3 ms·
> and fool everyone in the small town she lived in. As others have pointed out, I think that is absolutely the wrong way to think about this. Yvonne Calment (o
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> and fool everyone in the small town she lived in.
As others have pointed out, I think that is absolutely the wrong way to think about this. Yvonne Calment (or Jeanne) died in 1934. It's quite possible/likely that originally they were only trying to deceive the tax authorities. I also wouldn't discount how the chaos, upheaval and destruction of WWII (Arles was bombed heavily) would have made it easier for Yvonne to more "publicly" impersonate Jeanne in later years.
- neaden 4y agoBut Yvonne's funeral is recorded in contemporary newspapers, saying it was well attended and their was a viewing at the home. There is a death certificate signed by the parish priest and a notary. This swap wouldn't have been simple. And we have all the relevant records from Jeanne's life, none were destroyed in WW2 that I know of.
- tim333 4y agoFrom the Deigin article: >"Curiously, her death certificate was issued on the basis of testimony of a sole witness, a 71-year-old unemployed woman (i.e. not a doctor or nurse) who “saw her dead”
- munchler 4y agoIt doesn't have to be simple. It just has to be more plausible than the alternative. So, which of the following is more likely? a) Jeanne lived for 122 years. b) Jeanne died and Yvonne's friends and neighbors allowed her to take her mother's identity. I'm going with b).
- neaden 4y agoSo literally there is nothing that can be done to convince you then? Your prior is so strong that you are going to deny any evidence because you've decided something cannot happen.
- munchler 4y agoI never said or implied that. A photo of Jeanne shortly after her daughter's death would be very compelling, for example.