4 ms·
I've seen it multiple times; the sole company/developer often considers the software "their baby" and doesn't want to "let it go" for a number of potentially qu
by bombcar 4y ago
I've seen it multiple times; the sole company/developer often considers the software "their baby" and doesn't want to "let it go" for a number of potentially quite valid reasons, such as fear of loss of livelihood, disagreement with others on the direction, etc.
Tarn Adams has a similar situation with DF. But hopefully they realize that at least having some sort of 'make available on death' could be valuable.
We have already lost untold countless relatively custom software packages for niche markets that you've never heard of - and people just continue or go back to doing things by hand.
- alpaca128 4y agoLast I heard Tarn Adams is considering open-sourcing at least parts of it in the long term now that they are more financially independent. The Steam launch was probably the best case scenario for both developer and community.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoYeah, and part of me wishes they did this years ago, but at the same time I can understand they wanted to keep it small on purpose; once you go public like on Steam, the dynamics change and you can't just bury your nose in code all day but you have to deal with finances, refunds, reviews, legalese, etc as well.
- RajT88 4y agoSoftware escrow exists for this reason. I was honestly surprised when I discovered it existed when a customer demanded it.
- spydum 4y agoYup, NCC group, of all people owns a big software escrow service they recently acquired from Iron Mountain.
- Arch-TK 4y agoNCC has been doing escrow for a very long time before the Iron Mountain acquisition.
- kjellsbells 4y agoDoes escrow really work though? If the author of this software had placed a copy in escrow 25 years ago it is not clear to me that it would much use if the customer pulled it out in 2023 and tried to get it working. Access to the source, sure, but recreating the build chain on modern systems is not guaranteed to work at all. If someone told me they had escrowed 1998 vintage code and it was all mine to tinker with I would expect to find a CD with the release binaries, and a fat lump of a Visual SourceSafe database that expected NT4, some ancient C compiler (or worse, some VB5 runtime and a plethora of random DLLs) and who knows what level of deep magic to resurrect. And thats assuming I could even find hardware to run the OS of the build machine. Lord help you if there any kind of copy protection dongle nonsense going on, as was popular back then.
- Arch-TK 4y agoI don't work in that department so I can't tell you the exact process, but this is how it was explained to me: The goal of escrow is to have people not only understand the toolchain and ensure that they can get it working at the time when the software is put into escrow and then document it, but to also periodically pull it out of the archives and verify it can still be built. As part of escrow, steps are taken to ensure that any additional necessary software and hardware is kept to support this. That's what you're paying for with something like NCC's escrow service. If you want I can actually just ask my colleagues tomorrow.
- htrp 4y agoPlease do this actually sounds fascinating. What are the pretections against cheating the audit process? Do you specify a frequency for validations? What type of pricing model does the service use? How long can you escrow something?
- andybak 4y agoDF=Dwarf Fortress Please type things out in full so other people don't have to use a search engine just to follow along.
- Woberto 4y agoiykyk
- aew4ytasghe5 4y ago[flagged]
- praptak 4y agoTarn Adams has this base covered: https://www.vice.com/en/article/xyjam3/what-will-happen-to-gamings-most-ambitious-experiment-when-its-creators-die https://www.vice.com/en/article/xyjam3/what-will-happen-to-g...