3 ms·
In this thread everyone blaming homeless and the poor without any context of who the perpetrator is. It’s a big leap from shoplifting to a stabbing/murder. Also
by vlovich123 4y ago
In this thread everyone blaming homeless and the poor without any context of who the perpetrator is. It’s a big leap from shoplifting to a stabbing/murder. Also consider that even if the shoplifting/car break ins is being committed by the poor, they could be being directed by organized crime which is quite active in the area (look at the high profile heists in downtown that occurred in the past few years). The car break-ins in particular are as I understand it primarily organized crime not the homeless.
- hnburnsy 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_windows_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_windows_theory
- butt____hugger 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_windows_theory#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_windows_theory#Criticis...
- vlovich123 4y agoOh I understand that. The sad part is that the evidence is extremely limited and careful experiments done to empirically validate it have failed with other more plausible alternatives provided (see the criticism section). The most compelling one to me is that the cities that applied this theory and the ones that didn’t saw similar decrease in crime suggesting an overall downward trend that couldn’t be attributed to this theory. That’s basically an A/B test at scale that fails to find anything. Also: > Baltimore criminologist Ralph B. Taylor argues in his book that fixing windows is only a partial and short-term solution. His data supports a materialist view: changes in levels of physical decay, superficial social disorder, and racial composition do not lead to higher crime, but economic decline does. He contends that the example shows that real, long-term reductions in crime require that urban politicians, businesses, and community leaders work together to improve the economic fortunes of residents in high-crime areas. That sounds like the theory has cause and effect reversed and treating the effect does not actually address the underlying cause. If your wood beam is rotting, a fresh coat of paint can help but at some point it will collapse. > In the winter 2006 edition of the University of Chicago Law Review, Bernard Harcourt and Jens Ludwig looked at the later Department of Housing and Urban Development program that rehoused inner-city project tenants in New York into more-orderly neighborhoods.[25] The broken windows theory would suggest that these tenants would commit less crime once moved because of the more stable conditions on the streets. However, Harcourt and Ludwig found that the tenants continued to commit crime at the same rate. Oh look, another controlled A/B experiment that fails to validate anything. > In his 2012 book Uncontrolled: The Surprising Payoff of Trial-and-Error for Business, Politics, and Society, Jim Manzi writes that of the randomized field trials conducted in criminology, only nuisance abatement per broken windows theory has been successfully replicated So the only thing we can link it to is nuisance calls. All that work and hassling for a super minor win. It’s impossible to scientifically prove something but there’s enough holes to indicate that this theory provides an exceedingly poor model for crime. It’s also easy to consider a hypothetical scenario where one person or a small group of people steals all the money in the neighborhood such that everyone is poor and can barely feed themselves, if that. The poor now need to steal and commit crimes to feed themselves and their families and cause disorder by using drugs too try to escape their situation / self-medicate. Would broken windows policing actually accomplish anything when the root cause is that the money was stolen from the area?
- vorpalhex 4y agoCrime requires force. If you are stealing stuff, especially ala mugging, you need a threat. It's a short jump to actually stabbing someone. This wasn't some kind of hitman assassination.
- ashwagary 4y agoYou are assuming there is no motive for someone in his circle or that he personally knows to commit this kind of crime.
- tofuahdude 4y agoOccam's razor is a safe starting point for this situation.
- ashwagary 4y agoBob worked at a key position at one of the largest crypto exchanges in the world and later a mid-sized exchange. >Occam's razor is a safe starting point for this situation. The simplest explanation is he wasn't targeted and it was just a random mugging where he didnt want to hand over a few $1000s in belongings under the threat of violence?
- vorpalhex 4y agoViolent situations are not logical negotiations. People react in fight or flight (both the attacker and the defender!). But yes, it is absolutely the most likely occurrence that an obviously wealthy exec, an older man, was an easy mark for a random mugging gone wrong at the wee hours than some crypto bro plotted an assassination. "Mugging gone wrong, someone got stabbed" is a very, very common situation. Also note that he lived to receive initial aid and perished on the way to the hospital - it's not like he was shot and stuffed in a car trunk.
- octernion 4y agodang man you are so right. so smart. wow.
- ashwagary 4y ago>In this thread everyone blaming homeless and the poor without any context of who the perpetrator is. You are right. Nothing in the report points to the demographic being blamed in the majority of comments. It could be a person in his circle, a stalker, or even a rich drug dealer that stabbed this guy. Non-premeditated street crime is generally among the least of the dangers a crypto industry exec is exposed to. Pinning it on the homeless is a bit premature.
- Jackie4Chan 4y agointerestingly these type of comments are being greyed out while top comments are happy comments with trees and little bushes.