4 ms·
I trust the math. I trust the manipulator. But it drives home the reason why I parted ways with advanced math. There just came a point when the math no longer
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
I trust the math. I trust the manipulator.
But it drives home the reason why I parted ways with advanced math. There just came a point when the math no longer resonated with the natural world that I was comfortable living in.
Imaginary (and complex) numbers were the first real schism where my mind repelled the very idea.
Nonetheless, decades later, I would be talking with a friend who is much smarter than me. We were talking about the lossy nature of converting audio from the time domain to the frequency domain and back. I understood that phase information was lost in the translation (I also thought it was curious that the human brain seemed to be phase-agnostic and so could not perceive the difference when audio was round-tripped through the frequency domain).
"Oh," he said, "when you do a Fast Fourier transform to move audio into the frequency domain the phase information is represented by the imaginary part of a complex number."
Wait, what? So complex numbers have a real-world analog in constructing an FFT — a "real" algorithm that does real work?
I see now that the really smart people just understand the natural world much better than I do — or perhaps see it differently than I do.
- maxbond 4y agoI think it's less about some people being especially good at math than mathematics education being especially terrible and uninspiring. 3blue1brown's approach to math pedagogy had really changed how I'm able to see math and to understand it's profundity (as someone who didn't get any further than you, it sounds like, in formal math education [I never took calculus in school.]). https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZHQObOWTQDPD3MizzM2xVFitgF8hE_ab https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZHQObOWTQDPD3MizzM2xVFit... This is also a great series of videos about how, like it says on the tin, the imaginary numbers are real: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLiaHhY2iBX9g6KIvZ_703G3KJXapKkNaF https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLiaHhY2iBX9g6KIvZ_703G3KJ...
- skupig 4y agoThe second playlist is great, thank you! As someone with near zero math knowledge, it was very exciting learning that imaginary numbers are a beautiful and intuitive concept. Really makes me want to start playing with frequency domain stuff. Also, the reveal of the mapped video visualization... the whole series is worth watching just for that moment.
- maxbond 4y agoThat's lovely to hear! If you're interested, here are some videos about Fourier analysis: https://youtube.com/watch?v=spUNpyF58BY https://youtube.com/watch?v=spUNpyF58BY https://youtube.com/watch?v=h7apO7q16V0 https://youtube.com/watch?v=h7apO7q16V0
- skupig 4y agoI was hoping one of those links was Reducible! :-) His videos on image encoding are fantastic.
- Y_Y 4y ago(In the following, mathematical uses of terms are given in "quotes".) So many of the names of mathematical objects are arbitrary and I think that can be harmful. "Real" numbers are just as imaginary as "imaginary" ones! They both have use in physics as models for natural phenomena, but neither are real like an atom. You may still argue that "natural" numbers are real because we really can have n of something, but general real numbers can't be written down or computed or used to divide physical space and time as we understand them now. The names are mostly historical artefacts that serve as mnemonics, nothing more.
- wheels 4y agoImaginary numbers are important in a lot of real world applications. One of the most important ones at the moment is in quantum mechanics and quantum algorithms. You can't model quantum algorithms without imaginary numbers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 123pie123 4y agothis help me a little (a lighter easier intro) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUzklzVXJwo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUzklzVXJwo by veritasium
- friendzis 4y ago> Wait, what? So complex numbers have a real-world analog in constructing an FFT — a "real" algorithm that does real work? No. Complex numbers are "simply" neat construct to represent 2D coordinates algebraically - i.e. without matrices.
- maxbond 4y agoComplex numbers behave quite differently than vectors/matrixes, and their discovery wasn't motivated by needing to represent coordinates. They were discovered (or invented, for the nonplatonists) in the process of resolving the paradox that 3rd degree polynomials must have at least 1 (real) root (because they always stretch out in opposite directions, and so cross 0), but you end up needing to square root a negative number to solve for it (the paradox being, this was thought to be impossible, since the square of any real number is positive). Their existence is a natural consequence of the rules of the algebraic operations (addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, powers and logarithms); they aren't incidental, they are integral. Without imaginary numbers, the algebraic operations aren't closed. (This being a brief summary of the thesis of the videos I linked in a sibling comment.) That being said, they are useful as coordinates, as well.
- dvt 4y ago> Imaginary (and complex) numbers were the first real schism where my mind repelled the very idea. If extending the number line bothers you, you should also have a problem with negative numbers. And, in fact, many ancient mathematicians did, so you're in good company :)
- acer4666 4y agoThe problem isn't you! "Imaginary" numbers are terribly named, and I can see why that would put anyone off engaging with them. They are just as "real" as 2d co-ordinates are.
- voldacar 4y agoI suspect that what threw you off was the dumb term 'imaginary', not the idea that the real numbers could have an algebraic closure.
- verteu 4y agoDon't be intimidated! The person who first invented complex numbers called them "useless" and "mental torture."[1] Subsequent mathematicians have simply gotten used to them. You'd invent them, too, if you spent a few weeks building a computer program to output the values of `t` that make `t^3+pt+q=0` (when `4p^3 + 27q^2 < 0`, there are 3 real solutions, but they can't be expressed in general without involving complex numbers).[2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_number#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_number#History [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cubic_equation#Cardano's_formula https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cubic_equation#Cardano's_formu...