2 ms·
I’ve been your proverbial Dr Johnson many times. There are at least even odds that some other reviewer told you to cite me. When appropriate, I try to find fo
by hedora 4y ago
I’ve been your proverbial Dr Johnson many times. There are at least even odds that some other reviewer told you to cite me. When appropriate, I try to find follow on work, or point to a paper I cited that more people should read.
Also, I think people are overestimating how much reviewers care who the authors of the papers they are reviewing are, at least in my field.
For one thing, the papers are often written by a student, so writing style isn’t a great giveaway. Also, the advisor probably appreciates a thoughtful rejection of the crappy student paper. The alternative is getting it accepted, followed by a mad dash by the advisor to copy edit it and add experiments so the work isn’t embarrassing. (Tenure clocks are the main counter example of this, but junior professors aren’t exactly in a position to bully the reviewers!)
People could try to block work that would scoop their ongoing paper, but I don’t really see that happening in practice in my field. Double blind doesn’t help with that, of course.
However, it would pretty rapidly tank that reviewer’s reputation, since the other reviewers would see the bad behavior, and they know each others’ identities.