3 ms·
> Like I read your comment. I had thoughts during that process, but I read until the end, then I made a decision about what I thought, and that decision contain
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
> Like I read your comment. I had thoughts during that process, but I read until the end, then I made a decision about what I thought, and that decision contained all the information that I want to convey in my response.
I recognize that mode. I have it to. I had it now; this comment is aiming to transmit a thought that came to me fully formed while reading your response. That said, it's a bit suspect how it popped up as if my mind was doing an associative search. It's also interesting that, however fully formed the thought might have been, it's also small, as if a conceptual token, and I usually have to run further associative lookups to extend it before the comment (or train of thought) feels satisfactory to me.
In the previous paragraph, the last two sentences were not part of expressing the fully-formed thought described earlier. I'm not lying to you, it's just I didn't expect to write the second half of the previous paragraph (and this paragraph) when I was writing the first one; they came from conceptual autocomplete.
> That instantaneous understanding may change during the process of articulation, but not fundamentally
For me, it quite often does. I rely on it happening often. Example cases:
- On HN, I post maybe 1/3 of the comments I write. 2/3 of the time, the act of trying to express my thoughts makes me realize that a) I'm wrong, and/or b) it's a bad idea to continue (e.g. I'm just procrastinating, or posting something impolite, or not useful, etc.). Of the 1/3 that survive long enough to be posted, I still delete some - as sometimes the realization from the previous sentence hits me only a couple seconds after posting.
- When facing difficult problems, I do a lot of internal monologue. In it, exploring whether certain phrases feel right, and kind of sculpting the chain of thought, is a critical part of the process.
- Because I often feel I lack the working memory to keep enough thoughts in flight, I often "talk" with myself via a text file - externalizing my internal monologue. That process also involves sculpting sentences, paragraphs or bullet points until they feel right, so it's arguably still articulation. And the more I think about it, the more this looks to me like the kind of tricks you do to work around the token limit / window of GPT-3 / GPT-4...
EDIT:
Ultimately, I think we're both doing thinking in similar ways, perhaps with different proportions between modes, and different conception of it.
One relevant conceptualization I have that I remembered just now: in conversational situations, I often feel like my subconsciousness is a Markov chain / LLM autocomplete, spitting out phrases, and my consciousness is busy judging them, and choosing whether or not to pass them to the actuators (speech organs, or fingers on the keyboard).
The two "models" - the autocomplete and the censor - is something I can clearly see in my mind when I'm processing a problem in a calm manner, or participating in a slow-paced discussion. But I've noticed that the more excited I get (or intoxicated), the weaker the "censor" part is; in the limit (when I'm really excited, angry, or drunk), I feel as if the Markov chain bit is feeding phrases straight to my mouth/fingers, cutting out the middleman of consciousness.
(Of course, what I wrote is all "how the algorithm feels from inside", so it's not very objective or reliable...)
- dools 4y agoI wonder if your being bi-lingual has anything to do with the different ways we experience language (I'm not bi-lingual ... )
- TeMPOraL 4y agoGood question. I recently started to wonder about it myself. In my train of thoughts, I tend to switch between languages on the fly, based on which one feels like it's bringing me closer conceptually and emotionally to the thought I want to express. Or at least I used to, because I only recently realized that, over the last few years, I've mostly switched to thinking in English only. I'm now in a weird state: my native language (Polish) is still easier for me to use, but also using it feels wrong somehow. Often enough, when talking to people around me, I notice I'm translating my own thoughts from English. It might be that this process of learning and internalizing a second language, to the point it eventually took over my first one, is what changed my experience of the thinking process itself.