6 ms·
America Has Too Much Parking
- jimsimmons 4y agoLaughs in San Francisco
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoSF, NY, Chicago are not at all representative of 99% of America when it comes to parking. Even in these cities, the second you go 30km out to actual suburbs parking is ample and overwrought. That being said it’s not really a groundbreaking or even particularly interesting thing to point out that America has a cultural problem with favoring cars, and that too much parking is a simple consequence of that.
- zoltar 4y ago99% of what? It's nearly 4% of the US population (2021).
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoLand area, since we are talking about things that take up space (parking) and have to take into account that most people in these cities don’t own cars because of adequate (not great) public transportation. It’s more interesting to have this conversation about a city like Dallas or Houston or St Louis or Tulsa, all of whom have absolutely kowtowed to car culture to create negative externalities like what this article is going on about and for which public transportation probably could not easily be described as “adequate” in comparison to the aforementioned cities of NY, SF, Chicago.
- f1yght 4y agoAlmost 10% if you include the metro areas. SF, NY, and Chicago account for a significant portion of how Americans experience the world.
- hot_gril 4y agoYeah, it's not even like parking is the cause of the extra spacing, only the effect. In any city where space is extra valuable, this free parking "problem" quickly goes away.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoYet having a car isn't a problem. America is really big and things you need to do or places you need to go are rarely just down the block. The country is bigger than any one city, and self-transportation is fundamentally essential for our economy.
- f1yght 4y agoAccording to the census, 80.7% of americans live in urban areas. We really should be creating spaces where people don't have to have a car to do the basic necessities. When talking about car dependence, it's about creating viable options that are more sustainable and more equitable for getting where you need to go. Kids, elderly, disabled people all have issues driving and if we create a way for them to get around without a car, it makes the city a better place. The issue isn't cars specifically. The issue is our built environment requires cars. Maybe more things should just be down the block.
- nitwit005 4y agoThe size of America isn't relevant. People aren't driving across five states to get to work or buy groceries. People used to be able to just go down the block here. That's been made illegal many places by zoning.
- circuit 4y ago> America is really big and things you need to do or places you need to go are rarely just down the block The continental United States has about 3.5 million square miles of land. By comparison China has about 3.7 million square miles. Roughly the same, give or take a few. Observe the number of public passenger rail lines that China has and the timeframe in which they were built them. The idea that America is just too geographically big for public rail or any kind of public transportation system and we must be beholden to the car is categorically false.
- renewiltord 4y agoSF has loads of parking. The only place I really worry about is the Mission. Everywhere else parking is abundant.
- michelb 4y agoIt’s probably been one of the most successful lobbies, is it not? Destroying any budget that could have been used on public transport.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoIm glad WSJ is telling us how to live our lives. Whatever would we do without their hand holding.
- circuit 4y agoWe'd do the same regardless of their "hand holding." They just happen to be right on this one.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>They just happen to be right on this one. "When know what we're doing, this is is the way of the future, it's how we will implement our utopia" is what everyone said back in the 50s-70s when they were cooking up single family zoning, parking minimums and all that crap. I'm very bearish on the idea that doing the same exact kind of micromanagement of property development but with a different set of values will generate results that of substantially different net value to society over all.
- smeagull 4y agoWe? I don't remember choosing to build parking lots. Wait a minute... You're trying to tell me how to live my life!
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoYou are free to build your own parking lot, or not. My point is people want to drive to work, run errands, and conduct business. So-called journalists like to play nanny with other people's lives and livelihoods. It is grotesque. It is the same problem that presents with pushing everyone to electric vehicles, electric cooking, and electric heat. We can barely meet the demand now. Add 140,000,000 more electric vehicles and millions of homes and you crash the whole grid. NYC has 4.4MM cars moving through it each day. If only a fraction of them were forced to take the MTA or LIRR on top of existing ridership, then everything grinds to a halt.
- 4y ago
- oxfeed65261 4y agohttps://archive.ph/mavRl https://archive.ph/mavRl
- zzzbra 4y agono kidding.
- black_13 4y ago[dead]
- bruce511 4y agoThing is though, when done well, plentiful parking is a resource best over-supplied. Garages that have 20% empty spaces pretty much all the time ,give me the confidence to rely on them. I plan around it being available (and am happy to pay for it). By contrast if it's full 20% of the time then that feeds me with doubt. I say "done well" because in many cases it's using basement floors and other hidden spaces. Sure the building costs more, but that value is returned in parking fees, and also the improved "dependabilty" of the building. Of course the sprawling open land approach is terrible, lacks imagination, is ugly, impractical in bad weather, and likely what you thought of reading the headline. So on that I agree. Parking, like any architectural feature can be done well, or badly.
- tablespoon 4y ago> Garages that have 20% empty spaces pretty much all the time ,give me the confidence to rely on them. I plan around it being available (and am happy to pay for it). By contrast if it's full 20% of the time then that feeds me with doubt. My impression the that people who complain about "too much parking," actually don't want to you have the "confidence to rely on" parking being available. They want to "feed you with doubt" until you get rid of your car.
- bruce511 4y ago>> They want to "feed you with doubt" until you get rid of your car. I guess if I lived in NY or London I might get rid of the car. But to be honest that's never entered my head here. I need the car to get to work. And yeah, there's parking there. But if there was no parking there, I'd still need car for everything else. I get the point, there are cities where you can work,play, shop, school, all on public transport. Where ironically the streets are full of cars all the time. But alas, I don't live in one of those cities.
- antisthenes 4y ago> I get the point, there are cities where you can work,play, shop, school, all on public transport. Do any of those cities exist in the US (except for NY)?
- LispSporks22 4y agoI love me some empty parking lots for motogymkana
- Gigachad 4y agoIt’s so liberating to visit a city or area which has minimal to no parking or roads. You can get around so freely. Thankfully a lot of places are making massive improvements on this front. My city in Australia has been removing street side parking to replace it with trees and dining spaces. It’s beautiful.
- darkteflon 4y agoOh man, which city? I’m moving back to Aus after almost 20 years away. Any place putting cars last would be top of my list.
- mikhailfranco 4y agoMelbourne https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/push-to-convert-thousands-of-cbd-parking-spots-into-green-space-20221129-p5c265.html https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/push-to-convert-...
- darkteflon 4y agoAll for it, and best of luck, but from decades Living in Melbs I reckon they will struggle to pull that off. Recent shitstorm around bike lane expansion is instructive imo. Those business lobby cats are like something out of Nosferatu.
- Gigachad 4y agoI was talking about Adelaide although I don’t recommend it. The CBD is improving a lot in this regard but the wider state is still full speed ahead on cars. I’ve recently moved to Melbourne and found public transport to be massively better. I just don’t have a point of comparison to what it used to be like, like I have for Adelaide.
- darkteflon 4y agoOh nice, yeah Melbs CBD has always been that way - or at least since the early 90s, which is as far back as my memory of it goes. We spent most of our adolescence in a comparatively car-free utopia and didn’t even appreciate it. There’s a lot more that could be done, of course - in particular, expanded car-free zones in the ex-CBD inner-city suburbs. Go from the CBD down Punt or Sydney Rd, for example, and the sudden change in air quality is pretty telling. Don’t reckon anything on that score will improve within our lifetimes though.
- throwaway22032 4y agoYou may as well say that my house has too much space because there's currently no-one in the front room. I could reduce my CO2 emissions by not having a front room and using shared front rooms like pubs or the library. I'm not going to, though.
- Tangurena2 4y ago> Many municipalities imposed detailed parking requirements for every type of land use. In Los Angeles, for instance, churches must include one spot for every five seats in the pews. Hospitals must have two per bed. Zoning requirements are why so many businesses are "a box in a parking lot". When you see a sign in a restaurant that says "Maximum Occupancy X" - that occupancy limit is set by how many parking spaces they have. "Vertical zoning" is the term used to describe zoning that changes based on height. In "older" cities, you can see photos where the ground floor is a store and the upper floors could be residences. That was killed off in the 50s. Denver came up with an urban zoning called "Main Street" (now called "C-MS" & "E-MS") which is intended to be pedestrian-friendly [0]. The main page for the zoning code is [1]. 0 - https://www.denvergov.org/files/assets/public/community-planning-and-development/documents/zoning/denver-zoning-code/denver_zoning_code_article7_urban_center.pdf https://www.denvergov.org/files/assets/public/community-plan... 1 - https://www.denvergov.org/Government/Agencies-Departments-Offices/Agencies-Departments-Offices-Directory/Community-Planning-and-Development/Denver-Zoning-Code https://www.denvergov.org/Government/Agencies-Departments-Of...
- tablespoon 4y ago> Zoning requirements are why so many businesses are "a box in a parking lot". When you see a sign in a restaurant that says "Maximum Occupancy X" - that occupancy limit is set by how many parking spaces they have. That's completely and totally wrong. Maximum Occupancy is set by fire codes, based on how many exists there are and how quickly people can evacuate in case of fire. https://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2014/08/maximum-occupancy-building-calculated/ https://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2014/08/maximum-occ...
- thegrim33 4y agoHave sources such as this ever once in their history published a good faith article from someone who doesn't share this opinion? As in, publishing the arguments both for and against this issue? Or are they 100% one-sided? Are they even pretending to educate the viewer on such issues? At this point when I see such ridiculously one-sided reporting, to the point where it's basically pure propaganda, I just assume a default opinion of the opposite of what they're promoting. If their ideas were good/correct/right they wouldn't need constant propaganda campaigns to convince people of it.