5 ms·
Whenever someone sadly hits their personal "last straw" threshold for iPhone, one option to consider is the privacy&security-focused GrapheneOS variant of Andro
by neilv 4y ago
Whenever someone sadly hits their personal "last straw" threshold for iPhone, one option to consider is the privacy&security-focused GrapheneOS variant of Android.
https://grapheneos.org/features https://grapheneos.org/features
You can run GrapheneOS on recent models of Pixel hardware. (It usually has to be a unit purchased from Google, or that otherwise hasn't had OEM-unlocking disabled by the carrier that sold it.)
https://grapheneos.org/faq#device-support https://grapheneos.org/faq#device-support
https://grapheneos.org/install/web#enabling-oem-unlocking https://grapheneos.org/install/web#enabling-oem-unlocking
You might also try minimizing the apps that you depend upon, though GrapheneOS has put work into supporting apps in a bit more private&secure way. There's also the option of the F-Droid app store, if you want to try to avoid commercial apps altogether, but still need things like an OpenStreetMap app.
There were a lot of things I liked about iPhone, but I overall feel more respected by GrapheneOS.
If you end up liking GrapheneOS, and have the means, there's an optional Donate page on their Web site.
- mypgovroom 4y agoThis! I'm very impressed with how well it works and the continued anti-consumer steps iOS and Android make are only driving Graphene's development!
- crossroadsguy 4y agoAs someone who reluctantly moved to iOS from Android and reluctantly stays on iOS there really is no other option for "normal" ("regular"?) users who don't want the Google crap all over their existence. Graphene, Lineage etc are all excellent solutions for people who want to (or "can") get their hands dirty and can live without normal functions of "commercial" apps, for everyone else as of today there is just two option - Apple's iOS or Google blessed Android. I am not even talking about warranty and bricking woes. This is a duopoly as clear as day. We can keep telling ourselves that we have options, we don't. It's settled, at least that is how it is right now (again, maybe except for "tinkerers" which I guess even I was until around a decade ago).
- neilv 4y agoThis doesn't address all your concerns, but for people who want to keep the commercial apps, GrapheneOS now supports that to some degree: https://grapheneos.org/features#sandboxed-google-play https://grapheneos.org/features#sandboxed-google-play
- KingMachiavelli 4y agoI will say GrapheneOS is much more usable than normal custom Android ROMs. Maybe this has changed but IME even Lineage based ROMs, official or otherisez don't have automatic updates the same way stock does. But GrapheneOS and a few similar projects actual have fully automatic updates, for every Android security update and major versions. Once installed which is very easy as long as your are starting fresh, GrapheneOS requires no effort to maintain. F-droid or even the Google Play Store works just fine once configured. The only apps that don't work are major banking apps and snapchat so not a big deal. If you have family/friends that use smartphones but don't really use "Apps" then GrapheneOS is perfectly fine.
- an_aparallel 4y agoI am not 1% as technical as the regular HN contingiency - and i can only say - flashing a pixel 6 pro with graphene was smooth as silk. Just requires some good reading and instruction following skills. Amazing OS...works fast, UI doesnt change whenever it feels like...absolutely the best tech related thing i've done this year. I would have been on it sooner if i wasnt so annoyed about needing to own a Google phone to use it :P
- aembleton 4y ago> The only apps that don't work are major banking apps and snapchat so not a big deal. Its a big deal for me if my banking app doeosn't work.
- crossroadsguy 4y agoMy banking and finance apps are the mandatory apps that I keep on my phone :( These are the kinds of caveats I tried to point to in my comment. That it’s not an option even though it feels like that.
- hackernewds 4y agoOr you know, switch to Android.
- Zuiii 4y agoThank you. I previously relied exclusively on samsung to for phones, tablets, and smartwatches but decided to stop dealing with them after they decided to silently enable sending everything I typed to grammarly in an update. (Literally 2 decades of good will wasted). If the next models remains secure with GrapheneOS, I'll be switching to using pixels exclusively instead. How long does GrapheneOS support pixel devices? A strong clear policy on Security updates was main reason why I stuck with samsung and continued to recommend them for so long despite them becoming more and more abusive.
- madmads 4y agoThere's active support going back to the Pixel 4a with the Pixel 4 being EOL. https://grapheneos.org/faq#device-support https://grapheneos.org/faq#device-support Looking under the next section "Which devices are recommended?" it sounds like support is planned for the full life of newer devices that have 5-year update guarantees.
- emptybits 4y agoAnother vote for GrapheneOS here. I moved away from a great iOS experience to a great GrapheneOS experience nearly two years ago. Pixel 5. Works fantastic. Bonus: I get nearly two full days of battery life between charges, even with heavy use, because my phone is not full of apps and system services chatting away to their motherships all day. I have all the mobile apps I need and enough of the apps I want. (And probably a little more peace and useful disconnection because I'm "missing" some apps that I used to spend time with but I honestly can't tell you what they were or that I actually "miss" them. Ha.) I'm still a happy MacOS desktop user and while I occasionally miss some mobile/desktop automagic syncing that Apple does so well (iMessage, Photos, etc.) I find this split GrapheneOS/MacOS life forces me to smartly use more Signal Messenger and suggest others try it too. And I use the amazing Syncthing on all my devices for mobile/desktop syncing needs like photos and more. Also ... moving away from an iPhone, I moved from Apple Watch to Garmin Fenix and am super happy about that move also. Two weeks of battery life from a watch that's more durable, has physical buttons that I prefer, and is more customizable when I'm feeling nerdy. Garmin's philosophy on user data/privacy seemed to be very good compared to Google, Samsung, and other watches. And they're better built watches and meant for 24/7 hard use. Kudos and donation to the GrapheneOS team. Also, their regular system updates work so smoothly, perfectly, if a little too frequently. Maybe it's not forever, but I did this purely as an experiment with my Apple safety net waiting for me. The iPhone and Apple Watch have depreciated and gathered dust and haven't been touched in nearly two years. Time will tell...
- das-hinterland 4y agoTop posting because there is a lot of mis/false information overwhelming the comments section and this needs to be known. Facts: 1. OP is a customer of Xfinity Mobile - which is a "Wi-Fi first" internet service. Note they don't call it "cellular" because it isn't. 2. Their terms of service are clearly laid out here: https://www.xfinity.com/mobile/policies/broadband-disclosures https://www.xfinity.com/mobile/policies/broadband-disclosure... To quote: "Comcast's Xfinity Mobile broadband Internet access service ("Xfinity Mobile service" or "Service") utilizes Wi-Fi service - both Xfinity WiFi and Wi-Fi provided by other Internet Service Providers ("ISPs"). When not connected to Wi-Fi, the Service utilizes our carrier partner's mobile broadband Internet access service network and is subject to its network management practices and controls." Basically they roam onto cellular when their WiFi is out of range. 3. OP keeps claiming that he never agreed to anything blah blah yes you did. When you sign up for anything with Comcast they make you sign an agreement that you agree to their ToS. See South Park episode "Human CentiPad". 4. The service OP signed up for is at a discounted price because of trade offs. The trade offs are that your device will prefer the Xfinity hotspots over cellular. That's literally how it works. That's why you're getting it for cheaper because the service sucks by design. That's on the customer. 5. People attempting to point these facts out have been getting downvoted which is just sad.
- beckman466 4y agowow they've done it: they've out-exploited an already monsterably ruthless monopoly!
- andreareina 4y agoIt can both be true that OP is getting what they asked for, and that this is a bad thing for Apple to unilaterally allow. How does Apple know that OP signed up to have their preferences ignored?
- das-hinterland 4y agoThis has been going on for years. Not many people know of the deep integration between Apple and the carriers. Your iPhone, when a SIM is inserted, pairs it with a "carrier profile" which is downloaded from Apple's servers. This profile, among other things, has network settings and preferences such as the APN. That's why you need to have the phone connected to the internet to "activate" it; it's part of the provisioning process. These wifi offload networks (along with likely a setting if it can be disabled or not) is likely downloaded as part of that profile. This is reminiscent of those "ad supported" ISPs of yesteryear that people would subscribe to then complain that it has ads.
- r0l1 4y agoMy words! I made the switch to Copperhead / now GrapheneOS 7 years ago and never looked back. Can only recommend this OS and the lead dev is a legend.