3 ms·
I feel like the punishment or rehabilitation dichotomy is looking at the wrong question. When your code breaks you don't blame the user. You figure out the pro
by jfengel 4y ago
I feel like the punishment or rehabilitation dichotomy is looking at the wrong question.
When your code breaks you don't blame the user. You figure out the problem was. Why did that guy want to commit this crime? Why was it possible?
As far as I'm concerned we should just let him go, or look at some kind of "restorative justice" program even though it can never begin to repay people. I see zero reason for him, or anyone, to spend time simply rotting. But they point to much bigger issues where jail is no solution at all.
- adam_arthur 4y agoIf there’s no jail there’s more incentive to commit crime, which is also not good. I don’t think the length of the sentence materially alters the incentive structure, but there definitely needs to be repercussions for people who break the law/harm others
- jfengel 4y ago"Jail" is a relatively recent concept, dating only to the 18th century or so. A lot of history existed without jail as a punishment. It was considered the less-barbaric alternative to other punishments. It's still pretty barbaric. And we know it's not much of a deterrent, since the jails are full to bursting. I'm hardly an expert, and the experts disagree on the approach. But I think it's important to reconsider our notion that "jail" is the viable approach.