5 ms·
System76 Open Firmware
- purpleidea 4y agoWe want this in LVFS. https://fwupd.org/ https://fwupd.org/
- mistrial9 4y agook - if it tells the owner what it is doing, and what is inside right? oh and the owner can turn it off too ?
- its-summertime 4y agohttps://github.com/system76/firmware-open/issues/289#issuecomment-1025850692 https://github.com/system76/firmware-open/issues/289#issueco...
- amir734jj 4y agoSo this means I should buy my next laptop from this list if I want a proper Linux support.
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> LVFS > Linux Vendor Firmware Service https://fwupd.org/ https://fwupd.org/ had not heard of it, for anybody else
- da768 4y agoThat's the easiest way to maintain firmware for docking stations, SSDs, laptops, mouse dongles, etc.
- cm_silva 4y agoSome Linux distributions, like Fedora Workstation, will use LVFS to update firmware. It's one of the default repositories.
- circularfoyers 4y agoIt's not a small effort, there's quite a lot Lenovo and Dell firmware on there.
- hackerfactor1 4y agoI have been so incredibly impressed by System76. Professional, easy to work with, open source, and great quality. I used to run a Dell-only shop, but my last few systems have been System76. (Oh, and they don't spam you ever few months like Dell.) Not a paid advertiser. Just a very happy customer.
- piloto_ciego 4y agoBought a meerkat mini last year - I freaking love it. System76 is amazing and I thoroughly am happy with my purchase.
- brightball 4y agoThose little Meerkat's are great. I have one too as my desktop.
- thesuperbigfrog 4y agoBought a Meerkat in 2015 and it is still running great.
- amir734jj 4y agoThe same. I had a great experience with them + PopOS is great.
- Ologn 4y agoHave bought from System76 for years, got a Thelio desktop a year and a half ago that I have been happy with (I run Ubuntu, not PopOS). My Nvidia card only has 12 gigs VRAM but I have had it grinding away on Stable Diffusion, LLAMA etc.
- kdamica 4y agoLove the company, but I wouldn’t buy another one of their laptops.
- genuine_smiles 4y agoWhy?
- sneak 4y agoMore context would be helpful. Are the model identifiers listed in the README the current top-spec machines, or older ones, or discontinued? What does "open firmware" mean in this context? Is it possible to boot these machines free of proprietary blobs entirely? I was under the impression that's not strictly possible given that the Intel ME needs at least the minimal/neuter/HA firmware blob to not forcibly power off the system shortly after boot.
- doener 4y ago"System76 Open Firmware consists of multiple projects under different licenses. [...] Intel CSME Proprietary Intel FSP Proprietary Intel microcode Proprietary" https://github.com/system76/firmware-open/blob/master/LICENSE.md https://github.com/system76/firmware-open/blob/master/LICENS...
- mattanimation 4y agoSystem76 and Framework should merge, then we can have the best of the best
- rolandog 4y agoAdd the privacy protections of Purism, and I'm sold! I'm looking to buy another laptop in the near future, and I'm torn between the offers put forward by those companies. Openness, Modularity, Privacy... choose two?
- cbsmith 4y agoI think it's great that they're competing with each other.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoIs the market they are in big enough for that? by the way, your username makes me think of https://www.broward.org/Parks/Pages/park.aspx?park=5 https://www.broward.org/Parks/Pages/park.aspx?park=5
- teawrecks 4y agoThat is a worry I have, but on the other hand, more pro RTR brands out there is more opportunities to win over customers. I had a galago ultrapro 10 years ago. Loved it, loved system 76's support for it (they shipped everyone a replacement keyboard at no cost simply because they weren't happy with the one it launched with). The only part I didn't like was the plastic body which saw a lot of wear and tear. But the laptop is still working fine. Now I have a framework. The first touchpad on mine had issues. Wasn't registering clicks unless I pressed really hard. They shipped me a replacement, I swapped it out myself and shipped them back the defective one at no cost to me. I wish both companies the best, but yeah I do hope there is enough business out there for them both.
- poink 4y agoI think the market is plenty big enough, because I suspect Framework will sell a lot of their upcoming 16" laptops to Windows gamers.
- felixg3 4y agoI immediately thought about Open Firmware as the bios competitor in SPARC and PowerPC. It’s been a few years since I’ve used it, the last time was trying to boot from USB on a 2005 iMac G5.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eschaton 4y agoI wouldn’t really call IEEE-1275 Open Firmware a “BIOS competitor” so much as an actual attempt to standardize firmware. By all rights, EFI, UEFI, and all the various random boot loaders shouldn’t exist because a manufacturer can just leverage one of a number of independent, interoperable implementations of the standard and support booting arbitrary software on their systems. Despite not being large and quite well-designed, about the only thing that’s survived from IEEE-1275 into the modern era has been the “device tree” concept. But that can still change! There are Open Source implementations of Open Firmware these days, they’re rather straightforward to bootstrap, and since so much of the higher levels are implemented in FORTH and the lower levels in platform-independent C, you get a lot of bang for the buck in adopting it, including things like booting from an arbitrary IP network or arbitrary local storage, using an arbitrary text or graphics device for output, and using arbitrary devices for input. All it needs is a set of straightforward drivers for the local hardware, since it doesn’t need to be super-fast.
- ahoya 4y agoCatching up with Star Labs which has had monthly firmware updates for my 12th gen intel for some time through fwupd
- steponlego 4y agoAw dang I thought they were using OpenFirmware.
- doublepg23 4y agoI wonder if you could make an OpenFirmware esque payload for Coreboot, though booting linux directly is probably good enough.
- pgeorgi 4y agoOpenBIOS (www.openbios.org) is an OF1275 implementation that can be built as a coreboot payload (or it used to be possible, at least). There's a certain historical overlap between the teams (some OpenBIOS folks moved to LinuxBIOS, which became coreboot), so that kinda makes sense.
- neilv 4y agoI just learned that System76 will sell me a 2U server with x8 A100 units.
- geraldhh 4y agomight be encouraging or depressing news, depending on what a 'A100' unit is.
- DSingularity 4y agoMy system 76 Wi-Fi card is bad. Get random application level failures when checking out repos that appear as if they are in the app stack but disappear the second Ethernet is used. Other than that inconvenience the machine has been perfect.
- lionelholt 4y agoDid you contact System 76 support? In my experience they've been fantastic.
- orsenthil 4y agoI ended up buying a second hand Evoo Gaming Laptop, with like 12 CPU 16 GB Ram, Nvidia GPU. It cost me around 800 dollars. I installed PopOS and I like the performance and convenience of this machine.
- zxcvgm 4y agoI'm impressed to see this paragraph in the README: > System76 customers may request board schematics for their system by sending an email to firmware@system76.com with the subject line "Schematics for model", where model is one of the supported models listed above. > Please include the serial number of your system for verification. This means that you can actually troubleshoot and repair the board yourself, if you're so inclined.
- jraph 4y agoThis is neat. Why do they not provide the schematics for everyone though?
- justaj 4y agoAFAIK same as Framework: It has to do with NDAs.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoThat's awesome. I've emailed other manufacturers asking for documentation and the best I got was an unrelated user help page. If I remember correctly, some of their laptops are based on Clevo parts. I wonder why they can release documentation but Clevo can't.