Also, even if you take the position that the age gap is so statistically unlikely as to be impossible[1], it tells you nothing about where the error is. It does

Also, even if you take the position that the age gap is so statistically unlikely as to be impossible[1], it tells you nothing about where the error is. It does not imply a swap. A swap is one possibility, but extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and I don't see any credible evidence of a swap having occurred. Isn't it more likely that her age is simply wrong by a few years? [1]Really, in statistics, extraordinarily unlikely is not the same thing as impossible.