4 ms·
> 1. The age gap between Calment and the next oldest person is the strongest evidence. It's very, very hard to ignore this. This is in fact a very weak evidenc
by littlestymaar 4y ago
> 1. The age gap between Calment and the next oldest person is the strongest evidence. It's very, very hard to ignore this.
This is in fact a very weak evidence, that only appears to be a strong one because of a common epistemological mistake, let me explain:
The odds of such an age difference are extremely small according to a certain model of how people age, such a model has proven to be pretty accurate for the majority of the population, but that says nothing about the outliers. For biological entities like humans, one only need a single exceptional mutation or pathology to be a super-human of some sort, not fitting into the model at all. In fact, the tallest man in history is also a statistically impossible outlier, yet there's no doubt about his existence and actual height, he just happened to have a rare condition that caused him to grow up to a disproportionate height. (And if you grabbed a Guinness book of records, you'll find these kinds of things in almost every category related to human anatomy or physiology).
Confusing the models with reality is a very common mistake in the history of science, often committed by people having a math background instead of a physics one, but not only. A very famous example is how French explorer Dumont d'Urville was ridiculed when he described the rogue waves he witnessed in the Indian Ocean, because such a wave would be statically impossible. It turned out that the physical model of waves at the time was just too simplistic, as rogue waves do in fact exist (and AFAIK we're still looking for a proper model explaining the phenomenon entirely).
- philegibbs 4y agoAging does not work like height. There are several biological processes that contribute to aging so one gene mutation would not make someone live longer. We can make people taller by giving them growth hormone. If aging was as simple we would have easy ways to slow aging by now.