3 ms·
Making laws is the backup case. Of course they're not experts in social media. They're not experts in anything. They're elected democratically. Democracy is al
by jfengel 4y ago
Making laws is the backup case. Of course they're not experts in social media. They're not experts in anything.
They're elected democratically. Democracy is also the worst possible solution, putting something to a vote rather than reaching the correct conclusion. It's the backup plan, for resolving disputes we can't resolve any other way.
There's a saying: regulations are written in blood. Every law on the books (especially regulatory law) traces back to some case where somebody was injured or killed. If they had installed the safeguards themselves, it wouldn't have come to the attention of regulators.
I've heard countless companies complain about the burden of regulations. They never seem to remember history: that regulation exists because you, or one of your competitors, killed somebody.
If the social media companies don't want to be regulated by ignorant lawmakers, they should regulate themselves. As it is, they still have a huge hand in forming those regulations. That's what lobbyists are for, and it's a valid way to engage in the process.
But like democracy, it's the worst way. The Congress wasn't elected because they know anything about anything. They rely on interested parties to come tell them about it. That means industries, consumer groups, academics, etc. shepherded by professionals that we call "lobbyists". It's ugly and wrong-headed, and only to be done when they can't or won't do it themselves.
It would be great if we had a philosopher-king with expertise in social media to write the rules. If the industry thinks that they are those philosopher-kings, they should be writing the rules themselves. Failing to do that is why they are here, and I don't have a lot of sympathy for them.