4 ms·
I'm not sure how a tool to read some text and display a diagram of the chemical reaction described falls under the "law" of the quoted passage. Copyright law c
by jrockway 15y ago
I'm not sure how a tool to read some text and display a diagram of the chemical reaction described falls under the "law" of the quoted passage. Copyright law certainly allows for this, so all the journals can do is say, "you don't get to buy our feed anymore if you run your program on our articles," but surely this is a game of chicken because no company wants to lose tens of thousands of dollars a year for no reason.
I would implement this as a browser plugin that uploads the content to a server (like Google Translate), and let the journals deal with each rogue user individually.
Telling people what software they can use to read text doesn't scale.
- michael_dorfman 15y agoWhat would happen if you actually did try to textmine it. surely this is a game of chicken because no company wants to lose tens of thousands of dollars a year for no reason. Elsevier is willing to play this game of chicken; they are convinced that their customers (i.e., research universities) cannot do without their product. Hence the OP reporting that twice, they instantly and without warning cut off all access to their product to the entire university, because of detected scraping. Telling people what software they can use to read text doesn't scale. Unfortunately, I think it does. If individual users, even a large number of them, use a plug-in, they might get away with it-- but this would result in an incomplete data set. To systematically textmine the corpus (which is the task at hand) requires some kind of systematic access to the data, and this is where Elsevier steps in and shuts it down.
- jrockway 15y agoPossibility number two is to break in to a router closet at MIT to do the scraping :)
- stfu 15y agoWhat actually happen with that guy? I remember all the mainstream media stories what kind of a bad ass hacker he was, but somewhat never caught up with the "happy end".
- dangrossman 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz#JSTOR http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz#JSTOR
- jrockway 15y agoNot really a bad ending. The feds have no case against him, MIT and JSTOR aren't going to sue him, and JSTOR decided that releasing their archive was a good idea. Hopefully the FBI will drop their case.
- dangrossman 15y ago35 years in prison would be a pretty bad ending, and he's still being prosecuted for that.
- jrockway 15y ago35 years in prison is what you would get in federal court for walking across the street as the light was changing from yellow to red. It is there to give the government a better position to offer a plea agreement. It is highly unlikely that he would be convicted of every count, and even if he was, it is highly unlikely that he would receive the maximum sentence for each count. But, 35 years is scary, and if I were in his shoes and the government said "pay a $100,000 fine", I'd probably agree without much argument. And that's exactly the point of saying he faces "up to" 35 years.
- dredmorbius 15y agoFirst: it's very difficult to grok copyright issues from a one-sided, non-legal presentation. Settled case law means going to trial and often going through multiple appeals. Second: as it stands, this looks more to be a contractual than copyright matter (Elsevier is contractually banning use of automated text processing by subscribers), though it might possibly attempt to put teeth into this by asserting copyright. The remedy sought by Elsevier would be not to allege infringement, but to cancel future subscriptions. It might be nice for, say, a large collection of institutions to call Elsevier's bluff. Third: Copyright law as it exists (and particularly in the US where I understand it reasonably well) is very mechanical: it governs the making of copies of an expressive work. Copyright does NOT govern facts, it does not apply to works which are not expressive, it does not apply to works which are functional in nature. The real test here would be to put this (and possibly other) contract claims to test in a court. Unfortunately, contracts are governed (in the US) under state, not federal law, and while there's some uniformity of language, it would probably take several such cases (and appeals to at least the Federal Circuit) to establish reasonable case law. Otherwise, what's significant about this to me is that, once again, it's a case far less about the availability and copying of information (journal articles are routinely copied), than it is about power and control within an information market. This is an area in which conventional economics is far too often lacking (though it's also an area in which much interesting work is starting to happen).