep it casual indefinitely... I guess I'm wrong, or is Michigan not as good of a sample as the article believes?
- than3 4y agoIt is not really surprising at all. There is very little hope for a free future, and that won't change because too much profit backs it. All the corporations care for is profit and coercion, all the politican's care for is increasing power and grandstanding. There is no actual representation left, and politicians don't see inaction as violating oaths they swore. The previous generation grew up having certain minimal things, and then proceeded to enrich themselves, and remove those same opportunities from future generations. Generations since have come to find out the many of these promises were not true, they were lied to and not only that, they were stolen from on a grand scale to fund benefits that only benefit one aging generation (social security). People have choices, and for a growing number of people, they find it would be inhumane to bring a child into a world where that child would be no better than a slave and suffer. Hence we are seeing the last generation for a lot of intelligent people. The way things are going, we are headed for an inevitable collapse on scale never before seen. A railroad track going off a cliff, and we are racing down it at full speed. Without the most modern technology, we can only feed 2-4 billion max. When things break, and they will because current systems are engineered to be brittle with single points of failure because that is most profitable, at least half dies. Who would ever wish this on their children, let alone engineer it such that the people that want to stop it are prevented from doing so (for profit)? Its a race to the bottom, where only the ruthless, unethical, and lucky survive.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ChainOfFools 4y ago> Hence we are seeing the last generation for a lot of intelligent people The opening montage of the distressingly precient Idiocracy is literally an illustration of this premise. The message is that the world gets into the state that it is 5 centuries later based on a dramatic shift in who's having children in the present era. Spoiler alert, it's not the intelligent people.
- kwere 4y agojust rational suicide with extra steps fueled by fears that arent based on reality, even if tomorrow we end up in a nuclear winter, who could survive will have a better life than our ancestors 8k years ago.
- psychphysic 4y agoYour reasoning is common but flawed. Humans do not have an objective way to rate their subjective judgement of quality of life.
- sneed_chucker 4y ago[flagged]
- than3 4y ago[flagged]
- sneed_chucker 4y ago[flagged]
- antifa 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tmnvix 4y agoI've often wondered how many people do regret having children. I imagine it would be hard to come up with reliable statistics - nobody would want to admit that out loud.
- psychphysic 4y agoI agree it's tricky. Having kids doesn't seem like the kind of thing you can really judge without having had kids. Especially since you're basically manipulated by biology once the process starts.
- DaveExeter 4y agoSome of them admit it on the internet. https://www.reddit.com/r/regretfulparents/ https://www.reddit.com/r/regretfulparents/
- adamredwoods 4y agoI think that it is difficult without a support network. Having extended families and a large property helps, and as a society we're moving away from both. I can see parental regret increasing for those struggling.
- preommr 4y agoYou'd also have to factor in the personality of the kid. Some kids are so much easier to raise, it's not always a fair comparison.
- throwntoday 4y agoTheir personality is a direct product of their environment. Shit parents make shit kids, it's nothing short of a miracle when a kid somehow sidesteps that fate and comes out a better person than their parents.
- projectazorian 4y agoThat’s very simplistic; there are way too many variables at play to make such a sweeping assertion. For one thing, most children born in the 80s (and especially the late 80s onward) had very little lead exposure in childhood, while almost all of their parents did.
- spacedcowboy 4y agoI never used to think I wanted kids, until I had a kid. Life-changing doesn't even begin to describe it. Everything changes.
- DaveExeter 4y agoFor better or for worse?
- adamredwoods 4y agoBoth. It's the journey that counts, and it's a difficult one.
- spacedcowboy 4y agoThe first few months were a living hell, compounded by myself and my wife not living close to family. Knowing its on you, and only on you can be hard. Ever since then it's been pretty good... Now he's 11, it's all about him figuring stuff out, and it's kind of awesome to see the thinking going on when he's trying for malicious compliance... Which I let him get away with, as long as it's within the rules he was given. No better way to train a brain :)
- JohnFen 4y agoSome changes are definitely worse, and some are better. Overall, my experience is that it's a net win.
- viggos_son 4y agoIt's like running a startup. Hard but fulfilling. You don't do a startup because it was going to be easy. Highs and lows. In both cases you are crafting something deeply personal. Both take commitment and sheer will. Having the right co-founder is paramount.
- doubled112 4y agoWhat if you don't find it fulfilling? What is left?
- Waterluvian 4y ago> We found that 20.9% of adults in Michigan do not want children, which closely matches our earlier estimate of 21.6%, and means that over 1.6 million people in Michigan are child-free. For the sake of unwanted children, I wish it worked that way. The article, at least, seems to conflate a bunch of things. It’s bizarre to read.
- adamredwoods 4y agoN = 1000 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0283301 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... >> Focusing on adults aged 70 or older, we find that parents express more life regret (M = 3.87, SE = 0.20) than childfree adults (M = 3.30, SE = 0.39), but that the difference is not statistically significant (t127 = 1.29, p = 0.20). This suggests that childfree adults do not experience more life regret than parents in their late years of life.
- ttymck 4y agoDecent sample size. Sample was pretty heavily weighted towards parents, though. Is "life regret" a 1-5 discrete measurement? I'd like to see the distribution of sample measurements. p=0.2 feels strong enough for me to at least consider the possibility of no children == more regret (correlated, if not causal)
- bscphil 4y ago> p=0.2 feels strong enough for me to at least consider the possibility of no children == more regret You got the correlation backwards. In their sample, parents experienced more regret.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- sabarn01 4y agoThe issue is that you are not the same person 30 years later. I am not the same person I was before I had kids. What am I regretting? I find the premise here based upon the idea that there is some magical set of choices you can make to have the perfect life and regret is assessing your delta from that perfect life. The whole concept seems flawed.
- draw_down 4y ago[dead]
- KyeRussell 4y agoThere’s such a weird culture around the childfree “movement” that at this point I’m just tired of having to read between the lines of all the weird elitism. This article does seem to be a bit all over the place.
- piloto_ciego 4y agoI have also seen some eugenics vibes from those folks in the past too, so that’s not unsurprising. If you don’t want kids don’t have them, but begrudging those who do is folly.
- rayiner 4y agoIn other news, 99% of people don’t want to pay their taxes.
- SMAAART 4y agoIndeed I am one of them. It would be interesting to add to that: % of people who regret having kids That's a statistic I'd like to see.
- xen2xen1 4y agoDepends on the day.
- kwere 4y agofunnily most welfare societies are finding out that without childrens or a good enough replacement rate their systems cant function financially. Immigration, taxes, deficit spending cant substitute healthy demographics. Such trends will wreack (european & chinese) economies, especially in real estate and consumer goods, tanking a lot of networths. Childrens are still the best retirement fund, just in a more abstract way
- sneed_chucker 4y agoDownvoted, but I'm not sure why. The demographics question is one that every industrialized country is going to have to face. East Asia and Europe will have to reckon with it first, but the same trends are playing out in North and South America, South and West Asia, etc
- than3 4y ago> ..., but I'm not sure why. If you'd read the rules when you signed up (as we all are required to), you'd have noticed its against HN rules to comment about votes. Secretly I think they have a bot that goes and does it based on keywords, but I haven't gotten any confirmation. It happens, and breaking the rules typically will cause you to lose karma. You have to be careful with a new account because if your karma goes negative your posts get auto hidden, and if its beyond -5 you may have the account go dead and it will be closed. Its just how it is.