9 ms·
Wow... I wonder what the Ivies would look like if admissions were 100% merit. No legacies. I think there would be FAR fewer trust-funders. And MIT's 'Chocolat
by bilbo0s 15y ago
Wow... I wonder what the Ivies would look like if admissions were 100% merit.
No legacies. I think there would be FAR fewer trust-funders.
And MIT's 'Chocolate City'...pretty much gone.
I suspect they would be very Asian places with a smattering of Jewish students. I think I can see why they would give ... say ... a Colorado snow boarder a few extra points. I think there is something that he brings to an Ivy campus...though I can't quantify it.
- gte910h 15y ago>I wonder what the Ivies would look like if admissions were 100% merit. The issue is "how do you determine merit".
- geogra4 15y agoRight on. Merit is much more than SAT scores and GPA. It is, in fact, whatever the school wants it to be.
- vecter 15y agoSurely merit does not include race?
- hackinthebochs 15y agoMerit can include a consideration of race. One factor of merit is being an outlier of your group. There are many ways to analyze a given population that reveals different clusters. Being an outlier of this cluster is a factor in merit. The question is, is race a relevant dimension to consider? At face value, the answer is no. But in the US at least, race is a proxy to many other factors that are extremely hard to quantify. These hard to quantify factors are relevant in determining who "deserves" a spot at your prestigious school. Thus a consideration of race within specific contexts can be relevant, college admissions being one of them.
- gte910h 15y agoThat isn't at all what I was saying, but the idea that two IDENTICAL students with nothing other than one being white and the other being asian would require 200 more SAT score points to get in is inaccurate. As a class, the students who applied who happened to be asian are probably lacking in other areas as well if this BIG of a bias is being seen. Perhaps there aren't enough participation in volunteering/jobs/sports. Perhaps there isn't a good relationship in the alumni interviews, who knows. There may STILL be a racial bias on top of that, however I'm guessing not 200 points worth of pure racial bias.
- tesseractive 15y agoPlus, standardized test scores have a significant income bias. Affluent kids get SAT prep and can take the SAT multiple times if they're unsatisfied in their scores. And I don't have any data, but my guess is that there's a negative correlation between how many hours per week that you are employed while attending high school and your GPA. These factors may be part of the consideration when accounting for lower quantitative admissions requirements for black and hispanic applicants, and those from lower income brackets in general.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoStudies which aren't funded by Kaplan tend to show a minimal effect due to test prep. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124278685697537839.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124278685697537839.html Also, bringing up income when defending racial preferences is disingenuous. If colleges wanted to discriminate by income, they would. Fun fact: income is not the cause of racial gaps in educational performance. It plays a role, but the gap exists even holding income constant. http://www.umich.edu/~rdytolrn/pathwaysconference/presentations/craig.pdf http://www.umich.edu/~rdytolrn/pathwaysconference/presentati... http://www.jstor.org/pss/2963200 http://www.jstor.org/pss/2963200
- bilbo0s 15y agoYou're correct. Precision is important. It would have been more accurate to say "...100% academic merit..." The material point is the same though, I really can see where the hypothetical snowboarder might have something to offer the Ivy community even if there are others more qualified academically. But again...I can't attach a number of points to that. I don't know what that number would be. To the issue...I do think there should be more taken into account than just academics. I just can't think of a way to take those things into account AND be fair.
- gte910h 15y agoThat's the thing, you do it as best you can and get sued when you can convince people you probably didn't. Sometimes fairness is less important than not missing out.
- chernevik 15y agoIt occurs to me that a place like Harvard could be as interested in what a class will look like at its 25th reunion as anything else.
- yangez 15y agoEasy. Take "ethnicity" out of the application and blot out the applicant's last name when evaluating applications.
- byrneseyeview 15y agoExtracurriculars are another dog-whistle for that sort of thing. A heuristic like "Deduct 150 SAT points for violin or piano" would be pretty predictive.
- misterbwong 15y agoWhile this is true, I don't see why this can used as justification to keep name and ethnicity showing. There will always be ways to guess an applicant's ethnicity but since it (supposedly) has no bearing on admissions, why keep it in the application?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNot once it becomes known - I imagine Amy Chua types would stop forcing their kids to learn it, and applicants would stop mentioning it on applications (unless they are applying to Juilliard).
- maxklein 15y agoWhat about if they made merit not just where you are, but rather how much you have achieved?
- jamesaguilar 15y agoAnd there's also the question of how meritorious high marks in classes and nominal positions of leadership in common high school organizations are. If everyone can do it, it's not exceptional.
- nodemaker 15y agoAgreed. College is a place where students learn far more things than can be learned in classes or even books. In terms of teaching students to live in the real world, the value of racial and economic diversity in the student population of a college is often underrated. EDIT: Given both downvotes and upvotes, I guess what I have said is controversial. For the record I am south-asian myself .
- CWuestefeld 15y agothe value of racial and economic diversity in the student population of a college is often underrated. Then why are colleges fighting for the right to discriminate on race alone (I've seen nothing suggesting that they're looking for economic diversity)? The claim is that a multiracial student body enriches the educational experience, and there's truth to that. But having representatives of many races actually does little. Having a wife of a different race, I think I'm qualified to claim that racial differences make up the smallest of differences between people. Far more important, in real life as well as outlook on the world, are factors such as religion, urban/rural living, size of family, and more. I don't see schools concerned about the portion of the student population of Buddhists relative to Catholics, or that there are enough kids who grew up on farms. So long as they are pursuing only racial diversity, I think that their claims about the value of diversity are a sham.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- newbusox 15y agoThat's not quite true. From personal experience at two different Ivy Leagues schools, I can say that these schools and probably top schools in general are completely obsessive about fulfilling certain stated or unstated "requirements" for students. Yale, for example, where I went for undergrad, prides itself in having students from all 50 states--I can pretty confidently say that, if you're from a state with a smaller population, or simply a smaller number of people who are interested in attending a school far away, your chances of admission are substantially higher (think Montana versus New York). As others have pointed out, although admissions is need-blind (it is not relevant whether you're rich or poor), I'm sure that socio-economic factors are also evident from where the student went to school, recommendation letters, information about parents and their professions/education (which are often asked on applications), and so on. So, while race may be the most obvious "discrimination" point, this is really, in my experience, not the case. And given these multifactored assessments, it is enormously difficult to "prove" that schools are discriminating based on race: it is NOT the case that the school gives everyone a number, and then increases or decreases that number based on your race, wealth, etc.: compare Gratz v. Bollinger (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gratz_v._Bollinger http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gratz_v._Bollinger) (point allocation system where underrepresented minorities received more "points" on their application illegal) with Grutter v. Bolilnger (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grutter_v._Bollinger http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grutter_v._Bollinger) (less-rigid race-based affirmative action permissible).
- robrenaud 15y agoI'd guess it would look a lot like Caltech. http://www.mindingthecampus.com/originals/2010/12/why_caltech_is_in_a_class_by_i.html http://www.mindingthecampus.com/originals/2010/12/why_caltec... > A combined SAT score of 1470 (the 99th percentile by national standards) placed an entering Caltech freshman at only the 25th percentile among his fellow students. (At Harvard and Princeton, by contrast, the 25th percentile is reached by a score of only 1380) > Only 4 percent of the U.S. population, Asians made up a whopping 40 percent of the incoming freshmen class in 2008, a slightly larger proportion than the 39 percent figure for whites.
- herge 15y agoIf an average Caltech graduate has a higher SAT score than an average Harvard/MIT grad, does that translate to success later on in life? For example, are there proportionally more Google employees from Caltech or more startups in YCombinator with Caltech graduates?
- robrenaud 15y agoHow do you measure success in life? I'd bet P[At Google | Caltech degree] is greater than P[At Google | Princeton degree], but it's mostly explained by P[interested in CS | Caltech degree] >> P[interested in CS | Princeton Degree].
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- meow 15y agofrom the article: "The fact that 17 of its student alumni and 14 of its faculty have gone on to win Nobel Prizes, and six of its alumni have won the prestigious Turing Award in computer science, surely says something about the institution and what it stands for. Despite its small size, Caltech was chosen by NASA to be the center for its Jet Propulsion Laboratory, and in the past was a major venue for visiting scholars of the rank of Heisenberg, Einstein, Lorentz, and Bohr. In more recent times its undergraduate alumni have gone on to be founders or co-founders of such leading-edge American companies as Intel, TRW, Compaq, and Exploratorium."
- wyclif 15y agoFor purposes of admission, Filipinos are far better off checking the "Hispanic" box than the "Asian" box.
- kenamarit 15y agoHere's a parallel situation at the high school level. At Stuyvesant High School here in NYC admissions is 100% test base, meaning the only criteria for acceptance is your test score. Here's a quote about their acceptance policy (from an article called "Paper Tigers" in NY Mag last year): "Entrance to Stuyvesant, one of the most competitive public high schools in the country, is determined solely by performance on a test: The top 3.7 percent of all New York City students who take the Specialized High Schools Admissions Test hoping to go to Stuyvesant are accepted. There are no set-asides for the underprivileged or, conversely, for alumni or other privileged groups. There is no formula to encourage “diversity” or any nebulous concept of “well-roundedness” or “character.” Here we have something like pure meritocracy. This is what it looks like: Asian-Americans, who make up 12.6 percent of New York City, make up 72 percent of the high school." Not sure if this article ever made Hacker News, but it's worth reading if you have a chance. It's long-winded, but being Asian-American myself there's a sort of poetic-truth to it: http://nymag.com/news/features/asian-americans-2011-5/ http://nymag.com/news/features/asian-americans-2011-5/
- balloot 15y agoThat's a great article. The same situation has developed here in San Francisco, where the magnet public high school that admits based solely on test scores is Asian by a large majority. The problem is, in the drive to get perfect grades and test scores, the drive for knowledge and life skills is lost somewhere along the way. And in the end, many asian students simply never get the skills needed to actually create things or execute at a job that doesn't have very rigid guidelines. I think the larger picture issue is optimizing for grades and tests does not optimize for achieving in the real world. And elite colleges in the US have acknowleged that, and brought in the use of subjective factors. And while that may be an imperfect system, it is less imperfect than choosing solely on scores and grades.